• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Political impacts of Ukraine war

Think this will amount to some real action or more finger waving at Russia?
I think the Poles will do something tangible. It’ll be very modest and calibrated, but real enough.

It may not be particularly visible to us on the outside, but I suspect they’re willing to communicate a clear message in some way shape or form.
 
Or maybe they're trying to make it look like the Estonians are allowing Ukraine to launch drone attacks from their territory on Russian shipping in the Baltic?
 
Or maybe they're trying to make it look like the Estonians are allowing Ukraine to launch drone attacks from their territory on Russian shipping in the Baltic?
Whoah. A blatant kinetic hit and potentially ‘hard kill’ on a Russian ship in the baltic Sea servicing Kaliningrad is a hell of a move.

I don’t see a realistic way for Ukraine to fly a drone and make this hit without either having a sea-based launch platform in the Baltics, or more realistically, overflying Belarus and then up the Suwalki Gap between Poland and Lithuania, then over Kaliningrad.

Purely spitballing, but if Poland has allowed their airspace to be used for such a strike as a one-off, I could conceivably see that falling on the more belligerent end of the realistic options in response to the missiles the other day.

If that’s what happens, it sends a message that continuing to fuck with Poland will put Kaliningrad directly in the line of fire from Ukrainians long range strikes.

EDIT TO ADD: The more I think about this, the more inclined I am to think I might be on the right track. This would be an elegantly proportionate and pragmatic response to the incursion of Russian missiles in Polish airspace… “Maybe you don’t want Polish airspace in play.” The kinetic aspect can also be seen in the might of Russian missiles striking at least one NATO member embassy in Kyiv recently.

Use of Polish airspace to allow a one-off missile strike off Kaliningrad, followed by a quiet reach out from Poland to Russia to the effect of “do we have an understanding?” makes a lot of sense to my very amateur eye.
 
Last edited:
Occasional Starshield/Starlink constraints, or limits on exquisite weapons, are not things that are deciding the course of the war. They have become convenient sticks for people to grasp to take a few whacks at Trump.

Said from the comfort of a secure place in a geographically distanced, (militarily) un-attacked, materially prosperous and fortunate nation.

On a fairly regular basis, I find myself in the professional company of UAF soldiers and commanders who have far from the security and lossless lifestyle with which you make your statement above, and my latest engagement with them was post-Starshield/Starlink degraded services, and I don’t doubt for a moment that there was tangible loss directly related to inability to effect operations due to such degradation.

Feel comfortable with your statement if you will, though having seen in their eyes the impact of these “convenient sticks” as you call them, in the Ukrainians, I would not be comfortable making such a statement.
 
Twitter’s lighting up in the last few minutes with reports of air raid sirens and airport closure in Kaliningrad. No clarity yet on nature or validity of any threat.
 
Or maybe they're trying to make it look like the Estonians are allowing Ukraine to launch drone attacks from their territory on Russian shipping in the Baltic?
Those dots - as well as others - are being connected by USSSR 2.0 commentators & pro-RUS narrative sharers, for sure. Highlights mine ...
... with this from about a month ago or so:
 
Said from the comfort of a secure place in a geographically distanced, (militarily) un-attacked, materially prosperous and fortunate nation.

On a fairly regular basis, I find myself in the professional company of UAF soldiers and commanders who have far from the security and lossless lifestyle with which you make your statement above, and my latest engagement with them was post-Starshield/Starlink degraded services, and I don’t doubt for a moment that there was tangible loss directly related to inability to effect operations due to such degradation.

Feel comfortable with your statement if you will, though having seen in their eyes the impact of these “convenient sticks” as you call them, in the Ukrainians, I would not be comfortable making such a statement.
Dieppe was a major setback for the people involved, but didn't decide the course of WW II. My observation said nothing about denying losses.

Of course I'm comfortable with my statement. There is a big picture, and there are lots of little ones. Your attempt to fit me to some sort of callous attitude is as absurd as suggesting that I must be in favour of unemployment when I observe the benefits of productivity increases.

The point remains: here, as elsewhere, people are obsessed with fleeting issues that have a nexus with Trump, and as long as all the attention is on Trump, every other leader and country just doing enough to keep the war at approximately a stalemate feels very little political pressure to move in either of the two alternate directions I've repeatedly advanced (persuade Ukraine to make concessions for peace, or help Ukraine escalate to a scale that cracks Russia). I emphasize for the n'th time that I favour escalation of aid to Ukraine, and I emphasize for the n'th time that no amount of whinging about Trump is going to move everyone else capable of contributing to the solution. I have no problem with my position here.
 
Said from the comfort of a secure place in a geographically distanced, (militarily) un-attacked, materially prosperous and fortunate nation.

On a fairly regular basis, I find myself in the professional company of UAF soldiers and commanders who have far from the security and lossless lifestyle with which you make your statement above, and my latest engagement with them was post-Starshield/Starlink degraded services, and I don’t doubt for a moment that there was tangible loss directly related to inability to effect operations due to such degradation.

Feel comfortable with your statement if you will, though having seen in their eyes the impact of these “convenient sticks” as you call them, in the Ukrainians, I would not be comfortable making such a statement.

The Ukrainians regularly claim that 80 to 90% of their strikes on all targets (tactical, depth, strategic and defensive) are by drones .... all enabled by modern comms.
 
We'll see ...
 
Dieppe was a major setback for the people involved, but didn't decide the course of WW II. My observation said nothing about denying losses.

Of course I'm comfortable with my statement. There is a big picture, and there are lots of little ones. Your attempt to fit me to some sort of callous attitude is as absurd as suggesting that I must be in favour of unemployment when I observe the benefits of productivity increases.

The point remains: here, as elsewhere, people are obsessed with fleeting issues that have a nexus with Trump, and as long as all the attention is on Trump, every other leader and country just doing enough to keep the war at approximately a stalemate feels very little political pressure to move in either of the two alternate directions I've repeatedly advanced (persuade Ukraine to make concessions for peace, or help Ukraine escalate to a scale that cracks Russia). I emphasize for the n'th time that I favour escalation of aid to Ukraine, and I emphasize for the n'th time that no amount of whinging about Trump is going to move everyone else capable of contributing to the solution. I have no problem with my position here.

Noted.
 
Back
Top