I have my 73 Charger stuffed in the garage right now,
Duey- How did I just know that you still had that Charger...If you went up Recruit Hill with that thing 5 mph faster in 1986, you would still be in low Earth orbit.
I'm going to put an early defence in on the VW. My wife and I have a 2005 VW Jetta TDI wagon and have not had a problem in 23K. The Wagons are made in Wolfsburg, not Mexico so there may be quality control differences. Anyway, we came across Canada this summer from Victoria to Halifax, loaded to the rafters, with lots of touristy type city driving- on 440 litres. Made it from Ottawa to Fredtown on one tank o' diesel. No issues, whatsoever (knock on wood).
We found the service excellent in Naniamo (where we bought it) and at the Dartmouth VW. Admittedly, the service sucked in Victoria, which, coincidentally, also is a Porsche dealer. My thoughts- don't deal with a VW dealership that also sells Porsche- you will finish second everytime at the service department.
Back to the car- we found it has tons of power and rides well. The interior is a bit small for a tall guy like me, so the backseat is basically useless when I'm driving. Supposedly, the 2006's are 8 inches longer, which gets rid of that problem. I have heard about the electrical system issue with lights burning out, but it has not happened to us.
Oil changes are twice as expensive. The oil is $10/litre and a wierd synthetic that only comes from VW. On the other hand, you only have to get a oil change every 16K, which is more than double what I do on my also trouble free 2001 Nissan XTerra (love the truck- hate the mileage. Doesn't get driven alot at $1.18/litre).
Cheers!