• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Bolivia's richest province seeks autonomy, raising fear of political crisis

Mike Baker

Army.ca Veteran
Inactive
Reaction score
1
Points
430
LINK

SANTA CRUZ DE LA SIERRA , Bolivia — This divided country faces a constitutional crisis Sunday when its richest and second most-populous province votes whether to declare itself autonomous from President Evo Morales's national government, a referendum the president has called illegal.

If the referendum passes, as polls show it overwhelmingly will, leaders of Santa Cruz province say they'll elect a state legislature, organize local police and otherwise set up a government equivalent to that of a U.S. state.

Morales has called the referendum a move to split up this nation of 9.1 million and to thwart his government's efforts to rewrite Bolivia's constitution so that its indigenous majority wins more political power. Bolivia has a centralized government, where police, taxation and other government functions are controlled by federal officials.

"This referendum violates the current constitution, because there's no mechanism to convoke it," said Leonida Zurita , a close Morales ally and a substitute senator with the president's Movement to Socialism party. "They want to found a second Bolivian state, and we won't let the fatherland be divided."

Morales, a leftist critic of U.S. policies in the region, has received the support of Venezuela , Cuba , Ecuador and Nicaragua in the provincial-autonomy fight. The Bolivian president also has accused the United States of backing the autonomy move, a charge U.S. officials have rejected.

Autonomy advocates, including Santa Cruz business leaders, denied that they wanted to secede and insisted that their goal is modernizing an overly centralized government. Three other eastern Bolivian provinces, Beni, Pando and Tarija, also are planning to hold autonomy votes in coming weeks, and leaders in two others, Cochabamba and Chuquisaca, are also advocating autonomy. Only three provinces have resisted the idea.

"We're seeing a social process that's happening all over this country," said Eduardo Paz , president of Santa Cruz's chamber of commerce. "After Sunday, the people will have sent the message that they want to do things in a new way."

Both Morales and autonomy advocates have called for calm Sunday and cancelled potentially incendiary actions by both autonomy supporters and the president's indigenous activists. This week, the government prohibited civilians from carrying arms, and Morales has pledged not to send troops to Santa Cruz to block the referendum vote.

On Wednesday, the Organization of American States sent Political Affairs Secretary Dante Caputo to Bolivia to initiate last-minute dialogue between the two sides, but he left with only pledges to keep the public peace.

The OAS held its second meeting in less than a week on Friday to discuss the crisis in Bolivia . After Caputo briefed ambassadors, Bolivian Foreign Minister David Choquehuanca gave a hard-hitting speech, blaming the governors for failure to hold a dialogue before the referendum and insisting that the referendum was illegal and risked breaking up the country. OAS Secretary-General Jose Miguel Insulza warned that violence could break out and "could last a long time.''

On the streets of Santa Cruz Wednesday night, thousands of people attended a pro-autonomy demonstration, with several saying they were ready to defend the referendum with force if necessary.

"I voted for Morales two years ago because I had great hopes for Bolivia ," said student Jose Sanabria . "Now, I think he doesn't do things the right way. He acts against Santa Cruz and against autonomies."

At the heart of the conflict is a July 2006 referendum in which Bolivians nationwide rejected allowing provincial autonomies, while voters in the four provinces now pushing referendums approved the proposal.

Those provincial leaders have said that the vote lets them pursue their separate paths despite the national rejection, while federal officials insist that only a national approval allows for provincial autonomy.

Santa Cruz leaders have long demanded more independence from Bolivia's federal government and complained that the province surrenders millions of dollars in tax revenue without getting enough back in government support.

The province, which sprawls over the country's eastern flatlands and produces natural gas, soybeans and other exports, is responsible for about 30 percent of Bolivia's gross domestic product while making up about a quarter of the country's population. The province's population is also less indigenous than that of the country's mountainous west.

Since Morales became the country's first indigenous president in 2006, Santa Cruz leaders have slammed government plans to redistribute farmland and seize more state control over natural gas and other industries. On Thursday, Morales announced that he'd nationalize the country's main telecommunications company, Entel, which is half-owned by Telecom Italia , and reclaim control of four foreign-owned natural gas companies.

Political scientist Fernando Mayorga said that despite the tensions, both sides would have to negotiate after the referendum because "they can't maintain this political tension for much longer."

The goal, Mayorga said, would be fitting regional autonomies into a draft constitution that Morales allies hurriedly approved in December, without the presence of most opposition representatives.

That constitution would allow Morales to be re-elected once, claim more state control over natural resources and grant autonomy to indigenous communities and cities, among other actions.

Morales' congressional allies had originally scheduled a national referendum also for this Sunday on the draft constitution, but cancelled it after the country's top electoral court said the vote couldn't be adequately organized in time. The president's activist allies had surrounded the national legislature in February and blocked opposition legislators from voting on the referendum date.

The electoral court also has declared the Santa Cruz referendum illegal, saying only the national legislature could schedule such votes, and announced it won't certify Sunday's results.

"The Santa Cruz leaders know the autonomy statute can't be implemented where there is no constitutional framework," Mayorga said. "And both sides know they can't resolve this outside of political negotiations. The fact is they're both too weak to defeat each other, so they have to work together eventually."

(Special correspondent Heger reported from Santa Cruz de la Sierra , Bolivia . Chang reported from Rio de Janeiro, Brazil .)
 
Morales is a marxist and is dragging the country in a direction that many dont want to go.One can hope that this move will begin Morales' downfall. We dont need an AQ penetration of Latin America sponsored by Hugo.
The US would be doing the people of Venezuela and the region a favor by dropping a JDAM on Hugo's bedroom.
 
decoy said:
So what if he is a Marxist? The vast majority of Bolivians support Morales and VOTED FOR HIM in a DEMOCRACY. It's the mixed/light skinned European elite MINORITY that don't support him. Morales was democratically elected by the indigenous people of Bolivia...why would you advocate anti-democratic forces breaking up the only chance the indigenous majority have had to have their voices heard? Bolivia has been dragged down by decades of structural adjustment programs...Morales is the voice of the indigenous poor that make up most of Bolivia's population...

So then you agree with his policy with regards to the "Cocaleros"?

Interesting, what are your thoughts on the Taliban and the Poppy harvest?

Dileas

Tess
 
The vast majority of Bolivians support Morales and VOTED FOR HIM in a DEMOCRACY. It's the mixed/light skinned European elite MINORITY...

Then why are 4 provinces, including one that makes up a quarter of the population trying to gain autonomy?

Autonomy advocates, including Santa Cruz business leaders, denied that they wanted to secede and insisted that their goal is modernizing an overly centralized government. Three other eastern Bolivian provinces, Beni, Pando and Tarija, also are planning to hold autonomy votes in coming weeks, and leaders in two others, Cochabamba and Chuquisaca, are also advocating autonomy. Only three provinces have resisted the idea.
 
decoy said:
The populations in these provinces are diverse, and there's nothing in this article that gives a disaggregated breakdown of who is actually supporting the push for autonomy. Also, Pando and Beni do not produce natural gas, but have interests tied to Tarija and Santa Cruz, as pipelines pass through P&B and they gain transfers from those pipes. Santa Cruz department is not a monolith either, even if it does contain 1/4 of Bolivia's pop...there is a great divide between the urban and rural populations. Most of the autonomous movement is centred in Santa Cruz de la Sierra, the capital of Santa Cruz (and the richest in Bolivia) - and not surprisingly, this is the wealthiest and whitest area. The REST of Santa Cruz department (i.e. the rural outlying areas) is populated by Guarani and Aymara indigenous peoples that do not participate in the autonomous movement. The Guarani peoples of the Tarija province are also largely marginalized from the autonomy debate.

Also, the previous government under Carlos Mesa bowed to Santa Cruz’s demand for a referendum on autonomy. However, in October 2005, when the national referendum was held, it was overwhelmingly defeated, as was a second referendum in July of 2006.

It's a complicated issue....

You never answered
decoy said:
The populations in these provinces are diverse, and there's nothing in this article that gives a disaggregated breakdown of who is actually supporting the push for autonomy. Also, Pando and Beni do not produce natural gas, but have interests tied to Tarija and Santa Cruz, as pipelines pass through P&B and they gain transfers from those pipes. Santa Cruz department is not a monolith either, even if it does contain 1/4 of Bolivia's pop...there is a great divide between the urban and rural populations. Most of the autonomous movement is centred in Santa Cruz de la Sierra, the capital of Santa Cruz (and the richest in Bolivia) - and not surprisingly, this is the wealthiest and whitest area. The REST of Santa Cruz department (i.e. the rural outlying areas) is populated by Guarani and Aymara indigenous peoples that do not participate in the autonomous movement. The Guarani peoples of the Tarija province are also largely marginalized from the autonomy debate.

Also, the previous government under Carlos Mesa bowed to Santa Cruz’s demand for a referendum on autonomy. However, in October 2005, when the national referendum was held, it was overwhelmingly defeated, as was a second referendum in July of 2006.

It's a complicated issue....

I still await your answer with regards to Morales being the leader of the Cocaleros, and the relevent comparison to the crops in the taliban held regions of Afghanistan.

What is the difference?

dileas

tess
 
Two more states in Bolivia vote for autonomy

LA PAZ, Bolivia (CNN) -- People in two Bolivian states celebrated what they viewed as a victory Sunday night in referendums on autonomy from the central government.

The autonomy measure passed with 89 percent of the vote in the state of Beni and 85 percent of the vote in the state of Pando, according to initial exit polls.

The two popular referendums come a month after voters in the state of Santa Cruz also cast ballots in favor of autonomy. The votes highlight a dispute between the central government of President Evo Morales -- the country's first indigenous president -- and several eastern states that are rich in oil and gas reserves.

The tension also has underscored divisions between the largely poor Indians, who make up the majority and live in Bolivian's mountainous west, and the richer inhabitants -- largely of European descent -- of the eastern lowlands. Residents of eastern states have opposed the leftist president's policies on land reform and energy nationalization and his plans for a new constitution.

People sympathetic to the national government burned ballot boxes and blocked routes to some polling places in rural areas Sunday.

Ernesto Suarez, governor of Beni, said Sunday that the results sent a clear signal.

"The government has to listen to the people," he said.

The Bolivian government, however, said the vote was illegal and unconstitutional.

"There is no possibility -- none -- of recognizing these votes," said presidential aide Juan Ramon de la Quintana. He said "there is no possibility of recognizing something that does not have any legal basis."

The government also argued that the referendums are contrary to the concept of national unity. It has contended that genuine autonomy is possible but that the eastern states want to go beyond that to create what would amount to something akin to countries within a country.

Meanwhile, Morales has scheduled a nationwide vote of confidence on his rule for August 10. He predicts it will give him a new mandate and strengthen his hand against the autonomy movements.

"Personally, I have no fear of the people," he told reporters in La Paz recently. "The people should say the truth about their authorities. This is another way for the people to judge their elected officials."
 
Back
Top