• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

18 Aug 2025: Poilievre/By-election in Battle River–Crowfoot (AB)

IMO the Conservatives are not government electable right now. Poliviere is so "mean".

And that's all it takes to sink a potential PM.

I think PP would actually make a good Prime Minister. However, I think you're also right that, in politics, perception and public sentiment often matter more than policy or competence.

At this point, PP appears to be unelectable. In my view, he needs to step aside and allow an interim leader to take the reins while the party does some soul-searching and determines what direction it wants to take before selecting a new leader.

Right now, he has become a sea anchor for the CPC. That's just my opinion, but I think his presence is doing more to hold the party back than move it forward.
 
At least for now in the yellow - with as volatile a leader as POTUS47, lots can still happen.

I probably should have used the past tense in my original wording.

I'm starting to sense a disturbance in the Force, and I think they've reached the peak of their popularity.

In my view, it will be the cost-of-living crisis that ultimately topples this government and the party, with Liberal arrogance serving as the icing on the cake.

The only thing holding that outcome at bay right now is the absence of a credible alternative from the CPC.

But the pressure keeps building, and it feels like something has to give sooner or later.
 
I probably should have used the past tense in my original wording.

I'm starting to sense a disturbance in the Force, and I think they've reached the peak of their popularity.

In my view, it will be the cost-of-living crisis that ultimately topples this government and the party, with Liberal arrogance serving as the icing on the cake.

The only thing holding that outcome at bay right now is the absence of a credible alternative from the CPC.

But the pressure keeps building, and it feels like something has to give sooner or later.
I don't know if I think PMMC is that close to peak yet, but I feel the pressure building a bit, too, especially on the cost of living.
 
I don't have an issue with individuals who hate the LPC because they allowed a woke, environmentalist agenda pull Canadian policies way to the left of the spectrum. It is a very valid sentiment. It would be great if some of them could admit that if nothing else, PMMC has attempted to bring things back a little more to the centre.

As a someone who sits in the middle of the political spectrum, who leans a little more right as I age, I have concerns that PP could not keep policy in the centre of the spectrum. I believe the fear of many in my position is that by electing him, and the Conservative party, would see an immediate shift to far right conservative policy like we saw in the USA.

Part of me can't understand how given what I would expect his personal beliefs must align with given his family background, he can allow some of the far right ideology influence the party as much as it does.
 
Gives the party a chance to pick a leader that has a decent chance to ramp up an approach (a new one, maybe?) to 1) effectively but loyally provide opposition to the current government during a tough time, and 2) start building themselves up as a potential next PM.
I think we’re witnessing the early stages of a decline within the current LPC and PMMC. It behooves the CPC to recognize this moment, move on from its current leadership, and begin the process of finding someone who can articulate a credible alternative to what the current government is offering—someone who can do so without being weighed down by the baggage of cultural politics.

It took Canadians 10 years to finally signal it was time for Trudeau to leave, and the minute he did, his (or the party depending how you see it) popularity immediately started to climb again.

It's still the same voter base. A new leader for the CPC now means 2 or 3 years of character assassination vs 1 year of character assassination.

PMMC campaigned on spending less. PBO just reported that federal government spending is $331.6 billion higher across the three spending plans tabled under him. Do people really care? I suspect a new party leader would be raising the exact same concerns Poilievre is, they might just be more polite about it. I don't think decorum will be enough to sway anyone from PMMC's celebrity power for quite a while.
 
It took Canadians 10 years to finally signal it was time for Trudeau to leave, and the minute he did, his (or the party depending how you see it) popularity immediately started to climb again.

It's still the same voter base ...
And it took a change of leadership of Team Blue in September 2022 (marked with purple bars) for their fortunes to climb for more than 2 years with the same voter base, too (source).
Screenshot 2026-11-18 100437.jpg
 
I would like to throw a small observation. Does it amount to anything? I don't know. Just my observation.

So last may, got a phone call and caller shows "Nanos", eagerly I answer my cell. It was Nanos polling and asked if I would like to participate in a poll. I agreed. They asked for occupation so I first started with "Farmer..." and was promptly cut off. I was told they were looking for in town residents in Collingwood, Owen Sound and Kincardin. I still have a Collingwood cell# so they mistook me as an in town resident. I argued I should be able to speak. They replied "Your not the demograph we are looking for" Call ended.

Yes, for you doubters out there, this really happened.

Next, 2 weeks ago, I was invited to participate in Angus Reid polling (You get like a membership type thing), I signed up. Woo hoo, I get a say. Or do I? First poll was just get to know you. Second poll was basically my age, family and voting preferences. I answered as voting conservative last election. Next poll, I answer the preliminary questions on social media activity. I am stopped at the initial question stageas I am not the target audience they are looking for. OK. I fill out another poll answering how I feel immigration is polling, a few questions in and again, I am stopped and explained I am not who they are looking for. I go to do another poll on trade and stuff, I am stopped 3 questions in, too many people in the poll.

So when the fuck do I get to be heard?

How much faith are you putting in these polls being done honestly?
 
So when the fuck do I get to be heard?
Voting Election Day GIF by The Democrats

...and any time you reach out to the Councillor/Reeve/Mayor/MPP/MP that has been elected by your local peers to represent you at their particular level of Government.

Polling by private polling firms isn't done for the benefit of the public or to act as a voice for the public. It is a contracted service by an interested party to provide data on a specific subject and target audience that is in their interest.
 
On the Carney still "soaring in the polls" untouched. History repeats itself. The last ones to know that Carney is lower than a snake's belly in popularity will be the polling firms and the Liberals themselves. I do have a memory and I remember certain pollsters (and other political pundits) thinking Trudeau was ok and it wasn't really too bad until it got to summer and fall 2024, then it was undeniable that Trudeau was an election time bomb. And Jagmeet Singh failed miserably to capitalize on a golden political opportunity. It cost him his career and his party, which it appears the NDP will still not be nothing more than a fringe party.

Trump was the golden goose the floundering Liberals needed with banker Carney as the "saviour" of the party. A crisis that was already packaged up, ready to go and to be sold to the Canadian population. One massive media propaganda campaign, that saw an interesting vote change as boomers really fell for him (Go back and look at old polls broken down by age group, and it was mostly boomers who were fed up with Trudeau).

We know how the rest went.

There are two big questions to this really.
1. Is Mark carney doing what should be done as Prime Minister for Canada's greater well being?; and
2. Is Pierre Poilievre the man who should replace him as PM?

It is possible that one can think PM MC is doing a terrible job and not at all support Pierre as potential PM. Both can be true at the same time.

My personal views (and very well known here). I support Pierre as PM. He is very outspoken as leader of the opposition and here is the brutal truth, we fucking need that big time. Shut up and go along is NOT democracy. Disagreement is democracy.

And the points Pierre champions were still true in 2024, as they were in 2025 and even more truer today late 2026. Housing, food cost, fuel cost, affordability, future for young Canadians, economy, energy, trade with the USA, are ALL still relevant today as they were 18 months ago.

Anybody noticed how cozy some prominent democrats are with Mark carney lately? Hillary calling him the natural leader of the free world. Obama speaks highly of him. Yeah, me thinks there is some fishy but unprovable stuff going on with the Democrats and PM MC. Like maybe cough, cough don't get a deal, cough. Then if a dem wins presidency in 2028, voila, we are friends again. Question is, what do you choose to believe?

On by elections. I point to spring of 2024 when Leslie Church ran as a "for sure winner" for the LPC in Toronto St Pauls and boom! CPC Don Stewart won. It was a shocker at the time. After action seems to point to people fed up with Trudeau and lack of support for Jewish community being a distant second as the factors for that upset. Swap out Carney for Trudeau, call a general election less than a year later and Leslie Church crushes Don Stewart in the election. Now what was that about people don't vote for the party but the person? Don't get me wrong, in some cases that really is the case. In Toronto St Pauls, it clearly wasn't.

Weirdly enough, Brian Liley and Warren Kinsella both predicted spring of 2024 that Mark Carney was going to replace Trudeau as leader of the LPC and Trump would be a major factor in our elections if he won. Funny how two old political journalist could call that.

If these by elections go ugly for the CPC, even I will admit that I think Pierre will step down. Even with that, its not a predictor in how a general election will go.

Carney popularity is in my opinion starting to wear thin. And I am predicting he will have a faster and harder fall than Trudeau. Why? Debt driven up higher, immigration (which in recent polls, more than one, a large majority of Canadians do not support increasing and many want to see decrease), The Gordie Howe bridge fiasco will come back to haunt him, job losses will hurt him, end of the day, the results are getting much too harder to ignore. Even the CBC and CTV have been leaning on the LPC lately. Carney mini melt down in Ireland with the press was not a good look.

Lets not forget $500 million to save the rain forest! The same ones that Carney as CEO of Brookfield was clearcutting and stripping away hundreds of acres at a time. Brilliant business strategy as he is now investing our tax dollars in saving same said rain forest. And it is 13 billion commitment over several years. Don't worry about not paying rent or mortgage, at least the monkeys will have a happy home in the trees.

And as Vesper Digital points out, so called "conservatives" like Kory Tenycke (owner of Rubicon strategies) and Fred Delorey (Another lobbyist) among many others, have been getting money hand over fist from the Liberal government. No fucking wonder they piss all over Pierre.

Believe what you want to believe.
 
Voting Election Day GIF by The Democrats

...and any time you reach out to the Councillor/Reeve/Mayor/MPP/MP that has been elected by your local peers to represent you at their particular level of Government.

Polling by private polling firms isn't done for the benefit of the public or to act as a voice for the public. It is a contracted service by an interested party to provide data on a specific subject and target audience that is in their interest.
In other words it should be like this
"SO the latest poll from Rick's polling found that of 800 conservative leaning 20-50 year olds of many full time workers, they supported X as a ..."
At least be honest and not say "Canadians believe..." from 1600 SELECTED and SCREENED polling participants.
 
PMMC campaigned on spending less. PBO just reported that federal government spending is $331.6 billion higher across the three spending plans tabled under him. Do people really care? I suspect a new party leader would be raising the exact same concerns Poilievre is, they might just be more polite about it. I don't think decorum will be enough to sway anyone from PMMC's celebrity power for quite a while.
…on operations, and investing more in economic growth over the next five years.

He was pretty clear there would be larger budgets, specifically dealing with the economic pressures of the CURSIT. He was clear government operations overall would be reduced, which less DND, PBO has confirmed is happening. The use of investment as a specific term to resource the mega corporation tax reductions to rates below US corporate tax, which are fiscal lines in the investment plan and count in the overall budgets moving forward. Those investments that support reduced business taxes are intended to serve increased investment in Canada which in turn supports economic (GDP, etc.) growth. I can find no statements during or after the campaign where there was any promise to have smaller budgets, which is how I took the intentions of your quoted statement above.

I still remain to see how the overall economic growth plan will unfold for Canada, but personally I am seeing developments in my work that directly correlate to support from PMMC’s investment strategy, so I am cautiously positive that we (Canada) are faring about as well as anyone could get us to, and that includes some very candid discussions I have hade with fellow business sector colleagues from the U.S., Europe and Asia. Asians in particular seem to be very positive of Canada’s handling the economic challenges of today.
 
It took Canadians 10 years to finally signal it was time for Trudeau to leave, and the minute he did, his (or the party depending how you see it) popularity immediately started to climb again.

It's still the same voter base. A new leader for the CPC now means 2 or 3 years of character assassination vs 1 year of character assassination.

PMMC campaigned on spending less. PBO just reported that federal government spending is $331.6 billion higher across the three spending plans tabled under him. Do people really care? I suspect a new party leader would be raising the exact same concerns Poilievre is, they might just be more polite about it. I don't think decorum will be enough to sway anyone from PMMC's celebrity power for quite a while.

I want to be clear here: I don't think the CPC should rush into this and simply throw the next available person into the leadership role. They should take the time to identify and recruit someone who can effectively serve as PMMC's opposite number. If that takes a couple of years, so be it.

In the meantime, let the LPC continue to flounder and mismanage the country. Frankly, let Canadians sit with the consequences of their electoral choices for a while as well. I'm perfectly comfortable with the Conservatives remaining a relatively ineffective opposition in the short term. Let voters fully experience what they voted for rather than being shielded from the results.

To put it proverbially, sometimes people only learn that sticking a fork into an electrical socket is a bad idea after they've experienced the consequences.

Then, about a year before the next election, bring in the hired gun and launch a relentless campaign built around a positive alternative. The message should be simple:
  1. The LPC has spent years taking the country in the wrong direction.
  2. Here's how we would do better.
Stay on the offensive. Keep the focus on the government's record and the Conservative alternative. Never allow the LPC to define the narrative or dictate the terms of the debate.

Carney popularity is in my opinion starting to wear thin. And I am predicting he will have a faster and harder fall than Trudeau. Why? Debt driven up higher, immigration (which in recent polls, more than one, a large majority of Canadians do not support increasing and many want to see decrease), The Gordie Howe bridge fiasco will come back to haunt him, job losses will hurt him, end of the day, the results are getting much too harder to ignore. Even the CBC and CTV have been leaning on the LPC lately. Carney mini melt down in Ireland with the press was not a good look.

I agree the wind is beginning to shift. Even the CBC's Chantal Hébert has been noticeably more critical of PMMC and the LPC lately than she was previously. It's subtle for now, but the tone appears to be changing.

At the moment, it's only a small shift, but the tire-pumping seems to have stopped. What was once fairly consistent praise and benefit-of-the-doubt coverage is increasingly being replaced by more scrutiny and criticism. Whether that develops into a broader trend remains to be seen, but the early signs are there.
 
Carney benefits as being somewhat competent, following a totally incompetent PM who's only advantage was nice hair and funky socks. So people seem to think he is wonderwaffle, when he is at best, average.
 
And it took a change of leadership of Team Blue in September 2022 (marked with purple bars) for their fortunes to climb for more than 2 years with the same voter base, too (source).
Right. I think it comes down to celebrity power. Many people associate a leaders popularity (and CV) with themselves. Some kind of vicarious transfer of status.


Looking at that graph it took 9 years for Trudeau to start losing popularity. Trudeau didn't lose popularity because of one incident. His supporters looked the other way at blackface, at sexually assaulting a reporter, at the WE scandal, so on and so on. He finally started losing popularity when he became too much of an embarrassment on the world stage, and it wasn't cool to be a Trudeau fan anymore. People didn't see themselves in Trudeau. Liberal support was declining in 2012 until Trudeau threw his hat in. A star was born. Remember how obsessed people became with him?

Fast forward to 2025 you can see the exact moment where Poilievre mysteriously blew his 30 point lead. Quite the immediate and sharp increase in Liberal support. Only it's not mystery , a new celebrity stepped in the ring. "Carney is always the smartest man in the room" and "If you disagree with Carney you're just wrong" seemed to be the theme of his supporters. They were beside themselves with CV and accomplishments. Many of whom just months before would lament about evil corporate elitists' and the Conservatives relationship with them. As you can see by that graph, Carney steps in and it's Trudeau mania all over again. Instant start power.

So what?

Conservatives picking a new party leader would be practically useless. Carney's supporters aren't going to abandon someone like him over something insignificant like going over budget half a trillion dollars or going back on campaign promises. A new CPC leader will make a few of us feel better, in the end it's just exposing the new guy to fire for longer. Who in Canada could match Carney's celebrity power? Any new CPC contender will instantly and aggressively be compared to Trump. A new CPC leader doesn't even begin standing a chance until after November 2028. Probably even 2030.
 
…on operations, and investing more in economic growth over the next five years.

He was pretty clear there would be larger budgets, specifically dealing with the economic pressures of the CURSIT. He was clear government operations overall would be reduced, which less DND, PBO has confirmed is happening. The use of investment as a specific term to resource the mega corporation tax reductions to rates below US corporate tax, which are fiscal lines in the investment plan and count in the overall budgets moving forward. Those investments that support reduced business taxes are intended to serve increased investment in Canada which in turn supports economic (GDP, etc.) growth. I can find no statements during or after the campaign where there was any promise to have smaller budgets, which is how I took the intentions of your quoted statement above.

I still remain to see how the overall economic growth plan will unfold for Canada, but personally I am seeing developments in my work that directly correlate to support from PMMC’s investment strategy, so I am cautiously positive that we (Canada) are faring about as well as anyone could get us to, and that includes some very candid discussions I have hade with fellow business sector colleagues from the U.S., Europe and Asia. Asians in particular seem to be very positive of Canada’s handling the economic challenges of today.

That's a fair distinction. I agree that investing in Canada's economic capacity is worthwhile. I think we're still looking at difference concerns though.

Carney campaigned on spending less and investing more. The question is whether his government is actually delivering on that commitment. The latest PBO assessment posted here and in the Liberal thread puts $331.6b in new measures across his three spending plans, with 61% classified as day to day operating expenditures rather than that capital investment.

My read of it is we're not just talking about increased investment in infrastructure, defence or business growth. We're also talking about a substantial growth in government operating expenditures. That's contrary to what he was saying during the campaign. There's a story about May quitting (again, again) where she points out what's said during the election, and what Carney ultimately does.

Is the government is living up to its fiscal promises? You're seeing positive changes so I'd say that's a great start. As a layman I'm still skeptical.
 
Conservatives picking a new party leader would be practically useless. Carney's supporters aren't going to abandon someone like him over something insignificant like going over budget half a trillion dollars or going back on campaign promises. A new CPC leader will make a few of us feel better, in the end it's just exposing the new guy to fire for longer. Who in Canada could match Carney's celebrity power? Any new CPC contender will instantly and aggressively be compared to Trump. A new CPC leader doesn't even begin standing a chance until after November 2028. Probably even 2030.
Well, if support for Carney is chipping away as much as some say it is, the sapping under the trenches has begun. If a change in face can bring around the kind of turnaround in popularity that PP taking the baton saw when he took over, also shows it could happen again.

Mind you, by that time, PMJT was a low bar to leap over, so maybe Team Blue may have a harder time finding someone that much more ... appealling? to the public than Carney right this second.
 
Right. I think it comes down to celebrity power. Many people associate a leaders popularity (and CV) with themselves. Some kind of vicarious transfer of status.

Looking at that graph it took 9 years for Trudeau to start losing popularity. Trudeau didn't lose popularity because of one incident. His supporters looked the other way at blackface, at sexually assaulting a reporter, at the WE scandal, so on and so on. He finally started losing popularity when he became too much of an embarrassment on the world stage, and it wasn't cool to be a Trudeau fan anymore. People didn't see themselves in Trudeau. Liberal support was declining in 2012 until Trudeau threw his hat in. A star was born. Remember how obsessed people became with him?

Fast forward to 2025 you can see the exact moment where Poilievre mysteriously blew his 30 point lead. Quite the immediate and sharp increase in Liberal support. Only it's not mystery , a new celebrity stepped in the ring. "Carney is always the smartest man in the room" and "If you disagree with Carney you're just wrong" seemed to be the theme of his supporters. They were beside themselves with CV and accomplishments. Many of whom just months before would lament about evil corporate elitists' and the Conservatives relationship with them. As you can see by that graph, Carney steps in and it's Trudeau mania all over again. Instant start power.

So what?

Conservatives picking a new party leader would be practically useless. Carney's supporters aren't going to abandon someone like him over something insignificant like going over budget half a trillion dollars or going back on campaign promises. A new CPC leader will make a few of us feel better, in the end it's just exposing the new guy to fire for longer. Who in Canada could match Carney's celebrity power? Any new CPC contender will instantly and aggressively be compared to Trump. A new CPC leader doesn't even begin standing a chance until after November 2028. Probably even 2030.

I think we need to be honest about the fact that PP is responsible for a substantial portion of the party's anemic popularity.

I also agree that we can't afford to hand the LPC enough time to dust off its well-worn campaign strategy centered on abortion, firearms, Trump, and generic anti-conservative messaging. That is why I support installing an interim leader and accepting a period as a lame-duck opposition. It would allow the party to focus on the more important task of finding PMMC's true opposite number: a candidate who can broaden the party's appeal, control the narrative, and seize the initiative heading into the next federal election.

Is the government is living up to its fiscal promises? You're seeing positive changes so I'd say that's a great start. As a layman I'm still skeptical.

I personally believe that many people are engaging in confirmation bias, latching onto small examples that validate what they already want to believe. They're searching for proof in the micro while intentionally ignoring the macro, where the overall trend tells a very different story.

I personally try to be careful of this as I recognize my biases.

I think people genuinely had their worlds turned upside down with the election of old '47 and his follow on activities. Scared people do strange things.
 
Last edited:
Back
Top