- Reaction score
- 9,113
- Points
- 1,360
Well he is the Prime Minister, so yes, it is his fault when someone in the Government does something wrong.
And yes the RCMP Commissioner really should also know better
Freedom Convoy protests [Split from All things 2019-nCoV]
- Thread starter Quirky
- Start date
And yes the RCMP Commissioner really should also know better
- Reaction score
- 9,113
- Points
- 1,360
I've got more thoughts on this. Not a lot of time to comment atm. I'll roll larger reply up for you tomorrow when I'm off call.
Needless to say, I would expect the Commissioner of the RCMP to refrain from suggesting such plainly stupid ideas.
Fair re: when you have more time
Like Remius, I distinguish between essentially private (though disclosable) one on one conceptual spitballing between two senior police executives, and advancing ideas for serious considerations. The messages, read in context, don’t appear to be suggesting of using CAF for breaking up the protest, but rather for auxiliary roles in support of, and to bolster the strength of, overly taxed police and, apparently, border officials. It appears to have not gone past the point of ‘a passing notion’.
- Reaction score
- 3,104
- Points
- 1,160
Texting with unacceptable ideas will get you a giant governmental greasy linger inserted deeply up your third point of contact. Depends who’s team you play for, I suppose.
Has nothing to do with any team. Has to do with making mountains out of molehills. I would agree that the idea as I said seems odd (the uniforms and special constable status) and if a plan had actually been proposed, submitted and prepared for I’d be more concerned. This looks more like musing and brainstorming ideas. Good and bad.
At that time plenty of people everywhere where musing on what role the CAF would/could or couldn’t provide if the EA or aid to civil power/authority was enacted.
- Reaction score
- 18,710
- Points
- 1,360
Mmmmmmm….pretty sure it’s still Harper’s fault.
daftandbarmy
Army.ca Dinosaur
- Reaction score
- 26,837
- Points
- 1,160
The fact that the RCMP's boss even considered some of these absurdities speaks volumes about how unqualified she is for the job, I would propose.
I wouldn't doubt they paid them to do it.
I can accept that as a valid argument against her level of qualification or where that should be.
- Reaction score
- 9,113
- Points
- 1,360
Which is part of the reason for my sarcastic tone.
They got caught paying actors for other protests so not trolling.
- Reaction score
- 5,323
- Points
- 1,040
Who is they and when did they get caught?
And then is the Freedom Convoy a bottom up driven expression of political disatisfaction, or some kind of 'deep state' created false flag operation? It can't be both.
- Reaction score
- 5,323
- Points
- 1,040
And in a related note, here is a good example of a situation where crowd behaviour is unpredictable and can go really wrong very quickly; and probably started with a small group of people but then quickly spread. Riots can start and spread pretty easily, so the small numbers of nutjobs who wanted to overthrow the government could have gotten a large number rumbling.
https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/south-korea-crowd-surge-1.6634610
https://www.cbc.ca/news/world/south-korea-crowd-surge-1.6634610
South Korea grieving after more than 150 die in Halloween crowd surge
Death toll could grow, with 24 people in critical condition
Concerned relatives raced to hospitals in search of their loved ones Sunday as South Korea mourned the deaths of more than 150 people, mostly in their 20s and 30s, who got trapped and crushed after a huge Halloween party crowd surged into a narrow alley in a nightlife district in Seoul.
Witnesses said the crowd surge Saturday night in the Itaewon district caused "a hell-like" chaos as people fell on each other "like dominoes." Some people were bleeding from their noses and mouths while being given CPR, witnesses said, while others clad in Halloween costumes continued to sing and dance nearby, possibly without knowing the severity of the situation.
"I still can't believe what has happened. It was like a hell," said Kim Mi Sung, an official at a nonprofit organization that promotes tourism in Itaewon.
Kim said she performed CPR on 10 people who were unconscious; nine of them were declared dead on the spot. Kim said the 10 were mostly women wearing witch outfits and other Halloween costumes.
Rescue workers treat injured people on the street in the Itaewon district of Seoul early Sunday. (Lee Jin-man/The Associated Press)
The crowd surge is the country's worst disaster in years. As of Sunday evening local time, officials put the death toll at 153 and the number of injured at 133. The Ministry of the Interior and Safety said the death count could further rise as 37 of the injured people were in serious conditions.
Ninety-seven of the dead were women and 56 were men. More than 80 per cent of the dead are in their 20s and 30s, but at least four were teenagers.
An estimated 100,000 people had gathered in Itaewon for the country's biggest outdoor Halloween festivities since the pandemic began and strict rules on gatherings were enforced. The South Korean government eased COVID-19 restrictions in recent months and this was the first big chance to get out and party for many young people.
A street in Itaewon district is pictured full of people before the stampede. Some of the faces have been digitized by the Yonhap News Agency. (Yonhap/Reuters)
Witnesses say the streets were so densely clogged with people and slow-moving vehicles that it was practically impossible for emergency workers and ambulances to reach the alley near Hamilton Hotel.
20 foreigners among the dead
South Korea's Ministry of Interior and Safety said at least 20 foreigners were among the dead, from China, Iran, Russia, the United States, Uzbekistan, Vietnam, Kazakhstan, Australia, Sri Lanka, and Norway, with several people still unidentified.
The Chinese state news agency Xinhua said at least three Chinese nationals were killed. Two Japanese nationals, a woman in her 20s and another girl or woman between the age of 10 and 19 were confirmed to have died in the crush, an official at Japan's foreign ministry said.
Global Affairs Canada said Sunday that it is "aware that a Canadian was injured in the mass casualty incident."
Rescue workers and firefighters try to help injured people near the scene Sunday. (Lee Jin-man/The Associated Press)
While Halloween isn't a traditional holiday in South Korea, where children rarely go trick-or-treating, it's still a major attraction for young adults, and costume parties at bars and clubs have become hugely popular in recent years.
Itaewon, near where the former headquarters of U.S. military forces in South Korea operated before moving out of the capital in 2018, is an expat-friendly district known for its trendy bars, clubs and restaurants and it's the city's marquee Halloween destination.
National mourning period
Authorities said thousands of people have called or visited a nearby city office, reporting missing relatives and asking officials to confirm whether they were among those injured or dead.
The bodies of the dead were being kept at 42 hospitals in the capital, Seoul, and nearby Gyeonggi Province, according to Seoul City, which said it will instruct crematories to burn more bodies per day as part of plans to support funeral proceedings.
A woman uses a phone Sunday near the scene of the tragedy. (Kim Hong-ji/Reuters)
Around 100 businesses in the Hamilton Hotel area have agreed to shut down their shops through Monday to reduce the number of partygoers who would come to the streets through Halloween Day.
South Korean President Yoon Suk Yeol declared a national mourning period on Sunday and ordered flags at government buildings and public offices to fly at half-staff. During a televised speech, Yoon said supporting the families of the victims, including their funeral preparations, and the treatment of the injured would be a top priority for his government.
He also called for officials to thoroughly investigate the cause of the accident and review the safety of other large cultural and entertainment events.
Medical staff attend to a person on a stretcher in Seoul on Oct. 30, 2022. Dozens were killed after a large crowd pushed into a narrow street during Halloween festivities. (Jung Yeon-je/AFP/Getty Images)
1 of 8
"This is really devastating. The tragedy and disaster that need not have happened took place in the heart of Seoul amid Halloween [celebrations]," Yoon said during the speech. "I feel heavy hearted and cannot contain my sadness as a president responsible for the people's lives and safety."
After the speech, Yoon visited the Itaewon alley where the disaster occurred.
It was not immediately clear what led the crowd to surge into the narrow downhill alley near the Hamilton Hotel. One survivor said many people fell and toppled one another "like dominos" after they were pushed by others. The survivor, surnamed Kim, said they were trapped for about an hour and a half before being rescued, as some people shouted "Help me!" and others were short of breath, according to the Seoul-based Hankyoreh newspaper.
Rows of bodies
Another survivor, Lee Chang-kyu, said he saw about five or six men push others before one or two began falling, according to the newspaper.
In an interview with news channel YTN, Hwang Min-hyeok, a visitor to Itaewon, said it was shocking to see rows of bodies near the hotel. He said emergency workers were initially overwhelmed, leaving pedestrians struggling to administer CPR to the injured lying on the streets. People wailed beside the bodies of their friends, he said.
Relatives of missing people weep at a community service centre in Sunday in Seoul. (Chung Sung-Jun/Getty Images)
Another survivor in his 20s said he avoided being trampled by managing to get into a bar whose door was open in the alley, Yonhap news agency reported. A woman in her 20s surnamed Park told Yonhap that she and others were standing along the side of the alley while others caught in the middle of the alley had no escape.
"Horrific news from Seoul tonight," British Prime Minister Rishi Sunak tweeted. "All our thoughts are with those currently responding and all South Koreans at this very distressing time."
Jake Sullivan, the U.S. national security adviser, tweeted that reports of the disaster were "heartbreaking" and said Washington "stands ready to provide the Republic of Korea with any support it needs."
2nd major crushing disaster in a month
The last South Korean disaster this deadly also hit young people the hardest. In April 2014, 304 people, mostly high school students, died in a ferry sinking. The sinking exposed lax safety rules and regulatory failures. It was partially blamed on excessive and poorly fastened cargo and a crew poorly trained for emergency situations. Saturday's deaths will likely draw public scrutiny of what government officials have done to improve public safety standards since the ferry disaster.
It was also Asia's second major crushing disaster in a month. On Oct. 1, police in Indonesia fired tear gas at a soccer match, causing a crush that killed 132 people as spectators attempted to flee.
daftandbarmy
Army.ca Dinosaur
- Reaction score
- 26,837
- Points
- 1,160
Um... kinda not going to happen on Parliament Hill in February, I'm guessing.
Good crowd management - unlike in S. Korea - can mitigate alot of dramas....
- Reaction score
- 22,445
- Points
- 1,090
Who, when and where?
- Reaction score
- 5,323
- Points
- 1,040
There was some earlier discussion of how crowd psychology can go horribly wrong, and people in crowds behave differently than how they would as individuals.
Different context for sure, but the protesters were packed in relatively close with the trucks restricting the available room and creating choke points.
FSTO
Army.ca Veteran
- Reaction score
- 4,774
- Points
- 1,210
Does anyone remember that the convoy crew tried to establish a similar presence at Queen’s Park in Toronto? No you don’t because the cops stopped that cold before it could cause an issue.
But the OPS screwed the pooch and here we are.
But the OPS screwed the pooch and here we are.
- Reaction score
- 1,357
- Points
- 1,260
Good thing too. Unlike Ottawa Transit, TTC does not have heavy wreckers.
- Reaction score
- 22,445
- Points
- 1,090
Things getting spicy in cross-examination of the former Ottawa Police chief.
lenaitch
Army.ca Veteran
- Reaction score
- 3,015
- Points
- 1,160
I'm not reading a lot into it. It struck me as a conversation between two people, one of which - at least - having an incomplete understanding of the NDA. If it was a full court press by a command team with SMEs, legal, etc. trying to sell an idea I would have been concerned.
I wouldn't expect a police leader to have a working knowledge of the NDA any more than I would expect the CDS to have a working knowledge of our Police Services Act. The foundation of what you know is learned at the coalface; most of what follows is enhancement and/or supervisory/leadership. I couldn't find a detailed breakdown of Lucki's experience but it seems her actual law enforcement delivery experience was rather short.
Don't conflate a lofty position with a broad and encompassing first-hand knowledge of what they command. The OPP had a Commissioner who's sum total of actual law enforcement delivery was about seven years in a traffic detachment.
Similar threads
