- Reaction score
- 35
- Points
- 560
Disturbing economic news:
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/09/business/chinas-flawed-inflation-figures.html?_r=1&src=recg
http://www.nytimes.com/2011/09/09/business/chinas-flawed-inflation-figures.html?_r=1&src=recg
China’s Flawed Inflation Figures
Associated Press
Volatile prices on items like pork greatly affect China's inflation number.
By JOHN FOLEY and MARTIN HUTCHINSON
Published: September 8, 2011
When China reports this week that the consumer price index rose at an annualized rate of about 6 percent in August, economists may say inflation has peaked. They said the same last year, when the C.P.I. was running half as fast. The problem isn’t bad forecasting: China’s headline inflation measure is flawed.
Headline inflation is easily bent by volatile prices. Take pork, which rose 57 percent year on year in July. Vegetable prices are increasing more than 5 percent a week, and the effect is magnified because food composes a third of the C.P.I. basket. Conversely, some prices are artificially low, like energy and transport. A ticket on Beijing’s subway has cost a flat 2 renminbi for three years.
China’s size creates another problem. While Shanghai urbanites lament the price of their lattes, farmers in the hinterland have different concerns. Perhaps it would be better to have one C.P.I. for the city and one for the country. New tailored bank rules for low-income Xinjiang Province make that not so far-fetched.
Finding the genuine inflation number isn’t easy. One insight comes with the difference between nominal and real reported gross domestic product, the so-called G.D.P. deflator. By that measure, 2010’s inflation was around twice the C.P.I.’s reported 3.3 percent rise. If that’s a guide, today’s inflation could be in double digits.
Savers, who are robbed by rising prices, are giving a strong signal. They have flocked to real estate and high-yielding wealth products to beat the measly 3.5 percent mandated one-year deposit rate. That makes inflation harder to fight, since money pushed into informal lending channels isn’t affected by monetary policy tools like bank credit quotas. Allowing deposits to be set by the market would draw more back into the banks. But the fear of eroding banks’ margins seems to stand in the way of what would be a potent inflation-fighting tool.
And then there are the dog whistles from politicians. Premier Wen Jiabao wrote in a state magazine on Sept. 1 that price stability was his priority, and warned of “unstable” conditions. Whatever the numbers say, when savers and politicians worry, investors should, too.
Proximity Blues
Canada’s economic comfort is suffering at the hands of its troubled southern neighbor. The Bank of Canada on Wednesday stopped raising interest rates at 1 percent, largely because of deteriorating conditions in the United States. That’s a pity — Canada would benefit from rates above inflation. But sluggishness and policy-wrangling south of the border sap growth and make its currency less competitive.
That makes the central bank’s decision understandable. Canadian short-term rates are already 1 percentage point higher than America’s zero rates, while the Canadian dollar has strengthened 5 percent against the greenback in the last year. The prevailing near parity between the two currencies hurts Canadian exports, slows growth and hampers job creation, even though the country’s resources sectors remain competitive.
A pick-up in growth in the United States would help Canada’s exports, while higher interest rates in the United States would reduce the upward pressure on the Canadian dollar. But neither of those things is likely in the short term, and the Federal Reserve’s commitment to a zero-rate policy through 2013 could even at some point put pressure on the Bank of Canada to reduce rates.
Yet Canadian inflation approached 3 percent in the year to July, and the nation’s savings rate, at 4.1 percent in the second quarter, is uncomfortably low and has fallen by 2.7 percentage points in the last year. Higher rates could help on both counts. Increased savings could also help the government as it chips away at the budget deficit and tries to balance its books.
Not that inflation, let alone growth, can be said to be overheating. But that, like the Bank of Canada’s rates policy, has a lot to do with the cold wind from the south. The United States represented 73 percent of exports in 2010 and the hobbled European Union and Japan a further 11 percent.
A push to build closer ties with faster-growing developing countries could help long term. Location makes that diversification challenging and, if a United States diplomatic cable published by WikiLeaks is to be believed, Prime Minister Stephen Harper’s foreign travel — for instance, to Brazil last month — isn’t especially to his liking. But it’s a worthy goal. In the meantime, Canada’s erstwhile geographical advantage is, for now, its millstone.
For more independent financial commentary and analysis, visit www.breakingviews.com.