• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

1 Nov 2026 Hamilton Poppy Sale Attack (split from All Things Red Poppy)

Attachments

Unbelievable... infuriating

Cadet captain paralyzed from waist down after Hamilton attack​

A cadet leader who underwent spinal surgery after a violent attack says he is currently paralyzed from the waist down and will require months of physical rehabilitation.

Capt. Kenneth Kunkel provided an update on his situation last week in a statement shared online by a Hamilton member of Parliament.

 
There’s a letter from Captain Kunkel that explains what his state is, and what happened during the attack.

Screen shots are from X…
I really hope that he had a lawyer look at this before he posted it. As horrible as what that woman did to him, I actually think that he incriminated himself here, as well as potentially harmed the ongoing investigation and criminal charges. However, it is somewhat inconclusive if the youth was wearing the backpack or not. On first reading it sounded like he was dragging the kid by the backpack.

As much as the woman involved should see jail time for her actions, this was a situation that didn't need to happen. The CIC Officer should have called the police and let them handle it. None of his cadets were in immediate danger, in fact, he ceased supervising the cadets in order to follow the youth into the restaurant.

He lacked any type of jurisdiction to take the youth's backpack. Based on his comments that the youth was eating directly from the buffet does make it seem that he may have been holding the backpack. If this is true, that is assault. He did not witness the use of the air horn, the youth was not actively using the air horn. In reality, the CIC Officer had no way of knowing if the air horn was even in the bag. Had the youth been actively blowing the air horn in cadets ear, it might have been a different story.

I know this is unpopular saying this, but based on his own account it sounds like he acted very unprofessionally. Once again, I am making my observations solely on his account of the events in question.
 
And with the usual presumed-innocent-until-proven-guilty-in-a-court-of-law caveats, Rebel Media gives its take (30 minutes of talking thru the crack of a door warning for the video) ....
From the article:
Screenshot 2026-11-18 055231.jpg
 
I really hope that he had a lawyer look at this before he posted it. As horrible as what that woman did to him, I actually think that he incriminated himself here, as well as potentially harmed the ongoing investigation and criminal charges. However, it is somewhat inconclusive if the youth was wearing the backpack or not. On first reading it sounded like he was dragging the kid by the backpack.

As much as the woman involved should see jail time for her actions, this was a situation that didn't need to happen. The CIC Officer should have called the police and let them handle it. None of his cadets were in immediate danger, in fact, he ceased supervising the cadets in order to follow the youth into the restaurant.

He lacked any type of jurisdiction to take the youth's backpack. Based on his comments that the youth was eating directly from the buffet does make it seem that he may have been holding the backpack. If this is true, that is assault. He did not witness the use of the air horn, the youth was not actively using the air horn. In reality, the CIC Officer had no way of knowing if the air horn was even in the bag. Had the youth been actively blowing the air horn in cadets ear, it might have been a different story.

I know this is unpopular saying this, but based on his own account it sounds like he acted very unprofessionally. Once again, I am making my observations solely on his account of the events in question.
Where did you get your law degree? When did you get called to the bar?

Or can I assume you are a police officer?
 
Where did you get your law degree? When did you get called to the bar?

Or can I assume you are a police officer

As a law-talking guy who has spent many hours begging for toonies outside a provincial government liquor store in my polyester blue cadet uniform — Kilted is correct.

Capt Kunkel probably should not have put that letter out. It does not read like something that would survive intervention by a competent lawyer. I doubt he got legal advice.

Powers of citizens (read: non-peace officers) to make an arrest are appropriately limited. It does read as though K witnessed the offence nor was he in hot pursuit. That also means any force that was used (by K’s own admission) risks being grounds for a charge or civil suit, although the former is probably quite unlikely.

This does not read as a wise course of action by K (even before he was injured). I am loathe to kick a guy when he is down, but for the benefit of others — don’t do that.
 
As a law-talking guy who has spent many hours begging for toonies outside a provincial government liquor store in my polyester blue cadet uniform — Kilted is correct.

Capt Kunkel probably should not have put that letter out. It does not read like something that would survive intervention by a competent lawyer. I doubt he got legal advice.

Powers of citizens (read: non-peace officers) to make an arrest are appropriately limited. It does read as though K witnessed the offence nor was he in hot pursuit. That also means any force that was used (by K’s own admission) risks being grounds for a charge or civil suit, although the former is probably quite unlikely.

This does not read as a wise course of action by K (even before he was injured). I am loathe to kick a guy when he is down, but for the benefit of others — don’t do that.
So your not a lawyer or a police officer? You ASSUME you know exactly how this will unfold? Your going to legal arm chair this issue? Good luck. Kilted is guessing as to what will happen and how it unfold.

I have at least done over 150 disciplinary proceedings for the military and laid charges in most cases that resulted in conviction. Even I know to STFU and let the lawyers and cops duke this out (if at all) in the courts. Hint fucking hint.
 
I really hope that he had a lawyer look at this before he posted it. As horrible as what that woman did to him, I actually think that he incriminated himself here, as well as potentially harmed the ongoing investigation and criminal charges. However, it is somewhat inconclusive if the youth was wearing the backpack or not. On first reading it sounded like he was dragging the kid by the backpack.

As much as the woman involved should see jail time for her actions, this was a situation that didn't need to happen. The CIC Officer should have called the police and let them handle it. None of his cadets were in immediate danger, in fact, he ceased supervising the cadets in order to follow the youth into the restaurant.

He lacked any type of jurisdiction to take the youth's backpack. Based on his comments that the youth was eating directly from the buffet does make it seem that he may have been holding the backpack. If this is true, that is assault. He did not witness the use of the air horn, the youth was not actively using the air horn. In reality, the CIC Officer had no way of knowing if the air horn was even in the bag. Had the youth been actively blowing the air horn in cadets ear, it might have been a different story.

I know this is unpopular saying this, but based on his own account it sounds like he acted very unprofessionally. Once again, I am making my observations solely on his account of the events in question.

Where did you get your law degree? When did you get called to the bar?

Or can I assume you are a police officer?

As a law-talking guy who has spent many hours begging for toonies outside a provincial government liquor store in my polyester blue cadet uniform — Kilted is correct.

Capt Kunkel probably should not have put that letter out. It does not read like something that would survive intervention by a competent lawyer. I doubt he got legal advice.

Powers of citizens (read: non-peace officers) to make an arrest are appropriately limited. It does read as though K witnessed the offence nor was he in hot pursuit. That also means any force that was used (by K’s own admission) risks being grounds for a charge or civil suit, although the former is probably quite unlikely.

This does not read as a wise course of action by K (even before he was injured). I am loathe to kick a guy when he is down, but for the benefit of others — don’t do that.

So your not a lawyer or a police officer? You ASSUME you know exactly how this will unfold? Your going to legal arm chair this issue? Good luck. Kilted is guessing as to what will happen and how it unfold.

I have at least done over 150 disciplinary proceedings for the military and laid charges in most cases that resulted in conviction. Even I know to STFU and let the lawyers and cops duke this out (if at all) in the courts. Hint fucking hint.
I guess I’ll weigh in. @Kilted raises valid concerns. I cannot properly assess without having all the facts obviously, but if we take Capt Kunkel’s account and assume he’s telling it accurately, my first inclination on reading it is that he went past what the law allows a private person to do. And I had that thought immediately, before the subject came up here.

A non-peace officer can arrest without a warrant under 494 Criminal Code for an indictable offence ‘found committing’. They cannot, under circumstances like what was described, go looking for a person and then arrest them after the fact simply based on belief. Police can under 495 Criminal Code; non-police by and large cannot. The 494 arrest powers are much more limited. If you see someone commit the air horn assault and immediately grip on to them to hand them over to police? I’d say good to go. Being told about it after the fact, going looking, finding, and muckling onto a youth to effect an arrest? Yikes.

So, he may have just admitted publicly that he tracked down and restrained the youth beyond what the law permits. Do I like that a read of the law takes me this way in my thinking? Fuck no. Do I think he intended to do wrong or that any of what he did was morally objectionable? No. But does he describe an unlawful use of force and detention..? Unfortunately, taking the story at face value, it’s distinctly possible. FWIW, I’m being very cautious and hedging a fair bit in how I write this.

The really crappy part is that does leave room for a plausible claim by a bystander that they intervened to prevent or halt an assault. I’m not saying it was or wasn’t that, but an open minded investigation would absolutely have to consider it. And were I taking a statement from the Captain, with knowledge of what he posted, I wouldn’t be doing my job if I didn’t caution him first.

I would personally not have posted that story were I in his shoes. He needs to probably speak to and more importantly listen to a lawyer.

Everything I’ve said is based on a plain reading of the words alleged to have been posted by Capt K, and Ivlukd easily be mistaken in some or all of this. Any different facts from what’s presented in his post could change the legal situation completely.

I hope he recovers quickly and fully.
 
Last edited:
The really crappy part is that does leave room for a plausible claim by a bystander that they intervened to prevent or halt an assault.
Barring new information, if I had to bet a loonie, that’s what I’d guess her defence counsel would start working with.
 
So your not a lawyer or a police officer? You ASSUME you know exactly how this will unfold? Your going to legal arm chair this issue? Good luck. Kilted is guessing as to what will happen and how it unfold.

I have at least done over 150 disciplinary proceedings for the military and laid charges in most cases that resulted in conviction. Even I know to STFU and let the lawyers and cops duke this out (if at all) in the courts. Hint fucking hint.
I’m glad you’ve enjoyed a long career in military law. On the civvie side, this was probably not a smart move by K for reasons I have already explained, and which two other people have echoed. You’re welcome to provide us a substantive reply anytime, although I doubt one is forthcoming given what we’ve seen so far.

Lots of fun joining a forum where a thoughtful comment is met with drivel like this and a weird DM. Peace out.

E: As for the law-talking-guy reference, I’m surprised I need to link this but sure:
 
I’m glad you’ve enjoyed a long career in military law.
I never had a career in military law and never said I did. If you do not understand how our disciplinary system works, then give it a rest. Have you even served? yes or no? You obviously don't know me.

To both you and Kilted, making comments and assumptions based on what you read in the newspaper or even heard from a statement, is a BIG leap. Brihard has real world experience in investigating (and notice how cautiously he worded his statement), nothing is black and white is my point. Leave the legal judging to those in the profession. It reminds me of when people start arm chair quarterbacking how soldiers should do their job.

Hopefully Captain K recovers fully.
 
Why has this thread gotten needlessly aggressive. This is a discussion board, it is here for the purpose of discussing things. This is not the first time that legal matters have been discussed here, not even the first time that those legal matters involved a CAF member. All of those discussions have been civil.
 
Back
Top