People that just strip down to long johns are still wearing all the dampness they produced that day, the nature of advanced wicking material though is that you can put a pound of liquid into the stuff and it feels dry, but don't be fooled, it isn't. Just like if you ever fall through ice, the first thing people will do is strip you naked, dry you, then get in close. The sweat in your skivvies will pull all your heat into the bag, will dampen your bag causing feather clumping, ice crystals, and chills. Strip off all that stuff, and the problem is a lot less. Don't like the sweet kiss of frozen Nylon, buy the fleece liner from Walmart or Can Tire for about 15 bucks, it is the same as the Wheelers one, but you can buy two cases of beer in Quebec with the savings, (19.75 a case at the Can tire gas bar for 24 Bud Lights) Anyway, to test the theory of liquid retention, toss your long jon's in a bag, and leave them on the cold ground, dry clothing doesn't freeze, these will.
Another tip, use the issue scarp on top of your air mattress, but under your bivy bag, your body is pumping so much heat through the compressed fibers that moisture forms between the permeable bivy bag and the impermeable mattress. Putting the scarf there sops up all this water, and then can be left outside a tent, where it freezes, and then shaken to mostly dry it. Much nicer than sleeping in it. Anyone looking for a bit of additional warmth should look towards MEC Merino long undies, a bit expensive, but the best investment you can make if you are well off, bashful when nude, slight of build, and disciplined enough to use it only as a dedicated sleep item.
Also try and get a length of fleece from fabric land that you can wrap around your mid section, nothing is worse than getting a night off of the sentry rotation only to wake up at 2am squeezing your legs together and saying to yourself "can I make it till Rev?" My answer is usually no, get dressed, fall in the snow, moral dips, and I get really pissed, literally. So, wrapping the midsection keeps more heat within the core, and not based on any medical proof, allows me to go the distance when it comes to not pissing at night.
Last one, for a tent with mixed company, fellows, wear a pair of boxers in the sack, and without drawing attention to yoursel, toss the next days socks into your undies, not only will everyone be duly inpressed, especially if you have a size 13 boots, but yopu will have nice and warm socks for the morning.