i dunno.. for reservists i think that the summer basic should be the only way to go, and even then, step it up a bit... I know that when i got back from my 3s and saw one or two of the raw recruits who had passed, i knew that they weren‘t throwing enough people out... even in shilo 2002 there were a few people that my instructors would have LOVED to seen thrown out on their @$$es, but because of the due process and the cmdt, they weren‘t thrown out....
at my unit, we had the weekend basic, but those weekenders had to go to shilo, because they weren‘t able to get the course recognized for some reason (don‘t ask me why). One of my friends who did both says that the 2 experiences are totally different and cannot be compared to each other...