• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Chinese Military,Political and Social Superthread

I am no fan of this trend
Me either.

China and Russia are in essentially the same category. Both occupy foreign countries, both are guilty of egregious human rights violations, both aggressively conduct espionage (military and commercial). The only real difference is that Russia is conducting a major war of aggression right now and China hasn't conducted once since it invaded Vietnam.

I see no reason to treat China much differently from Russia in terms of relationships, but there are plenty of people screeching for various supports for Ukraine and at the same time making polite noises about China being potentially adversarial, but...

If China makes a move on Taiwan, an awful lot of stuff is going to have to be unwound. Probably better to make all commitments and use all resources elsewhere in the first place.
 
Me either.

China and Russia are in essentially the same category. Both occupy foreign countries, both are guilty of egregious human rights violations, both aggressively conduct espionage (military and commercial). The only real difference is that Russia is conducting a major war of aggression right now and China hasn't conducted once since it invaded Vietnam.

I see no reason to treat China much differently from Russia in terms of relationships, but there are plenty of people screeching for various supports for Ukraine and at the same time making polite noises about China being potentially adversarial, but...

If China makes a move on Taiwan, an awful lot of stuff is going to have to be unwound. Probably better to make all commitments and use all resources elsewhere in the first place.
CHINA IMO is the more dangerous of the two. Russia is at least "in your face".

China - its somewhere else.....
 
The mental gymnastics people make to justify closer ties to Beijing while being wary of Moscow and Washington…
Should be wary of Washington? Yes, but in two years or so the leadership will change. Hopefully its for the better.

In Russia and China the leadership will not change, barring an unforeseen circumstance. Be wary of them always.
 
Should be wary of Washington? Yes, but in two years or so the leadership will change. Hopefully its for the better.

I hope so too, but the current leadership in Washington is a symptom of the problem. The whole ecosystem that rose up and populated this government is not going anywhere anytime soon. I have no faith in either party to go back to normal there, especially as volatile as their electorate is and no party will be able to solve their gigantic problems.
 
Me either.

China and Russia are in essentially the same category. Both occupy foreign countries, both are guilty of egregious human rights violations, both aggressively conduct espionage (military and commercial). The only real difference is that Russia is conducting a major war of aggression right now and China hasn't conducted once since it invaded Vietnam.

I see no reason to treat China much differently from Russia in terms of relationships, but there are plenty of people screeching for various supports for Ukraine and at the same time making polite noises about China being potentially adversarial, but...

If China makes a move on Taiwan, an awful lot of stuff is going to have to be unwound. Probably better to make all commitments and use all resources elsewhere in the first place.
Plonk a division of US Troops on Taiwan and the Chinese will make all sorts of noises and threats, but very likely to do nothing concrete about it. They understand clear messages and will use less direct means to get leverage.
 
Plonk a division of US Troops on Taiwan and the Chinese will make all sorts of noises and threats, but very likely to do nothing concrete about it. They understand clear messages and will use less direct means to get leverage.

After today’s meeting, that won’t happen. The US might even send ships to help Xi. All for “peace”.
 
Should be wary of Washington? Yes, but in two years or so the leadership will change. Hopefully its for the better.

In Russia and China the leadership will not change, barring an unforeseen circumstance. Be wary of them always.

Washington is not a threat, in my opinion.

There are certainly people who believe North America would be stronger, more prosperous, and more secure if Canada and the United States were more closely integrated, whether economically, politically, or strategically. That's not a new idea, nor is it necessarily rooted in hostility toward Canada.

The larger concern for me is that Canada needs to get its own house in order. Productivity, economic growth, regulatory burden, defence spending, and interprovincial trade barriers are all issues that need attention. If we fail to address those challenges and our economic position continues to weaken relative to the United States, we may eventually find ourselves with fewer options and less leverage than we'd like. Strong countries make choices. Weak countries have choices made for them.

I suspect that the most dangerous moment for Taiwan will be be in two years from early November to mid January.

You may find this interesting: Davidson Window.
 
Washington is not a threat, in my opinion.

There are certainly people who believe North America would be stronger, more prosperous, and more secure if Canada and the United States were more closely integrated, whether economically, politically, or strategically. That's not a new idea, nor is it necessarily rooted in hostility toward Canada.

The larger concern for me is that Canada needs to get its own house in order. Productivity, economic growth, regulatory burden, defence spending, and interprovincial trade barriers are all issues that need attention. If we fail to address those challenges and our economic position continues to weaken relative to the United States, we may eventually find ourselves with fewer options and less leverage than we'd like. Strong countries make choices. Weak countries have choices made for them.

Amen to that...

Meanwhile, some of the foundations are a bit shaky:

‘The house is in order,’ says Finance Minister as Canada’s deficit reaches $62.3B. What Budget 2026 means for you​

Ottawa expects to run a $62.3-billion deficit this year, and the interest on that debt now costs more than what the federal government sends the provinces for health care.

Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne tabled Budget 2026 on Nov. 5, 2026, with $142.1 billion in new tax incentives, spending and other measures over the next five years. Champagne believes Canada can afford it. "The house is in order. We have a strong fiscal position, and that gives us the strength to build," he said.

Economists, on the other hand, are less certain, and the gap between those views matters for your household. A larger interest bill leaves less room for services and tax relief, while heavy government borrowing can affect the rate you pay on a mortgage. Here's what the numbers show and how they could reach your wallet.

 
Amen to that...

Meanwhile, some of the foundations are a bit shaky:

‘The house is in order,’ says Finance Minister as Canada’s deficit reaches $62.3B. What Budget 2026 means for you​

Ottawa expects to run a $62.3-billion deficit this year, and the interest on that debt now costs more than what the federal government sends the provinces for health care.

Finance Minister François-Philippe Champagne tabled Budget 2026 on Nov. 5, 2026, with $142.1 billion in new tax incentives, spending and other measures over the next five years. Champagne believes Canada can afford it. "The house is in order. We have a strong fiscal position, and that gives us the strength to build," he said.

Economists, on the other hand, are less certain, and the gap between those views matters for your household. A larger interest bill leaves less room for services and tax relief, while heavy government borrowing can affect the rate you pay on a mortgage. Here's what the numbers show and how they could reach your wallet.


Minister Squeaky Voice...
 
I kind of like the guy.

He reminds me of what I might be like if I had to be the Finance Minister: endlessly grateful to have made it through yet another day at work, and showing it a little too much. :)

I will give him credit, for better or worse, he is all in on this Gov and its leader.
 
From linked article: "while heavy government borrowing can affect the rate you pay on a mortgage".

Oh dear. You mean there's no free lunch for the people obsessed with trying to buy homes?

"Hi, I'm a young voter and I'm pissed about the cost of housing. But I want all the "laws" of human economic behaviour to be suspended so I can vote for these guys."
 
You mean there's no free lunch for the people obsessed with trying to buy homes?

It's amazing how many people inherited favorable conditions by being born at the right time and have now convinced themselves they have exceptional financial wisdom.

Wanting what was once a normal middle-class outcome is apparently asking for the moon now.
 
It's amazing how many people inherited favorable conditions by being born at the right time and have now convinced themselves they have exceptional financial wisdom.

Wanting what was once a normal middle-class outcome is apparently asking for the moon now.
Middle-class home ownership as we might understand is a relatively recent innovation, along with well-compensated lifetime union company jobs and romantic marriage. Governments have done a good job limiting where and how people might choose to live and reducing the fraction of incomes for which the spending choices are made by the earners, and it turns out it is easier to locate employment in dense packs than housing.

To paraphrase Thatcher, the facts of life are and always have been conservative. If people want the normal middle class outcomes, they're going to have to consistently choose the politics that support those outcomes. I am entirely confident that means no NDP and only roughly half of the contemporary LPC.

Social programs are manpower-intensive, and as I've written before, over decades I suspect the Baumol Effect is causing costs to rise faster than productivity in those endeavours. We cannot divide-the-pie our way out of that one.
 
Middle-class home ownership as we might understand is a relatively recent innovation, along with well-compensated lifetime union company jobs and romantic marriage. Governments have done a good job limiting where and how people might choose to live and reducing the fraction of incomes for which the spending choices are made by the earners, and it turns out it is easier to locate employment in dense packs than housing.

To paraphrase Thatcher, the facts of life are and always have been conservative. If people want the normal middle class outcomes, they're going to have to consistently choose the politics that support those outcomes. I am entirely confident that means no NDP and only roughly half of the contemporary LPC.

Social programs are manpower-intensive, and as I've written before, over decades I suspect the Baumol Effect is causing costs to rise faster than productivity in those endeavours. We cannot divide-the-pie our way out of that one.

Craig From Friday GIF


You ok man ?
 
You ok man ?
People bitch about circumstances without understanding how circumstances arose. (Well, some understand but are just in denial and want to believe they can will different outcomes.) There aren't really any mysteries in life.

In 1920, wanting a 1960 outcome was wanting the moon. In 2026, wanting a 1976 outcome can be the same, depending on where you demand it happen. It's not hard to figure out how to get from A to B.
 
People bitch about circumstances without understanding how circumstances arose. (Well, some understand but are just in denial and want to believe they can will different outcomes.) There aren't really any mysteries in life.

In 1920, wanting a 1960 outcome was wanting the moon. In 2026, wanting a 1976 outcome can be the same, depending on where you demand it happen. It's not hard to figure out how to get from A to B.

The world will be a better place in 20-30 years. You continue to provide me proof and comfort in that.
 
The world will be a better place in 20-30 years. You continue to provide me proof and comfort in that.
It should be. Technology keeps extending productivity and reducing human welfare problems, provided we don't get over our skis. Some things people think we could do (eg. large-scale climate engineering) we just don't understand well enough. Some problems are too complex for centralized planning (climate, economics).

Even a series of major global conflicts would be only a temporary setback, provided nuclear exchanges are avoided. The Great Depression and WW II didn't last forever.
 
Back
Top