KevinB,
nice camobats... what do you have to say about the Cyre combats?
as to other commments...
I guess it's all personnal preference when it comes to chest rigs. I looked at the HSGI chest rigs, pretty interesting design.
Chest rigs are handy if your in and out of a vehical as one poster said. small packs (or for that matter any size pack) are a bitch getting on and off each time your in and out.
Modular is the way to go, having one dedicated set of load bearing gear for each role (rifelman, 249, etc) is a supply nightmare. I like the modulare stuff better to adapt to each members needs.
for a standard foot-borne infantry, espeically one that has to yomp long distances with larger loads then I chest chest rigs loss some advantage, but you can adapt.
to me the Canadian TV missed thge boat, not enough capacity, as I'm sure you all will agree. The JTF-2 Patrol Vest is more what's needed in my opinion, or something better...
One of my pet peeves about chest rigs, espcially ones that hold everythng but a bathtub is... well it makes it so much harder to get close to the ground... am I the only one that just can't seem to get close enough (low enough) when people are shooting at ya? ;D Chest rigs do make it harder to oad, etc if your prone... but that's just me... you have to roll up on one side or the other to grab a mag... something to think about...
Personnaly I think they (the powers to be) should issue and have people train with both chest rigs and the more standard LB gear, become comfortable using both.
One soluthion the IDF uses is a small lightweight nylon pack that's attached to the webbing (not the smaller fanny pack). if carrying a radio, larger pack, etc, the attached one is light enough to compress down and not interfer and doesn't need to be removed. if empty it doesn't bug one sitting in a vehical. These work nice to carry rain gear, etc. The older C-7 Assualt vest had the same idea, just in canvas and not quite as large as the IDF version.
Again it comes down to personaly preference when your free to pick, if you don't get a choice, well you'd better learn to use what you got on hard.