Right. I think it comes down to celebrity power. Many people associate a leaders popularity (and CV) with themselves. Some kind of vicarious transfer of status.
Looking at that graph it took 9 years for Trudeau to start losing popularity. Trudeau didn't lose popularity because of one incident. His supporters looked the other way at blackface, at sexually assaulting a reporter, at the WE scandal, so on and so on. He finally started losing popularity when he became too much of an embarrassment on the world stage, and it wasn't cool to be a Trudeau fan anymore. People didn't see themselves in Trudeau. Liberal support was declining in 2012 until Trudeau
threw his hat in. A star was born. Remember how obsessed people became with him?
Fast forward to 2025 you can see the exact moment where Poilievre
mysteriously blew his 30 point lead. Quite the immediate and sharp increase in Liberal support. Only it's not mystery , a new celebrity stepped in the ring. "Carney is always the smartest man in the room" and "If you disagree with Carney you're just wrong" seemed to be the theme of his supporters. They were beside themselves with CV and accomplishments. Many of whom just months before would lament about evil corporate elitists' and the Conservatives relationship with them. As you can see by that graph, Carney steps in and it's Trudeau mania all over again. Instant start power.
So what?
Conservatives picking a new party leader would be practically useless. Carney's supporters aren't going to abandon someone like him over something insignificant like going over budget half a trillion dollars or going back on campaign promises. A new CPC leader will make a few of us feel better, in the end it's just exposing the new guy to fire for longer. Who in Canada could match Carney's celebrity power? Any new CPC contender will instantly and aggressively be compared to Trump. A new CPC leader doesn't even begin standing a chance until after November 2028. Probably even 2030.