- Reaction score
- 7,716
- Points
- 1,360
The heads of Sergeants Major across Russia are exploding....
Radio Free Europe/Radio Liberty, 14 Jan 13
Russian Miltary Dress/Eqpt Changes (merged)
- Thread starter The Bread Guy
- Start date
- Reaction score
- 2,915
- Points
- 940
Makes our rank inflation seem pretty tame, if they've got a LCol overseeing that. ;D
- Reaction score
- 3,104
- Points
- 1,160
wouldn't you love to do your 2 x 16 in those? Holy burger meat for feet, Batman.
- Reaction score
- 7,716
- Points
- 1,360
I was sorta wondering about how cushiony (not) they might be, too.Kat Stevens said:
- Reaction score
- 3,966
- Points
- 1,160
Back a couple of decades (or more) while on a course, I recall this item (and a demonstration of correct wear) being prominently featured in a training film (pretty sure it was a Soviet training film, sub-titled for our use), the intent of which was to familiarize us with our enemy of the day and instill a sense of their toughness. If they could march across the frozen steppes with only dish towels wrapped around their feet, then we must be more determined and better prepare ourselves to halt them when they attempt to cross the inner German border. As often happens when the occasional odd-sort in uniform is exposed to the unusual, one of the other junior officers on course thought he would toughen himself and be better prepared to face the Red hordes if he also forsook socks and started wearing "portyanki". For a while (a short while) he was a fan and proclaimed their superiority over socks, however the novelty wore off and he was soon back in "socks, wool, grey".
Only a LCol? I thought in the CF that one had to be at least a general officer before pouncing from behind potted shrubbery to check the correctness of undergarments.
Journeyman said:
Only a LCol? I thought in the CF that one had to be at least a general officer before pouncing from behind potted shrubbery to check the correctness of undergarments.
- Reaction score
- 2,915
- Points
- 940
To be fair, I believe he was only a Col when the grey sock thread-colour scandal broke.Blackadder1916 said:
- Reaction score
- 39,309
- Points
- 1,210
Journeyman said:To be fair, I believe he was only a Col when the grey sock thread-colour scandal broke.
And that experience served him well as a BGen when he would lurk behind potted plants to ensure the zippers on CANEX windbreakers were at the proper height.
In today's CF, though, we're joint, and using the same people to acquire such radically different items as air force toques and army toques.
I haven't heard about a PMO socks, but if we stand one up (under clothe the soldier, perhaps?) I'm sure we'll find it full of EME officers.
J
jollyjacktar
Guest
He was the Brigade Commander in Calgary when we were all checking our socks and other things. I didn't know he had a previous pattern of sock madness. His head exploded when he discovered some of the PPCLI with modified shirts on parade. Jimmy was special... :Journeyman said:To be fair, I believe he was only a Col when the grey sock thread-colour scandal broke.
OldSolduer
Army.ca Relic
- Reaction score
- 21,670
- Points
- 1,260
We have issues with new kit here, can you imagine what the Russians go through?
- Reaction score
- 0
- Points
- 210
My father was in USSR Army. He told me it was good for marching but not for everyday life.
- Reaction score
- 7,716
- Points
- 1,360
- Reaction score
- 2,915
- Points
- 940
For wear with DEU -- helmets and comms headsets aren't an issue.
- Reaction score
- 6,324
- Points
- 1,260
Journeyman said:
That's the spirit ... bring back garrison dress! :nod:
- Reaction score
- 39,309
- Points
- 1,210
E.R. Campbell said:That's the spirit ... bring back garrison dress! :nod:
I think the "Report to Mod" function is for posts like yours...
:'(
daftandbarmy
Army.ca Fossil
- Reaction score
- 44,539
- Points
- 1,160
Finally revealed... the real reason behind the Soviet policy of 'Glasnost' and building better links with the West. Nice to see a former super power having similar struggles to a 'middle power' like us:
Infantry: Another Uncomfortable Tradition Dies In Russia
November 15, 2013: This is the first Winter in which Russian soldiers have not worn Valenki. These are boots made from felt. In the West just about the only things you can still get made from felt are hats, but in Russia felt footwear has been popular for centuries. Felt is processed wool. Felt is relatively stiff and, like all wool products, is a good insulator and water resistant (not waterproof). Until the 20 th century, during the heart of the cold weather season, felt boots were the only way for Russians to go outside and not get frostbitten feet. While felt has been around for over 1,500 years, felt boots did not appear until the 1700s and only became cheap enough for widespread use in the 19th century, when their manufacture could be automated. Before that felt boots were very much a luxury item. By the late 19th century they were a mass market product and the Russian Army was a major customer.
But felt boots are not as study as leather ones and are useless in periods when there is a lot of slush or any rain at all. In times like that you need to wear the felt boots inside some rubberized footwear to keep them dry. While very useful during World War II, when even the German soldiers would steal felt boots from dead Russians and use them, the felt boots usually did not last more than one season, especially if you were in combat or worked outside regularly.
So now the Russian military is switching over to Western style cold weather footwear. This means Russia is also replacing the traditional rugged (and crudely made) slip on boots and foot wrappings as well. Western style combat boots that use laces, come in many different sizes, and are meant to be used with socks are much more popular (and familiar) to most Russians. Felt boots have been out of fashion for urban Russians for decades. Most Russians are also unfamiliar with the foot wrappings (“portyanki”) that soldiers were still taught to use. For portyanki to work the user has to wrap their feet just so before slipping the foot into the “tarpaulin” boots. If you did not do the wrapping correctly some of your flesh would be exposed to the rough inside surface of these canvas boots. This usually leads to debilitating blisters. The old-fashioned boots were widely disliked by most of the troops forced to use them. The number of older officers who still favored this 19th century footwear are also fading away. So the portyanki and valenki are officially gone this year, along with the old canvas boots that only came in two sizes.
What the Russians are using instead is what the United States has learned from twelve years of combat operations in Afghanistan. That forced the United States to develop several generations of combat boots for troops fighting in the rocky hills, freezing cold, and scorching heat found there. Every two or three years a new boot design was created and issued. Each generation of boot had fewer problems and the latest iteration (the HWMCB, for Hot Weather Mountain Combat Boot) has generated the fewest complaints. The HWMCB has a lot of little tweaks to the previous design with the biggest difference being that the new boot is 200 gr (7 ounces) lighter than the last one. Russians on the Internet were more interested in American cold weather boots, which were easier to develop than hot weather models.
http://www.strategypage.com/htmw/htinf/articles/20131115.aspx
Infantry: Another Uncomfortable Tradition Dies In Russia
November 15, 2013: This is the first Winter in which Russian soldiers have not worn Valenki. These are boots made from felt. In the West just about the only things you can still get made from felt are hats, but in Russia felt footwear has been popular for centuries. Felt is processed wool. Felt is relatively stiff and, like all wool products, is a good insulator and water resistant (not waterproof). Until the 20 th century, during the heart of the cold weather season, felt boots were the only way for Russians to go outside and not get frostbitten feet. While felt has been around for over 1,500 years, felt boots did not appear until the 1700s and only became cheap enough for widespread use in the 19th century, when their manufacture could be automated. Before that felt boots were very much a luxury item. By the late 19th century they were a mass market product and the Russian Army was a major customer.
But felt boots are not as study as leather ones and are useless in periods when there is a lot of slush or any rain at all. In times like that you need to wear the felt boots inside some rubberized footwear to keep them dry. While very useful during World War II, when even the German soldiers would steal felt boots from dead Russians and use them, the felt boots usually did not last more than one season, especially if you were in combat or worked outside regularly.
So now the Russian military is switching over to Western style cold weather footwear. This means Russia is also replacing the traditional rugged (and crudely made) slip on boots and foot wrappings as well. Western style combat boots that use laces, come in many different sizes, and are meant to be used with socks are much more popular (and familiar) to most Russians. Felt boots have been out of fashion for urban Russians for decades. Most Russians are also unfamiliar with the foot wrappings (“portyanki”) that soldiers were still taught to use. For portyanki to work the user has to wrap their feet just so before slipping the foot into the “tarpaulin” boots. If you did not do the wrapping correctly some of your flesh would be exposed to the rough inside surface of these canvas boots. This usually leads to debilitating blisters. The old-fashioned boots were widely disliked by most of the troops forced to use them. The number of older officers who still favored this 19th century footwear are also fading away. So the portyanki and valenki are officially gone this year, along with the old canvas boots that only came in two sizes.
What the Russians are using instead is what the United States has learned from twelve years of combat operations in Afghanistan. That forced the United States to develop several generations of combat boots for troops fighting in the rocky hills, freezing cold, and scorching heat found there. Every two or three years a new boot design was created and issued. Each generation of boot had fewer problems and the latest iteration (the HWMCB, for Hot Weather Mountain Combat Boot) has generated the fewest complaints. The HWMCB has a lot of little tweaks to the previous design with the biggest difference being that the new boot is 200 gr (7 ounces) lighter than the last one. Russians on the Internet were more interested in American cold weather boots, which were easier to develop than hot weather models.
http://www.strategypage.com/htmw/htinf/articles/20131115.aspx
- Reaction score
- 36
- Points
- 560
Look at the time lines and you realize there is only one real comment to be made:
Hire those guys
After seeing 12 years frittered away for a rucksack and still waiting for combat boots after how many years, I would also suggest sentencing the people in charge of clothing and equipment procurment to stripped of all their field kit (to be reissued to soldiers in field units) and given portyanki to wear. Maybe they might see the need for a bit of urgency in their job at that point....
Hire those guys
After seeing 12 years frittered away for a rucksack and still waiting for combat boots after how many years, I would also suggest sentencing the people in charge of clothing and equipment procurment to stripped of all their field kit (to be reissued to soldiers in field units) and given portyanki to wear. Maybe they might see the need for a bit of urgency in their job at that point....
OldSolduer
Army.ca Relic
- Reaction score
- 21,670
- Points
- 1,260
In Russia boots wear you.
You no wear boots.
You no wear boots.
Similar threads
