• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

The Sandbox and Areas Reports Thread (March 2008)

  • Thread starter Thread starter GAP
  • Start date Start date
Status
Not open for further replies.
A ray of light in the dark defile
The Western alliance is in trouble in Afghanistan. But France is ready to help take on the Taliban, and others still want to join NATO
(look at the charts, read the whole piece)
The Economist, March 27
http://www.economist.com/displayStory.cfm?story_id=10919203&fsrc=nwlptwfree

ANOTHER fighting season beckons in Afghanistan, and the strain is beginning to tell. Many European countries are weary of the war, America is growing tired of reluctant allies and Afghans are becoming disenchanted. Still, NATO says it retains the initiative: the Taliban have been forced to abandon set-piece battles in favour of “asymmetric” suicide-bombs.

This is brave talk. Last year was the bloodiest yet, with more than 230 Western soldiers killed. Opium-poppy production is at a record high, financing the Taliban and corrupting the government in Kabul. The old truth of counter-insurgency still holds: armies can win every battle, yet lose the will to fight an intractable war.

Paddy Ashdown, the British politician and ex-commando who was nearly appointed as the United Nations' envoy to Kabul, makes the point by quoting “Arithmetic on the Frontier”, a poem by Rudyard Kipling describing the British empire's troubles fighting Afghan tribesmen armed with the jezail, a home-made musket:

In such a fight against a weaker but elusive enemy, says Kipling, “the odds are on the cheaper man”...
http://whitewolf.newcastle.edu.au/words/authors/K/KiplingRudyard/verse/vol1/arithmeticfrontier.html

...out of the gloom comes some hope, in the dashing form of Nicolas Sarkozy. Despite the Bush administration's unpopularity in Europe, the French president has gone out of his way to befriend America and wants France to rejoin NATO's integrated military structure, from which de Gaulle withdrew in 1966. Even better, French forces hitherto deployed in Kabul seem ready to fight the Taliban. Mr Sarkozy is expected to announce in Bucharest the deployment of about 1,000 French soldiers alongside the Americans in eastern Afghanistan. This would release some American forces to move to Kandahar, keep the Canadians in Afghanistan and, perhaps, encourage others to do more.

A further measure of support may come from another unexpected quarter: Russia. For all the Kremlin's rage about NATO enlargement and American missile defences in Europe, President Vladimir Putin has been invited to Bucharest, where he may sign an agreement opening up air and land routes through Russia to supply NATO forces in Afghanistan...

Within Europe, only Britain and France (both nuclear powers) have a tradition of wielding military force far afield. But these days both are struggling with overstretched equipment budgets. Whether because of national pride, incompatible priorities or the desire to prop up domestic industries, European defence spending is fragmented and duplicative. A study for the European Parliament in 2006 found that Europeans operate four models of tanks, compared with one in America; 16 kinds of armoured vehicles compared with three American ones; 11 types of frigates versus one in America. The NATO Response Force (NRF), a 25,000-strong package of land, sea and air contingents meant to be ready for action at five days' notice, was supposed to help transform static European armies into nimbler forces. But barely a year after the NRF was declared operational, NATO admits the Europeans are too stretched to meet its requirements.

With deployments in the Balkans, the Middle East and Africa, many European countries are close to the limit of what they can sustain in terms of overseas operations. A NATO source reckons that, short of all-out war, only 10,000 more troops can be squeezed out of Europe. Helicopters fit for war zones are scarce everywhere. Any hope of a big increase in military resources in Afghanistan must await a reduction of American forces in Iraq...

Mark
Ottawa
 
Articles found March 31, 2008

Six weeks worth of mail greets Canadian gunners in Afghanistan
Article Link

KANDAHAR PROVINCE, Afghanistan — It's a time-honoured tradition that's been around for as long as parents have been watching their children go off to war, and if this week's haul is any indication, it's alive and well.

Six weeks' worth of mail - letters, parcels, care packages and even telephone and utility bills - landed Thursday in the midst of the dusty outpost that's currently home to the gunners of C Troop, B Battery from the 1st Royal Canadian Horse Artillery, based in Shilo, Man.

Within days of their arrival in Afghanistan last month, C Troop's first rotation saw them spirited away to Maywand district, on the edge of the border with Helmand province, to support the Royal Gurkha Rifles, an elite British light infantry regiment.

Before the mail had a chance to catch them up, however, they were moved again, back to the slightly more hospitable confines of a patrol base familiar to Canadian troops, in a part of the province where the Canadians have done the bulk of their work.

On Thursday, their mail finally showed up, piled on the back of a Gator utility vehicle driven by Warrant Officer Shane Clouthier, the troop's sergeant-major.

"After a month and a half of not seeing mail, they start getting a little edgy," Clouthier laughed about the soldiers under his command.
More on link

Mock advance trains reservists
By By ALEX MCCUAIG Mar 31, 2008, 04:26
  Article Link

SUFFIELD — The face of the Canadian Forces reserve units is changing quite literally, as older, more experienced soldiers begin to fill the ranks of the regular army in Afghanistan.
This new breed of soldiers is mostly too young to remember the country’s peacekeeping missions in the Balkans or Somalia but are the first generation of troops who have grown up in the post 9/11 Canada. What was considered the “new normal” after those attacks is their normal.
Some reserve units are seeing a good chunk of their troops take positions overseas, leaving behind the smooth-skinned teenagers, and young men and women whose faces dominated the landscape of the weekend’s exercises at Canadian Forces Base Suffield.
The war games encompassed the South Alberta Light Horse (SALH), 18th Air Defence, 20th Royal Canadian Artillery, King’s Own Calgary and 15th Field Regiments in an artillery support role of a mock British Forces advance along the Helmand-Kandahar provincial border in Afghanistan.
One commander called the operation, “the little exercise that grew,” after several Alberta units decided to join the 18th and 20th Regiment’s artillery training.
Capt. Scott Payne of the SALH said most of his regiment’s privates are between 16 and 21 years of age, with many of the officers being under the age of 37.
More on link

Tim Hortons franchise in Afghanistan a raging success
Matthew Fisher, Canwest News Service Published: Thursday, March 27, 2008
Article Link

KANDAHAR AIRFIELD, Afghanistan - A newly arrived British soldier actually thought the hugely popular and profitable Department of National Defence-owned Tim Hortons franchise at this noisy airbase was a religious cult.

"Once he got to know us, he realized we clearly were not a church group," said Amy Barbarie of Sault Ste. Marie, who landed what she called 'the best job in the world,' serving thousands of Canadian and NATO troops deployed here to fight the Taliban and al-Qaida.

Of all the troops who crowd the Tim's counter, or queue at the 'walk thru' window outside, Barbarie's personal favourites have been the Royal Gurkhas, the diminutive, but notoriously lethal Nepalese mercenaries who have fought for the British Army for nearly two centuries.
More on link

Canada's soldiers of misfortune
By KATHLEEN HARRIS, NATIONAL BUREAU CHIEF
Article Link

OTTAWA -- Soldiers who lose limbs, sight or hearing to roadside blasts or training accidents deserve more cash, say MPs who are demanding changes to the military amputee and injury compensation program.

They also want to see parity in compensation for part-time reservists.

Under 2003 guidelines, most Canadian Forces members are eligible for a maximum lump-sum payment of $250,000 if they lose both feet or hands or suffer another permanent major injury.

The figure is $125,000 for the loss of a single body part.

Some classes of reservists on service of less than six months see their claims capped at $100,000 and are eligible for only half or, in some cases, one quarter of the dismemberment claims for regular forces.
More on link

Visions of family for troops
Free portrait sessions keep soldiers in the picture
Trish Audette, The Edmonton Journal Published: Sunday, March 30
Article Link

When Warrant Officer Dave Shultz goes on tour -- to Bosnia, Kosovo and now to Afghanistan -- the 39-year-old brings a single photo album with him.

The album is the story of his life in pictures, from the days before he married his wife Jennifer through to the arrival of his sons Ethan, 21/2, and Jett, six months.

It was his idea, Jennifer Shultz explained Saturday, for his family to take advantage of "Operation Homefront," providing free family portraits for Edmonton soldiers in Afghanistan
More on link

Tories bar opposition members from NATO summit
Article Link

OTTAWA — Opposition members are furious that the Tory government has rescinded an invitation for them to take part in the NATO leaders summit, where the future of Canada's Afghan mission will be decided.

The Liberal, New Democratic and Bloc Quebecois defence critics were invited to accompany Defence Minister Peter MacKay to the meeting in Bucharest, Romania, next week.

The Department of Defence sent out the invitations, but then revoked them on Wednesday, saying that NATO had limited the size of the Canadian delegation.

A spokesman for the military alliance has denied a cap on delegates has been set.

"The official Opposition has tried at every opportunity to work in a constructive fashion regarding our mission in Afghanistan, but once again we see from this government an unacceptable level of partisanship, going so far as to hide the facts from Canadians," said Liberal defence critic Denis Coderre.
More on link

Canadian gunners in Afghanistan grow frustrated as airstrikes take precedence
Published: Friday, March 28, 2008 | 1:33 PM ET Canadian Press: James Mccarten, THE CANADIAN PRESS
Article Link

KANDAHAR PROVINCE, Afghanistan - The fighter jet, probably an F-16, came from nowhere, invisible under cover of night as it unleashed a short but deadly burst of gunfire with a sound that seemed to rip a hole in the darkness.

Seconds later, an orange streak of light appeared as the jet fired up its afterburners and beat a hasty retreat, its mission over.

With that, so too was the latest fire mission for the dejected Canadian gunners on the hilltop nearby, mortars in hand and at the ready, firing tubes locked on the very same target.

"Get out of here," one gunner muttered under his breath, half-jokingly, moments earlier amid the distinctive sound of approaching aircraft.

Don't get them wrong: the gunners of C Troop, B Battery, from 1 Royal Canadian Horse Artillery, based in Shilo, Man., realize they're just one part of a larger objective in Afghanistan.

But they've grown familiar with the sound of incoming "fast air" and what it's likely to mean for the chance that they'll fire their considerable weapons - it's happened several times in recent days.
More on link

Poland expected to offer more Afghan choppers until Canadian Chinooks arrive.
March 30, 2008 - 1:50 pm By: Murray Brewster, THE CANADIAN PRESS
Article Link

OTTAWA - On the eve of a crucial NATO summit, Poland appears ready to increase its offer of helicopter support for Canadian troops in Afghanistan who are awaiting the arrival of their own transports.

As many as four additional Mi-17 helicopters could be stationed at Kandahar airfield, bringing to six the number of aircraft the Polish government would put at the disposal of Canadians, defence sources told The Canadian Press.

The arrangement could be in place by this summer and last up to a year - long enough for National Defence to purchase and deploy six of its own CH-47D Chinook battlefield helicopters, said a source who spoke on condition of anonymity.
More on link

French fume at plan to boost Afghanistan force
2008/03/28
Article Link

PRESIDENT Nicolas Sarkozy came under fire at home yesterday for offering to send more French troops to Afghanistan in an address to the British parliament that was seen as a snub to French lawmakers.

Socialist Segolene Royal and the leader of her party opposed the plan for deepening French military involvement, while several lawmakers called for a full debate in the French National Assembly.

Far-right leader Jean-Marie Le Pen charged that Sarkozy had “offended the nation” by announcing the beefed-up mission in his speech to Westminster on Wednesday, on the first day of his state visit to Britain. France has about 1600 soldiers in Afghanistan.

Deputy Jacques Myard, a member of Sarkozy’s Union for a Popular Movement party, said the decision highlighted France’s “alignment with American positions at a time when Washington’s foreign policy is an almost total failure.” — Sapa-AFP
More on link

Two British soldiers killed in Afghanistan
Article Link

KABUL (AFP) — Explosions killed two British soldiers and wounded five Dutch troopers in Afghanistan at the weekend while a dozen Taliban were killed in security operations, military forces said Monday.

The violence occurred in southern Afghanistan, where Taliban militants focus their attacks in an insurgency launched after the hardline movement regrouped after being driven from government in late 2001 in a US-led invasion.

The Britons, Royal Marines, were killed in the southern province of Helmand on Sunday when an explosion blew up their vehicle, British Lieutenant Colonel Simon Millar told AFP.

They had been on a routine patrol near the remote Kajaki Dam, a vital water and power source for Helmand which the British military has been holding since Taliban were driven out nearly two years ago.

"The actual cause of the explosion is still being investigated," Millar said.

The pair were airlifted to a hospital at the biggest camp in Helmand, the British-run Bastion, where one was pronounced dead on arrival and the other died subsequently.
More on link

Opium Brides on the Rise in Afghanistan as Government Moves to Eradicate Opium Production
Article Link

NEW YORK, March 30, 2008 /PRNewswire via COMTEX/ -- As Afghanistan steps up its efforts to eradicate poppy crops, many poor farmers who rely on profits from the plants have had to sell their daughters to settle their debts from local traffickers who provide loans in exchange for opium. Many farmers have spent much of their lives raising opium in the stony hillsides of eastern Afghanistan and on the dusty southern plains since it is the only reliable cash crop.

In the April 7 issue of Newsweek (on newsstands Monday, March 31), Afghanistan Correspondent Sami Yousafzai and South Asia Bureau Chief Ron Moreau report that the practice began with the dowry a bridegroom's family traditionally pays to the bride's father in tribal Pashtun society. These days the amount ranges from $3,000 or so in poorer places like Laghman and Nangarhar to $8,000 or more in Helmand, Afghanistan's No. 1 opium-growing province. For a desperate farmer, that bride price can be salvation -- but at a cruel cost. Among the Pashtun, debt marriage puts a lasting stain on the honor of the bride and her family. It brings shame on the country, too. President Hamid Karzai recently told the nation: "I call on the people [not to] give their daughters for money; they shouldn't give them to old men, and they shouldn't give them in forced marriages."
More on link

Afghanistan adrift in misplaced aid
By Aunohita Mojumdar
Article Link

KABUL - A map of Afghanistan dotted with colorful pins adorned the wall in the office of the aid agency official. Looking with relish at the embellished map, the official stuck in a handful more, noting with a sigh of satisfaction the increase in the number of "projects completed".

For several years, reconstruction in Afghanistan has been a "drawing board and drawing pin" approach, with aid delivery overwhelmingly focused on numbers, quick delivery, high visibility, meeting benchmarks, a production line approach to the rebuilding of a nation.

However, the short-term, low-cost approach of the donor community is coming under increasing criticism from development
More on link

Kiwi patrol hit by roadside bomb in Afghanistan
2:44PM Monday March 31, 2008
Article Link

Four New Zealand soldiers in Afghanistan were fortunate to escape without injury after a roadside device exploded next to their patrol vehicle today.

A four-vehicle New Zealand Defence Force patrol from the provincial reconstruction team (PRT) was travelling to a village near the border of the Baghlan province with a doctor to set up a mobile medical clinic.

An improvised explosive device (IED) went off beside one of the vehicles, damaging the front and smashing the windscreen, but no shrapnel reached the four occupants.

While IEDs are commonly used in Afghanistan it was the first time NZDF personnel had encountered one.

NZDF spokesman Captain Zac Prendergast said the vehicles were not armoured and the occupants said they were lucky to get off with just cosmetic damage.

"The crater it made was 70cm across and 30cm deep. The dirt is quite hard-packed so there's fair whack of an explosion that's gone up.

"It obviously is a major threat to us and that's why there's drills and a high awareness of these."
More on link
 
Status
Not open for further replies.
Back
Top