• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Canada and the Normandy Campaign

A good interview with David Patterson about the Canadian artillery with a focus on D-day+1

 
Apologize for the thread-revival, but I took some time recently to read Milner's Stopping the Panzers which is referred to in the initial post. It was a very worthwhile investment, and it does show a series of Canadian battles in a new light compared to the narrative of the 60s through 90s.

The chapters on the planning of Normandy landings and enlargement were excellent, and highlighted the shifting nature of Canada's role in all this. Some other sources might go into more depth on the planning for the actual landings, but Milner's book really digs into the plan to secure the beachhead. You see the interplay between the operational plan and the assessment of what the enemy is likely to do. The changing intelligence picture comes forth, as does the continuing of the plan even after the assessment of the German panzer dispositions was changing. We often here a statement about how the Normandy landings orders were short, but this book puts that myth the rest. For example the Western Task Force Operation Order for First US Army was two-inches thick double-sided. The relative inflexibility once the machine was set in motion is evident.

The book has excellent contemporary air photos of some of the battlefields which helps bring the events to light. He has detailed descriptions of the tactical problems faced by the company, battalion and brigade commanders of both sides. He presents the events by following regiments in turn, similar to an avenue-in-depth wargame as opposed to covering each day for the overall force (like a more familiar belt-style wargame). This makes the reader shift back and forth in terms of dates, but it also allows for a more in-depth examination of each battle.

Milner probes into the lack of artillery support available to the Canadians during some of those early battles. There are also some interesting command studies at all levels as two forces crash into each other.

The framing of the initials battles as the successful defence of the beachhead as tasked as opposed to a failure to reach Caen is, I think, appropriate. The investment of time in the early chapters about the overall plan helps make this case. As Infanteer states up-thread, its not really about who "won" or "lost."

I am about half-way through Gullachsen's The Defeat and Attrition of 12SS Volume 1 which has a more detailed look at the German side of the same engagements. Also a worthwhile read!
 
Back
Top