• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Army Reserve Restructuring

I interviewed quite a few reservists who went over (including reserve officers incidentally). Almost to a man they complained about the homecoming. They were separated almost instantly from the guys they had just shared the most intense year of their life with and felt quite alone (unless they were lucky enough to have a buddy from the same unit who went over at the same time). The problem was identified early on but never fixed.

Thank you for your service through 100+ contacts...

And then the (never deployed) CO and RSM unload on you because you're wearing a coyote coloured dump pouch and don't have scrim on your helmet ...

... because that's the most important thing ;)
 
And then the (never deployed) CO and RSM unload on you because you're wearing a coyote coloured dump pouch and don't have scrim on your helmet ...
Funny story. The only complaint of that type was from a RegF MWO who was pissed because the stay-at-home RSM told the MWO to get himself and his returning boys to get back into Woodland and stop wearing the Arid tan around base. They thought they'd earned a few days to show off. The RSM thought otherwise.

🍻
 
Interesting observation as my Son had some interesting stories here in Halifax after his tours . It seems the PLF sent many non commissioned to the Sandbox but very few of the Professional Student Officer's went. LOTS of tension and far less discipline or respect from the guys that went towards the Student/Officers.
Sort of reminds me of the RESO programme. Great training, but the candidates only commanded their peers, not soldiers.

In some cases they found it difficult on a weekend FTX. They did not understand that the soldiers were not as knowledgeable as their fellow candidates on their RESO course.

Seldom went to the annual MILCON as they were on course. Commanding a Pl for 2 days or so is a lot different than a week.
 
If he doesn't, dig deep. I know people first-hand. At most the policy might have been unofficial.
That can happen. Another complication is that many of the returning RegF folks after a tour went on leave in short order anyway so it's pretty much six of one and half a dozen of the other.

There's a key area where the CAF needed to concentrate on and that is post-tour administration including medical assistance for reservists. For the most part returning reservists are located in cities or towns where such services aren't provided. In some cases, even if there was a facility, the staff there (since they weren't at one of the six or so major military bases used to dealing with deployed regulars) the staff had little in the way of information as to how to deal with reservists.

I have no idea if or how the system has improved since organizations are quick to forget wartime lessons when war stops.

🍻
 
If he doesn't, dig deep. I know people first-hand. At most the policy might have been unofficial.
I've just hear back from Mark.

"In all the interviews Kevin and I did—many with reservists and also battery group commanders and task force commanders—nobody mentioned this. A constant stated regret was that the reservists were basically just sent back to their unit with some not even returning with the unit to its home base.

I doubt there was any policy to allow reservists to stick with the unit or Kevin and I would have heard of it in those interviews."

I think that you are right. Any circumstances like you describe must have been unofficial.

I know that in most of the people I talked to (the pre 2009 crowd) they went straight back to their home units and given 3.5 paid days (What bean counter comes up with a number like that?) which, in some cases, resulted in them being put to GD work in the armouries like sweeping floors etc.

I have to capsulize and generalize, but in my years of experience I sum up the RegF attitude to reservists as "what have you done for me today?" Almost everyone loved the Class C reservists that they had with them on deployment. And in Ottawa everyone loves the Class Bs in their cubicles. OTOH, the general attitude towards Class As doing their training at the armories is that they are wastrels consuming resources that could be better used elsewhere. It's a challenge.

🍻
 
I have to capsulize and generalize, but in my years of experience I sum up the RegF attitude to reservists as "what have you done for me today?" Almost everyone loved the Class C reservists that they had with them on deployment. And in Ottawa everyone loves the Class Bs in their cubicles. OTOH, the general attitude towards Class As doing their training at the armories is that they are wastrels consuming resources that could be better used elsewhere. It's a challenge.

🍻

Probably because the Reg F usually engaged more with the people at my rank level + than the NCMs ;)
 
Because Reserves are all about preparing for war
You know as a young kid I grew up and played in the ruins of a bombed out Berlin. A bit later and going into teenagerhood I was watching atomic and hydrogen bomb testing going on and learning how to hide in a culvert or under my school desk when the big one came. That segued into having Walter Cronkite show videos of dead and dying American boys my age in Vietnam while I was training to stop the Russian horde from crossing the Fulda Gap.

Then everything turned relatively peaceful. Communism slowly died out in Europe and morphed in China. Our army dwindled to a shadow of itself. Life got better a bit at a time and wars were someone else's problem. And there were some but they were remote. Things took a turn when terrorism started blowing up buildings here and there but even with us in Afghanistan the whole thing still seemed distant.

And then a handful of geriatric assholes in high places with access to nukes started doing stupid stuff. For the first time in my life I'm worried about what kind world I'll be leaving my grandkids to grow up in.

🍻
 
looks like we are taking a page from the Swedish and Fin's with home guard civil defense model for this new third reserve

 
looks like we are taking a page from the Swedish and Fin's with home guard civil defense model for this new third reserve


Nothing like choosing an organizational model that's failing miserably in the rest of society upon which to rest your national defense plans. It's almost as if someone in Ottawa didn't take a few seconds to google this information ;)

 
Nothing like choosing an organizational model that's failing miserably in the rest of society upon which to rest your national defense plans. It's almost as if someone in Ottawa didn't take a few seconds to google this information ;)


In this, as in everything else in life, it is all about marketing. Those countries that succeed have populations that have been given reasons to believe in their countries and opportunities to help effectively.

And frankly, broken down old geezers hobbling around casting aspersions on those that offer to help and saying "you'll never make the soldier i was, lass" do not improve the odds.
 
In this, as in everything else in life, it is all about marketing. Those countries that succeed have populations that have been given reasons to believe in their countries and opportunities to help effectively.

And frankly, broken down old geezers hobbling around casting aspersions on those that offer to help and saying "you'll never make the soldier i was, lass" do not improve the odds.

Even huge non-profits with massive marketing budgets are struggling to attract volunteers.

Again, and I don't know how they came up with this in the first place, this idea smacks of a lack of thoughtful analysis of the data and sounds more like 'let's give this a shot'...
 
You know as a young kid I grew up and played in the ruins of a bombed out Berlin. A bit later and going into teenagerhood I was watching atomic and hydrogen bomb testing going on and learning how to hide in a culvert or under my school desk when the big one came. That segued into having Walter Cronkite show videos of dead and dying American boys my age in Vietnam while I was training to stop the Russian horde from crossing the Fulda Gap.

Then everything turned relatively peaceful. Communism slowly died out in Europe and morphed in China. Our army dwindled to a shadow of itself. Life got better a bit at a time and wars were someone else's problem. And there were some but they were remote. Things took a turn when terrorism started blowing up buildings here and there but even with us in Afghanistan the whole thing still seemed distant.

And then a handful of geriatric assholes in high places with access to nukes started doing stupid stuff. For the first time in my life I'm worried about what kind world I'll be leaving my grandkids to grow up in.

🍻

I walked past a bombsite on my way to school everyday in the early sixties and learned to ride my bike on overgrown runways while playing in the trenches and bunkers of abandoned airstrips.

We came to Canada shortly after a conversation with my Dad where he had been demonstrating the non-Hollywood way to safely handle my toy guns and effectively use my knife and break a neck. Enthralled with all of this my eight year old self observed that my Dad had served, all my uncles had served, both my grandads had served and so had my Dad's mum. They had served during two world wars separated by about 25 years. At the time BBC was running a commemorative war series called 25 Years Ago. Putting two and two together, and noting that the last National Servicemen were just being released while the news was full of Borneo ans Sarawk, I asked if I would have to go to war. The converstion stopped and was never broached again. two years later we were in Canada.
 
Even huge non-profits with massive marketing budgets are struggling to attract volunteers.

Again, and I don't know how they came up with this in the first place, this idea smacks of a lack of thoughtful analysis of the data and sounds more like 'let's give this a shot'...

This will remain a point of disagreement.
You see people with guns that aren't Commandos.
I see a harder target than Canada backed by people given guns and willing to use them in defense of the lives that they enjoy.
 
This will remain a point of disagreement.
You see people with guns that aren't Commandos.
I see a harder target than Canada backed by people given guns and willing to use them in defense of the lives that they enjoy.
Easy win.

Anyone in the MRES will be able to own restricted firearms.

Good incentive to sign up. Fills your want to have a hardened target. And we have a ready list of restricted gun owners.
 
Back
Top