• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Getting a Promotion

Verge1993

Jr. Member
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Do Reservist Rank up faster then RegF members?

I had a friend who completed his Reserve BMQ in March of 2009. Year and half later he got his Cpl. Then when he went to Virginia in 2012 on a tasking and he got promoted to MCpl. Is in normal to get to MCpl is just 3 years or is this just a Reserve thing?
 

Fishbone Jones

Army.ca Myth
Subscriber
Donor
Reaction score
215
Points
710
...........or you can search\ read the many threads, already posted, on the subject.

---Staff---
 

Mr. St-Cyr

Full Member
Reaction score
0
Points
0
SOP in reserve is 2 years after enrollment date you are cpl. The only conditions are you must be fit and qualified in your trade. Which is why reserve cpl's are notoriously young and inexperienced. Some actually spend two years as a recruit washing hay boxes and become cpl right after DP1.

Only in Canada.
 

cupper

Army.ca Veteran
Reaction score
0
Points
0
I hit MCpl in just over 3 years, which was somewhat accelerated for the Reserves.
 
Reaction score
0
Points
0
Fairly common to hit MCpl in the infantry reserves within 4 years of service. Is this faster than the Reg F? Generally, yes.
 

George Wallace

Army.ca Dinosaur
Reaction score
4
Points
410
cupper said:
I hit MCpl in just over 3 years, which was somewhat accelerated for the Reserves.

I hit MCpl in the Regs in 3 years.  I saw MCpls in 2 RCR with less time in. 

If they deem you to be ready, they will promote you.  If not, then they won't.  Quite simple really.
 

cupper

Army.ca Veteran
Reaction score
0
Points
0
George Wallace said:
I hit MCpl in the Regs in 3 years.  I saw MCpls in 2 RCR with less time in. 

If they deem you to be ready, they will promote you.  If not, then they won't.  Quite simple really.

It just seemed that a lot of the promotions to MCpl within my unit during my time in were around the 4 year TI mark. A lot of it may have had to do with hitting the trade qual and JLC/CLC courses at the right times.

But as you said, If the Powers that be feel you are ready, then you get to put up a maple leaf.
 

Eye In The Sky

Army.ca Fixture
Reaction score
270
Points
910
George Wallace said:
I hit MCpl in the Regs in 3 years.  I saw MCpls in 2 RCR with less time in. 

If they deem you to be ready, they will promote you.  If not, then they won't.  Quite simple really.

Kinda ignores CFA0 49-4 direction though.....
 

George Wallace

Army.ca Dinosaur
Reaction score
4
Points
410
Eye In The Sky said:
Kinda ignores CFA0 49-4 direction though.....
How?

Qualified in rank.  Advance promoted, on one year probation, and then subsequently substantiated.  DAPS.
 

Eye In The Sky

Army.ca Fixture
Reaction score
270
Points
910
Ref Annex A, Table 1 to the CFAO.  Can't remember it word for word but it lays out timelines, etc.  Including DAPS.

Like many CFAOs thought it is severely outdated and I would suspect a DAOD to replace it 'at some point'....
 

Fishbone Jones

Army.ca Myth
Subscriber
Donor
Reaction score
215
Points
710
Eye In The Sky said:
Kinda ignores CFA0 49-4 direction though.....
Are we talking today?




Or eons ago, when the Infantry went behind the Cavalry, so they could pick up equine biofuel to cook their supper?

;D

'cause that's when George was promoted a MCpl  :rofl:
 

Humphrey Bogart

Moderator
Staff member
Directing Staff
Subscriber
Reaction score
468
Points
1,010
I can tell you from my experience of dealing with meriting at the coy level that it is very rare to see anyone promoted to MCpl with 3 years of service onder their belt in the Regs.  Normally you will need a minimum of 3 MOI PER's before you are considered for promotion.  I personally think a more realistic number for promotion to MCpl for most in the Regs is 6-7 years at the top end of the spectrum.  Mind you I am speaking for the infantry here but I can't imagine it is that much different across the board.

The real difficulty arises in getting the key courses/positions and what stream you are in.
 

George Wallace

Army.ca Dinosaur
Reaction score
4
Points
410
RoyalDrew said:
I can tell you from my experience of dealing with meriting at the coy level that it is very rare to see anyone promoted to MCpl with 3 years of service onder their belt in the Regs.  Normally you will need a minimum of 3 MOI PER's before you are considered for promotion.  I personally think a more realistic number for promotion to MCpl for most in the Regs is 6-7 years at the top end of the spectrum.  Mind you I am speaking for the infantry here but I can't imagine it is that much different across the board.

The real difficulty arises in getting the key courses/positions and what stream you are in.

Times have changed.  The MCpls I witnessed being fast-tracked in 2 RCR were way back in the '80s, where there were twelve month long YTEP crses being run, and those who transferred over to the Regular Force on completion, who showed promise, were quickly loaded onto a ISCC crse and promoted. 
 

Eye In The Sky

Army.ca Fixture
Reaction score
270
Points
910
On of my first CCs in my old reserve unit was a product of a so called "super soldier" program.  Did recruit and BTT (QL3) one summer, STT (QL4, old recce crew cmdr's crse) and CLC the next summer and promoted to MCpl.  The guy wasn't a great MCpl or CC; never had any time to 'grow into it'.  He tried hard and stuff but....

 

George Wallace

Army.ca Dinosaur
Reaction score
4
Points
410
Eye In The Sky said:
On of my first CCs in my old reserve unit was a product of a so called "super soldier" program.  Did recruit and BTT (QL3) one summer, STT (QL4, old recce crew cmdr's crse) and CLC the next summer and promoted to MCpl.  The guy wasn't a great MCpl or CC; never had any time to 'grow into it'.  He tried hard and stuff but....

We are notorious for preaching one thing and then shooting ourselves in the foot by doing something quite the opposite; promoting people that shouldn't be or are not ready, passing people off course who should fail, etc. 

One of these days we may get it right.
 
M

MikeL

Guest
RoyalDrew said:
I can tell you from my experience of dealing with meriting at the coy level that it is very rare to see anyone promoted to MCpl with 3 years of service onder their belt in the Regs.  Normally you will need a minimum of 3 MOI PER's before you are considered for promotion.  I personally think a more realistic number for promotion to MCpl for most in the Regs is 6-7 years at the top end of the spectrum.  Mind you I am speaking for the infantry here but I can't imagine it is that much different across the board.

It might not be common to get MCpl in 3 years, but it does happen.  A buddy of mine(Reg Inf) became a MCpl in 3 years, he pretty much went from Pte to MCpl. When he came back from PLQ Mod 6 Inf, he was promoted to Cpl and the day after(or 2?) became a MCpl. At 6 years in, he became a Sgt.
 

myself.only

Member
Reaction score
0
Points
0
George Wallace said:
We are notorious for preaching one thing and then shooting ourselves in the foot by doing something quite the opposite; promoting people that shouldn't be or are not ready, passing people off course who should fail, etc. 

One of these days we may get it right.

IMHO quite often it seems to be tied to the idea that when it comes to performance guidance and developing pers our default solution is: let's make a course for it.
And then attending that trg = OK problem solved.
 

Old EO Tech

Full Member
Reaction score
0
Points
210
myself.only said:
IMHO quite often it seems to be tied to the idea that when it comes to performance guidance and developing pers our default solution is: let's make a course for it.
And then attending that trg = OK problem solved.

Yes an though we use the term mentor a lot lately, few organizations put it into daily practice and fail to give our people the real valuable experience they need to be successful at the next rank/job.  I'm personally always trying to do this to my subordinates, as we are not doing them any favours by promoting past their real skills/experience, just because they satisfy the min requirements.

Now the Inf are a bit different, though they still need just as much experience as any other Sgt/WO, to succeed.  They do face the problem that it is very easy to burn out/injure infanteers if they don't get out of the Cpl/MCpl rank before their bodies are too beat up. So there is a balance to deal with for them.

Jon
 

Eye In The Sky

Army.ca Fixture
Reaction score
270
Points
910
This used to be part of the *old* "Principles of Leadership"....the version I liked that I still carry in my wallet to this day.

"Develop the leadership potential of your followers"
 
Top