• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

LCBO theft

Costco claims it as a condition of membership and I'm not aware that it has been successfully challenged.
They can stop you walking in or they can order you to leave via trespass law, but any claim to a right to detain and/or search you is meaningless. Their authority is limited to cancelling your membership and banning you from the premises as trespass should you refuse.
 
They can stop you walking in or they can order you to leave via trespass law...

How do they actually stop someone from walking in? Do they have the authority or ability to physically prevent entry?

Or is the process simply to follow the person and wait for law enforcement to arrive and issue a trespass notice?

And what prevents that same individual from ignoring the trespass order and walking back in a week later?

I'm genuinely not trying to be argumentative. My concern is that paper orders, bonds, and similar measures have limited value when they're being imposed on people who have already demonstrated that they have little regard for our rules-based system in the first place.
 
That’s what it’s like in Manitoba now. If you don’t hand over your DL, the door doesn’t open. But you’re not trapped in the vestibule. You can always leave if they won’t let you in.

Nothing’s really to stop you if you walk out with a duffel bag of bottles, but now they have your ID info to hand over to the po-po.
It’s easier to enter the USA than a MLCC outlet 😉
 
How do they actually stop someone from walking in? Do they have the authority or ability to physically prevent entry?
Yes. If they so wish the law in Ontario (and probably everywhere) allows the occupier of a property to physically arrest a trespasser. That’s a lawful arrest and a person may use reasonable necessary force.
And what prevents that same individual from ignoring the trespass order and walking back in a week later?
That again depends on the willingness to do what trespass law allows them to do.

I'm genuinely not trying to be argumentative. My concern is that paper orders, bonds, and similar measures have limited value when they're being imposed on people who have already demonstrated that they have little regard for our rules-based system in the first place.
Yup, understood and agreed. This is one of those things where, like arrests for shoplifting, the law is more robust than many businesses are comfortable exercising. But it’s there.
 
It’s easier to enter the USA than a MLCC outlet 😉

Its very much my own personal belief that Alcohol needs to be very tightly controlled.

Not everyone is a good drunk, and people do horrible things when drunk.

I would keep it behind l lock and key and issue a license to be served or purchase alcohol, like a firearm. Which can be revoked.

AI ASSISTED Alcohol kills far more people in Canada each year than firearms do. [1, 2]

Alcohol-Related Deaths
    • Total Deaths: Alcohol consumption contributes to an estimated 15,000 to 18,000 deaths annually in Canada, encompassing chronic diseases (such as liver disease and multiple types of cancer) as well as acute harms like alcohol poisoning and impaired driving crashes. [1, 2, 3, 4, 5]
    • Impaired Driving: Alcohol is involved in roughly 70% of alcohol-related driving fatalities, with hundreds of Canadians dying in drunk-driving incidents each year (e.g., over 520 deaths in 2022). [1, 2]

Firearm-Related Deaths
    • Total Deaths: Firearms are involved in roughly 750 to 900 deaths per year nationally (with historical and recent multi-database reviews showing around 800–875 fatal firearm injuries annually). [1]
    • Breakdown of Intent: Roughly 75% to 80% of all firearm deaths in Canada are suicides, while roughly 15% to 20% are homicides, and a small percentage are accidental/unintentional. For context, police-reported firearm homicides typically number between 220 and 350 per year. [1, 2, 3, 4]
Overall, national public health data show that alcohol-related mortality is more than 15 to 20 times higher than total firearm-related mortality in Canada. [1, 2]

Google Search
 
Back
Top