• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Bush dodges shoes thrown at him in MidEast trip

Iraqi who threw shoes at ex-President George W. Bush says he acted to restore Iraq's pride

By SINAN SALAHEDDIN
Associated Press Writer
5:37 AM CST, February 19, 2009
BAGHDAD (AP) — An Iraqi journalist who gained cult status for throwing his shoes at former President George W. Bush said Thursday at the start of his trial that he was driven by a desire to restore the pride of his devastated country.

In his first public appearance since he was taken into custody on Dec. 14, Muntadhar al-Zeidi said he did not intend to harm Bush or to embarrass Iraqi Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki.

"What made me do it was the humiliation Iraq has been subjected to due to the U.S. occupation and the murder of innocent people," al-Zeidi said. "I wanted to restore the pride of the Iraqis in any way possible, apart from using weapons."

The 30-year-old journalist addressed the three-judge panel after being greeted by applause and cheers from supporters as he entered the courtroom in western Baghdad. His aunt handed him a scarf imprinted with a red, black and green Iraqi flag, which he kissed and draped around his neck.

The chief judge then threatened to order everybody out of the room if they didn't calm down. The trial was later adjourned until March 12.

Al-Zeidi has been in Iraqi custody since he was wrestled to the ground by guards and dragged away after the Dec. 14 outburst at Bush's joint news conference with al-Maliki in Baghdad.

When he threw the shoes, he shouted at Bush in Arabic: "This is your farewell kiss, you dog! This is from the widows, the orphans and those who were killed in Iraq."

In his testimony on Thursday, al-Zeidi described his growing frustration as Bush spoke about his victories and achievement at the press conference — held 37 days before Bush handed the war off to his successor, Barack Obama, who has pledged to end it.

"I was seeing a whole country in calamity while Bush was giving a cold and spiritless smile," al-Zeidi testified. "He was saying goodbye after causing the death of many Iraqis and economic destruction."

The obscure television reporter was transformed into a celebrity across the Muslim world, where thousands hailed him as a hero and demanded his release for what they considered a justified act of patriotism.

Al-Zeidi's attorneys say he has been charged with assaulting a foreign leader, which carries a maximum penalty of 15 years in prison. The defense has tried to get the charge reduced, saying the act doesn't merit such harsh punishment.

The defense has argued that Bush was not in Baghdad on an official visit because he had arrived in Iraq unannounced and without invitation. That would mean the charge of assaulting a foreign leader would not be applicable, according to the defense.

"The visit was not formal because Bush is an occupier and he was received by the commander of the U.S. Army and it was an undeclared visit," one of al-Zeidi's lawyers Ghalib al-Rubaie said. "President Jalal Talabani and the prime minister did not receive him when he arrived."

Judge Abdul-Amir al-Rubaie adjourned the trial, saying the court needed time to ask the Iraqi Cabinet whether Bush's visit was "formal or informal." Visits by foreign dignitaries are rarely announced beforehand due to security reasons.

The defendant, who was wearing a beige suit and a black shirt, spoke confidently and showed no signs of the injuries he allegedly suffered at the hands of security forces.

The case's investigating judge has said the journalist was struck about the face and eyes, apparently by security agents after he hurled one shoe at a time, forcing Bush to duck for cover.

Al-Zeidi said he was tortured, beaten and given electric shocks during his interrogation.

Two Cabinet protocol employees who witnessed the incident testified at the trial that no bodyguards assaulted al-Zeidi despite confusion at the scene.

One of the witnesses, Sameer Mohammed, said he saw some members of the audience start to beat al-Zeidi but then "the prime minister ordered that the press conference should proceed and that no one should hurt him."

Another witness said the guards did not assault al-Zeidi but there was a scuffle.

"No one from security or the bodyguards assaulted him, but they were trying to push him out and he was pushing them back," witness Abdul Amir said in testimony read by the judge.

Abdul Amir said al-Zeidi was repeating the word dog, which he had called Bush.

Al-Maliki was deeply embarrassed by the assault on an American president who had stood by him during the worst of the violence, when some Arab leaders were quietly urging the U.S. to oust him.

Supporters who rallied in front of the western Baghad court before the trial began Thursday said al-Zeidi should be praised for standing up to Bush, not punished for his actions.

"We are proud of what Muntadhar has done," said al-Zeidi's sister Doniya, standing outside the court with about 60 other supporters. "Bush was not a guest in Iraq and he didn't come by invitation of the Iraqi people. He came as an occupier."

The journalist's aunt, Nawal Lazim, who handed him the scarf as he entered the court, said Iraqis should be proud of al-Zeidi's act.

"What Muntadhar has done is revenge for Iraqi widows and for the bloodshed caused by the occupation and policy of Bush," Lazim said.
 
Iraqi's sole defense: Blind rage
Shoes were thrown at Bush to restore dignity, court told
By Liz Sly Chicago Tribune
February 20, 2009
http://www.chicagotribune.com/news/nationworld/chi-t6-iraq-shoe_0220feb20,0,1670816.story

BAGHDAD — The Iraqi journalist who threw his shoes at then-President George W. Bush made an impassioned plea for clemency on the first day of his trial Thursday, saying he had been blinded with rage when he saw Bush smiling and joking with the Iraqi prime minister during a news conference.

"I was trying to restore the dignity of Iraqis in any possible way short of using weapons," Muntadhar al-Zeidi, 30, told the court in his first public comments on the Dec. 14 incident, which transformed him overnight into a hero across the Arab world.

Bush ducked and avoided both shoes as Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki raised his hand to protect him.

Zeidi is charged with assaulting a visiting foreign guest, a crime that carries a maximum of 15 years' imprisonment. But members of his 22-strong defense team hope to portray the case as a test of Iraq's democratic freedoms and to reduce the charge to a lesser one.

Zeidi insisted he acted on impulse after listening to Bush praise the "achievements" made in Iraq.

"While he was talking I was looking at all his achievements," he said. "More than a million killed, the destruction and humiliation of mosques, violations against Iraqi women, attacking Iraqis every day and every hour.

"A whole people are saddened because of his policy, and he was talking with a smile on his face. So I reacted to this feeling by throwing my shoes. … It was spontaneous," he said.

The judge appears to be trying to determine whether the shoe-throwing was a premeditated act, which could carry a harsher penalty, defense attorneys said.

Zeidi also argued that Bush could not be considered either a guest, because his forces occupied Iraq uninvited, or an official visitor, because the trip was not announced in advance.

The judge adjourned the trial until March 12, pending a request to the prime minister's office to clarify whether Bush's visit was in fact "official or unofficial."

If the visit is deemed unofficial, then the defense team hopes the charge against Zeidi can be reduced to one of "attempted assault without harm," which typically carries only a fine. If the visit was official, the defense aims to persuade the judge to reduce the charge to "insulting a foreign guest," which carries a maximum 2-year penalty.
 
Looks like the shoe-thrower celebrity got himself 3 years in prison! :blotto:

An Iraqi journalist who hurled his shoes at George Bush was sentenced to three years in prison today for assaulting a foreign leader.

Muntazer al-Zaidi, 30, said: “Long live Iraq” as the guilty verdict was read out in a Baghdad courtroom before being led away.

The punishment prompted an angry reaction from family and friends who described it as harsh and politically motivated. Al-Zaidi’s defence team plans to launch an appeal.

The journalist captured headlines across the world when he flung his shoes at the then-US President during a press conference in Baghdad last December.

This is a goodbye kiss from the Iraqi people, dog! This is from the widows, the orphans and those who were killed in Iraq,” the reporter, from Al-Baghdadiya television, shouted before being bundled to the ground.

Al-Zaidi, who has been held in detention since December 14, denies any wrong-doing.

Wearing a light-brown suit, brown sweatshirt and thin-framed glasses, he stood confidently inside a wooden pen at the Iraq Central Criminal Court after being brought in under a heavy police escort.

Asked by Presiding Judge Abdul-Amir al-Rubaie whether he was innocent or guilty, the defendant said: “I am innocent. What I did was a natural response to the occupation.”

Some 200 people, including family members, lawyers and journalists, packed the courtroom to listen to the second day of the trial, which had been adjourned since February 19 for the three judges to weigh a defence argument that the charge was inapplicable because Mr Bush had not been in Baghdad as an official guest.

Judge Al-Rubaie, however, read a response from the Prime Minister's office today insisting that the trip had been official despite being unannounced.

Most people were sent out of the courtroom while the verdict and sentence were delivered.

The three-year prison term is lower than the 5-to-15 years carried by the assault charge because the judge took into consideration al-Zaidi’s young age and the fact that it was a first offence.

This did little to pacify his family. Upon hearing the outcome, one sister, Ruqaiya, burst into tears.

"Down with (Iraqi Prime Minister) Maliki, agent of the Americans," she said outside the courtroom. Several other family members shouted anti-American slogans and tried to surge back inside. They were pushed away by police.

Dhiaa al-Saadi, the chief defence lawyer, said that his team would appeal. “This sentence is harsh and is not in harmony with the law, and eventually the defence team will contest this in the appeals court," he said.

(...)





http://www.timesonline.co.uk/tol/news/world/iraq/article5893747.ece
 
3 yrs by our standards is harsh for a stupid display of a political stunt, however in an envorinment when not so long ago would have had you executed and wickedly tortured before hand, a 3 yr sentance is light.

I would imagine in time a judge will release him with time served.

IMHO anyways and for what its worth.

OWDU
 
I was watching the news the other day, apparently some people over there made a bronze statue of the very same shoe he hurled at Dubya's face.
 
http://www.ctv.ca/servlet/ArticleNews/story/CTVNews/20090913/shoe_thrower_090913/20090913?hub=World

Iraqi shoe thrower to be released Monday
The Associated Press  (Grammar / Spelling In Context)

BAGHDAD -- The family of the Iraqi journalist who threw his shoes at former U.S. President George W. Bush is preparing a festive welcome for the TV reporter, who is to be released from prison Monday after nine months behind bars.

At his family's home in Baghdad on Sunday, relatives of Muntadhar al-Zeidi were already celebrating, waving Iraqi flags and hanging balloons and posters of the reporter on the walls.

Al-Zeidi, a little-known reporter for a small Iraqi TV station, became an icon for many in the Arab world in a single moment last December. As Bush and Iraq's prime minister addressed a news conference, the reporter jumped from his seat and hurled his shoes at the American president.

Bush was unhurt but forced to duck. Al-Zeidi shouted at him in Arabic, "This is your farewell kiss, you dog! This is from the widows, the orphans and those who were killed in Iraq."

Many throughout the Middle East felt the protest reflected their own frustration and bitterness over the war in Iraq and the U.S. occupation. His act was widely celebrated and even inspired Internet games and T-shirts and led some to try to offer their daughters to him in marriage.

The 30-year-old al-Zeidi's family says he might use his newfound celebrity status to promote humanitarian causes such as the rights of orphans and women.

His employer, Al-Baghdadiya TV, expects he will return to work as a television reporter for the station, though some have questioned how he would be able to work again as a journalist in Iraq.

His actions deeply embarrassed Prime Minister Nouri al-Maliki, and many officials in his government would likely to blacklist the reporter.

In March, al-Zeidi was convicted of assault. His three-year prison sentence was reduced to one because he had no prior record and now he is to be released three months early for good behaviour.

"God forbid if he is not released on time," his brother Dargham said on Sunday.

The family hung posters showing al-Zeidi's face in front of an Iraqi flag and the words: "Release the one who regained Iraqis' dignity."

The family is expected to meet him at the gates of a prison in central Baghdad on Monday. Parties and music are planned at his family's home later in the day.

His family is worried about his safety and will try to keep celebrations small because of security concerns, his brother Dargham said.

In 2007, al-Zeidi, a Shiite, was kidnapped by gunmen while on an assignment in a Sunni district of north Baghdad. He was freed unharmed three days later after Iraqi television stations broadcast appeals for his release.

Then in January 2008, he was arrested by American soldiers who searched his apartment building and released him the next day with an apology.

Those experiences helped mould his resentment of the U.S. military's presence in Iraq, according to his family.
 
"Iraqi journalist turns tables on shoe thrower: PARIS (AFP) - A protester who presented himself as an Iraqi journalist in exile hurled a shoe Tuesday at the colleague who one year ago found fame hurling his own footwear at then US president George W. Bush.
Television reporter Muntazer al-Zaidi was in Paris to promote his campaign for the "victims of the US occupation in Iraq" when a fellow Iraqi critic turned the tables on him, shouting: "Here's another shoe for you.":
http://ca.news.yahoo.com/s/afp/091201/world/france_iraq_media_shoe
 
Back
Top