• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

All Things First Nations - CF help, protests, solutions, residential schools, etc. (merged)

There are no provisions in the any Canadian aviation security regulations that prevents someone from flying with alcohol in their checked bags. Cabin bags are a different story. There is no regulatory prohibition on traveling by road or water with alcohol in your possession (outside of regulations on open containers or within reach of the operator). A transportation company would have to develop, implement and enforce internal policies that prohibit the transportation of alcohol (and drugs) on any of their conveyances destined for a first nations community. This, in itself, opens up a much different can of worms.
That’s what made it tough to do when I was still working: CATSA et al are only supposed to keep flights safe, not screen for booze/drogs, and it wasn’t on legally to search without cause. I haven’t read the enabling BCR’s, but they look boilerplate from some template - we’ll see soon enough how well they work - or not.

So far, refusal to be searched = back on the return flight with you. It’ll be interesting to see how long it’ll take for someone to take it to court.

Late add: looking over some old stuff, as far back as 2010, then-NDP-MPP Howard Hampton (former AG, then in opposition) was calling for special search/seizure powers to help deal with this sort of thing on FN's, so it's not a new thing people know to look out for.
 
Last edited:
But isn't this why they are looking to do this before boarding at origin? So that if they refuse to be inspected, they are refused access to the flight/bus?
Honestly I’m with the FNs on this stuff, it just hasn’t been legally successful. Change a factor- opens up a new problem like Haggis is saying. The sentiment is good. The results have been bad.
 
So, Booter nails the first part:

And then I’ll add a second: what happens when buddy gets off the plane, grabs his stuff, refuses to be subject to a search, tells whoever is at the airport to eff off, and then just walks?

Either the authorities purporting to have this power accept noncompliance, in which case the system collapses immediately, or they attempt to forcibly detain/arrest the person in order to effect the search and potentially remove them from the community.

Do they have a lawful authority for that detention/arrest? They’d better. Because if not, now we’re into the realm of committing an assault via unlawful arrest. Take it a step further: if an unlawful detention or arrest is an assault, and the person uses reasonable force to defend themselves, now things get stinkier with probably an assault to resist arrest charge and further detention all based on an unlawful arrest. Take it a step further still: what if in the course of this arrest someone is injured? What if they’re injured quite badly?

A lot of legal liability and other headache comes from acting outside of legal authorities.
In those small communities, they are likely to find other ways to deal with people who break their own laws and offender might run to the local police for protection. Recently on Haida Gwaii they ran someone out of town and destroyed their house.
 
... Either the authorities purporting to have this power accept noncompliance, in which case the system collapses immediately, or they attempt to forcibly detain/arrest the person in order to effect the search and potentially remove them from the community ...
According to the NAPS "Border Control" FAQ (yellow highlights mine) ...

WHAT IS NBC?​

In 2022, the Nishnawbe Aski Nation (NAN) Chiefs directed NAPS to develop a pilot program targeting the escalating drug crisis.

This NAPS Border Control, or “NBC”, pilot is now being rolled out across a number of pilot communities, where specially trained Special Constables have been deployed to support searches of all incoming travellers.

If drugs are found, NAPS has the authority to seize drugs, arrest individuals, lay criminal charges, and, where appropriate, effect the removal of trespassers.

WHAT IF I OBJECT TO BEING SEARCHED?​

Anyone who does not wish to be searched has the option to return to their departure point.

However, if you wish to enter the community, be aware that you will be searched.

Notice of search has been extensively publicized at connecting airports, community entry points, and inside each of the pilot communities. All travellers should consider themselves on notice that they will be searched.
We'll see how it goes ....
 
Back
Top