• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
Nope. The Liberals campaigned on it and they can accept responsibility for their own failed promises.

From Google AI
The Canadian federal government gets involved in home and housing development to address affordability challenges, reduce homelessness, support economic growth, and stabilize the national housing market. Although provinces and territories hold primary constitutional authority over housing—and municipalities largely control zoning, land use, and permitting—Ottawa uses funding, financing, and federal lands to influence supply and support households nationwide

Doubling the pace of Canadian homebuilding to nearly 500,000 new homes per year was a key Liberal pledge.

It was also a cornerstone part of PMMC's plan to end homelessness, which he spoke about less than 2 weeks ago.
they can campaign all they want.
Builders build.
Municipalities are wholly creatures of the provinces
 
they can campaign all they want.
Builders build.
Municipalities are wholly creatures of the provinces
So why aren't they getting built? Go ahead, enlighten us. And please include how the Liberals are not at all responsible for this failure (A campaign promise they made).

Its not JUST municipalities and provinces, the federal government has a role in it. A big one.
 
Easiest way to get homes built is simply for the government to build them.

Vienna is the model to follow for a effective public housing program which keeps costs down, creates high quality housing, and doesn’t turn into guettos. Private enterprise isn’t going to solve this.
 
So why aren't they getting built? Go ahead, enlighten us. And please include how the Liberals are not at all responsible for this failure (A campaign promise they made).

Its not JUST municipalities and provinces, the federal government has a role in it. A big one.
because they can afford to wait until demand and pricing are more favourable for profits

Stupid campaign promises arent new.
Subsidizing the demand side doesnt work
Carrot over stick doesnt work
 
Easiest way to get homes built is simply for the government to build them.

Vienna is the model to follow for a effective public housing program which keeps costs down, creates high quality housing, and doesn’t turn into guettos. Private enterprise isn’t going to solve this.
Is the housing public owned or public built?
 
Stupid campaign promises arent new.
Subsidizing the demand side doesnt work
I see, so STUPID to use your word campaign promises implies it is a stupid political party to make them, which in this case is the Liberal Party of Canada and is lead by PM Mark Carney.

SO can I accept that you think the PM and his party are stupid? I don't disagree.
 
I see, so STUPID to use your word campaign promises implies it is a stupid political party to make them, which in this case is the Liberal Party of Canada and is lead by PM Mark Carney.

SO can I accept that you think the PM and his party are stupid? I don't disagree.
well i think there are probably lots of things i disagree with the PM on
its stupid IMO because its wrong.
did it help them get elected? not stupid in that sense
 
did it help them get elected? not stupid in that sense
Many people talk themselves into jobs that they don't hold on to. He has only been around 20 months.

I am absolutely fascinated that rather than actually point the finger at and criticize the Liberals, you are trying to find obscure ways to justify their failures.

Bottom line, they failed at housing, one of their key campaign promises.
 
Many people talk themselves into jobs that they don't hold on to. He has only been around 20 months.

I am absolutely fascinated that rather than actually point the finger at and criticize the Liberals, you are trying to find obscure ways to justify their failures.

Bottom line, they failed at housing, one of their key campaign promises.
i think in general bad ideas on housing. Im not surprised at failure. I didnt expect anything
seems critical to me
 
Toronto Sun with some useful criticism of the Carney Liberals and their failure to secure a deal with the USA (as he promised, another Carney broken campaign promise) and trying to secure a stronger trade deal with China (He never ran on that, in fact last election, he said they were the greatest threat to Canada).

Kind of backs my point. Carney and the Liberals will say and promise anything to get elected, and retain power. Are Canadians foolish enough to keep accepting this?

 
Easiest way to get homes built is simply for the government to build them.

Vienna is the model to follow for a effective public housing program which keeps costs down, creates high quality housing, and doesn’t turn into guettos. Private enterprise isn’t going to solve this.
We can't afford it. We have already spent my great-grandchildren's future. But getting it under control is easy. Freeze immigration at 200,000 per year including those already here that are being granted residency status. Build a couple new penitentiaries and then quit with the revolving door court room dramas: should take care of a few thousand. Shorten the decision times on refugee claims and if found illegal put them on the next flight out. Encourage industries to locate or re-locate in cities like Trenton and larger towns like Perth and put in decent connections between those centres and the major cities i.e. commuter rail. There are lots of ways to get control of the housing without spending tons of money on selective developments but where money is needed put it to the infrastructure: pipes, water, ditches (not sewers ask those of us in St. Catharines or Niagara, they don't work unless nature cooperates by only delivering at the designed rate), electric system upgrades and especially railed transit so people will accept living in a smaller community.
 
So why aren't they getting built? Go ahead, enlighten us. And please include how the Liberals are not at all responsible for this failure (A campaign promise they made).

Its not JUST municipalities and provinces, the federal government has a role in it. A big one.
A factor is that there are no, none, zero ‘national’ home builders here in Canada. There are regional players only and only two small/tiny companies in Alberta trade on the stock market.
The vast majority are privately held and have stunted access to the financial markets for cash/funding as a result.
 
Is the housing public owned or public built?
Essentially a publically owned corporation (along the lines of a crown corporation) which has a mandate to never sell property and to use any profits to build. They rent to a mixed variety of people (professionals, lower class, middle class) with only the highest income earners excluded.

Basic gist is initially they get long term mortgage/loans from the government building just at cost. Rent is set up to recoup costs over a 50 year basis, just paying for maintenance, no profits in there. After 50 years with the loan paid off the rent remains at the same low rate (with slight adjustments for inflation) and now is used to build more housing.

Now they no longer need government loans to sustain themselves and will grow exponentially over time. Civilian contractors still have a market in the higher end homes (which realistically is the only market being somewhat satisfied at the moment in Canada), and it forces them to build quality homes because they are competing with these quality government made homes.

Vienna started this in the 20s. It is the most successful housing program in the world. Just follow what works.
We can't afford it. We have already spent my great-grandchildren's future. But getting it under control is easy. Freeze immigration at 200,000 per year including those already here that are being granted residency status. Build a couple new penitentiaries and then quit with the revolving door court room dramas: should take care of a few thousand. Shorten the decision times on refugee claims and if found illegal put them on the next flight out. Encourage industries to locate or re-locate in cities like Trenton and larger towns like Perth and put in decent connections between those centres and the major cities i.e. commuter rail. There are lots of ways to get control of the housing without spending tons of money on selective developments but where money is needed put it to the infrastructure: pipes, water, ditches (not sewers ask those of us in St. Catharines or Niagara, they don't work unless nature cooperates by only delivering at the designed rate), electric system upgrades and especially railed transit so people will accept living in a smaller community.
We can afford it, certainly much more than a lot of other programs which bring in less than this.

For the 6 billion the federal government alone is spending on housing you could at the high end of cost build one hundred and thirty three, 100unit 1000sqft apartments. Thats 13,333 units which can hold a family of three or more comfortably. Based on that simple math thats 40k housed for that 6 billion which will start to be paid back immediately from the 750-900$ a month rent that would be charged for it.

I think your grandkids would like to have a decent apartment for 900$ a month.

Just reducing OAS to 100k households and lower would save 7 billion which would be another 155x100 unit 1000sqft buildings housing another 46,500 people.

So just shuffling how we spend Federal funds a little bit results in 86,500 people housed each year with low rents on a program which will pay for itself long term.

If you really wanted to you could use this to get rid of OAS all together by using this model to build senior homes and slowly phase out the benefit in exchange for free housing for low income seniors, OAS being more than what the cost of a 600 sqft apartment would be on this model.

Alternatively we can keep putting money out there in programs which aren’t working, have no proven track record of working, and don’t ever recoup their costs.
 
Essentially a publically owned corporation (along the lines of a crown corporation) which has a mandate to never sell property and to use any profits to build. They rent to a mixed variety of people (professionals, lower class, middle class) with only the highest income earners excluded.

Basic gist is initially they get long term mortgage/loans from the government building just at cost. Rent is set up to recoup costs over a 50 year basis, just paying for maintenance, no profits in there. After 50 years with the loan paid off the rent remains at the same low rate (with slight adjustments for inflation) and now is used to build more housing.

Now they no longer need government loans to sustain themselves and will grow exponentially over time. Civilian contractors still have a market in the higher end homes (which realistically is the only market being somewhat satisfied at the moment in Canada), and it forces them to build quality homes because they are competing with these quality government made homes.

Vienna started this in the 20s. It is the most successful housing program in the world. Just follow what works.

We can afford it, certainly much more than a lot of other programs which bring in less than this.
sure we can, but should we? We can afford to borrow money too. That is why our credit rating is so good. Debt makes you the slave of the person who holds the paper. How much of our paper is held in Beijing? It is quite conceivable that many of Carney's actions re: China are the result of string pulling. It is certain that that is the motive behind Trump.
For the 6 billion the federal government alone is spending on housing you could at the high end of cost build one hundred and thirty three, 100unit 1000sqft apartments. Thats 13,333 units which can hold a family of three or more comfortably. Based on that simple math thats 40k housed for that 6 billion which will start to be paid back immediately from the 750-900$ a month rent that would be charged for it.
I have seen pictures of that. Leningrad post war, council housing in London. No one packed into that kind of development is going to give a s**t about looking after the place so in 5 years the place will look 30.
I think your grandkids would like to have a decent apartment for 900$ a month.

Just reducing OAS to 100k households and lower would save 7 billion which would be another 155x100 unit 1000sqft buildings housing another 46,500 people.
As long as there is no grass or trees to clutter the place up. Your world is depressing.
So just shuffling how we spend Federal funds a little bit results in 86,500 people housed each year with low rents on a program which will pay for itself long term.
How be we stop paying for the Brazilian rain forest instead
If you really wanted to you could use this to get rid of OAS all together by using this model to build senior homes and slowly phase out the benefit in exchange for free housing for low income seniors,
Most of the seniors I know have fought like hell to stay out of that type of living. For them that move is one step closer to death
OAS being more than what the cost of a 600 sqft apartment would be on this model.

Alternatively we can keep putting money out there in programs which aren’t working, have no proven track record of working, and don’t ever recoup their costs.
 
Easiest way to get homes built is simply for the government to build them.

Vienna is the model to follow for a effective public housing program which keeps costs down, creates high quality housing, and doesn’t turn into guettos. Private enterprise isn’t going to solve this.
The fact that models exist doesn't mean they'll be applied here.

If government could do all these things that people keep claiming government can do well, why do things never work out that way?
 
Back
Top