• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

CAF Security Forces/"RCAF Regiment"/Defenders [Split from RCN Anti Drone Weapon]

Number one way to destroy an enemy airfield is with air assets and it is a high priority target so it makes perfect sense to have heavily equipped infantry (plus support weapons) or infantry like with AD weapons and now counter drone capability as well (which seems to be an evolving discipline)
 
Number one way to destroy an enemy airfield is with air assets and it is a high priority target so it makes perfect sense to have heavily equipped infantry (plus support weapons) or infantry like with AD weapons and now counter drone capability as well (which seems to be an evolving discipline)

'Back in the day' the RAF Regiment manned several Rapier missile batteries until they passed that role onto the Artillery:

 
Can't help but feel that 2 of those 3 trades are going to end up looking a lot like the Rock Ape gunners.

Drones, missiles or jets .... knocking them down feels a lot like a gunner's job to this civilian.
Who owns the people matters. If the RCAF wants the CA to provide gunners, but the CA wants them elsewhere the RCAF is left to "figure it out". The new security trade could be one way for the the RCAF "figure it out"...

To be clear, it doesn't take inter-L1 fighting to create problems of "ownership", but problems of ownership get bigger the farther up the ladder you go.
 
Who owns the people matters. If the RCAF can wants the CA to provide gunners, but if the CA wants them elsewhere the RCAF is left to "figure it out". The new security trade could be one way for the the RCAF "figure it out"...

To be clear, it doesn't take inter-L1 fighting to create problems of "ownership", but problems of ownership get bigger the farther up the ladder you go.
Helicopters have entered the chat
 
Who owns the people matters. If the RCAF wants the CA to provide gunners, but the CA wants them elsewhere the RCAF is left to "figure it out". The new security trade could be one way for the the RCAF "figure it out"...

To be clear, it doesn't take inter-L1 fighting to create problems of "ownership", but problems of ownership get bigger the farther up the ladder you go.

Don't misunderstand me. I am not calling for the RRCA to take over airfield defence or even to allocate airfield defence batteries.

I am a fan of an RCAF Regiment.

My supposition is that such a force, if it is also being tasked with CUAS security, is going to look more like the RAF Regiment than a police or guard force.
 
I wonder if any AD ARty guys can give us a head to head comparison of ADATS vs Rapier
They are somewhat comparable. ADATs had a range of around 10 kms, Rapier about 8 kms; ADATS radar ranged out to about 25 kms, Rapier to about 15 kms, ADATS guidance was a laser beam rider and Rapier manual optical radio guidance - effectively for both the operator kept his "cross hairs" on the target and the missile flew to that. They would fit in the SHORAD category and both changed a bit during their life cycles. One big difference is in the numbers sold and missiles produced. ADATS was low scale - only 42 were ever built and Canada owned 36 of those. About 600 Rapier have been built and purchased by well over a dozen countries.
Who owns the people matters. If the RCAF wants the CA to provide gunners, but the CA wants them elsewhere the RCAF is left to "figure it out". The new security trade could be one way for the the RCAF "figure it out"...

To be clear, it doesn't take inter-L1 fighting to create problems of "ownership", but problems of ownership get bigger the farther up the ladder you go.
The problem is that no one has the people to man this kit in the number needed. The second problem is the army is risk averse to giving the reserves "high-tech" gear. The fact that over 400 reservists made up about half of the army's AD branch before the turn of the century is lost on leadership. The army's priorities haven't changed from 2011 when air defence was considered so unimportant a priority that the whole branch was ash-canned. And when they woke up to the threat then the GBADS was initially quite anemic and targeted at just enough for Latvia with a training component in Canada. No one ever contemplated equipping a whole army much less a whole CAF and a whole country.

AD is expensive but not needed every day. But even with a healthy sprinkling of reservists the acquisition costs, the training burden and the continuous annual operating costs will be very high. I think the numbers simply boggle the minds of the L0 and L1s. This is a "hot potato" issue that no one wants to grab hold of.

If there is one thing that Ukraine is teaching us it's that air defence is a whole country activity from home guards with simple systems to THAAD. I honestly am not sure if our military has been able to wrap its head around this and cyber warfare.

And the fun part is we have morons and psychopaths running nuclear nations.

:cool:
 
Back
Top