• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Continental Defence Corvette

The Swedish Corvettes.


And the Canadian companion piece


Meanwhile, next door in Finland, work is coming along well on their corvette/light frigate.
Pohjanmaa-corvette-RMC.jpg
 
close to what we are looking for?
ice strengthened
117m long
8 cell mk41
8 ASM
57mm
2 x RWS

I was thinking Inocea owned Rauma too getting them confused with Helsinki
I think ice capability is now off the table for the CDC. I think that maybe it was incompatible with all the other capabilities they are looking for.
 
close to what we are looking for?
ice strengthened
117m long
8 cell mk41
8 ASM
57mm
2 x RWS

I was thinking Inocea owned Rauma too getting them confused with Helsinki
Only thing we would need to do is add or swap out a few things for equipment we use, like incorporating CMS 330 with Saab 9LV, NSM instead of Gabriel V, Mk 32 instead of Tub m/20.

I think ice capability is now off the table for the CDC. I think that maybe it was incompatible with all the other capabilities they are looking for.
Ice strengthening is already built-in to the design of the Pohjanma class.
 
Here they are, but they didn't start until you posted this. How's about we do the regular navy jobs properly first before we start faffing about with the most complicated combined naval, army and logistical military operation that have ever existed?

Amphib capability is a useful capability, but its not existential (like it is in Australia's case). I'm all about building capability in the correct order. Get the Canadian Task groups that can defend Canadian waters and add to allied defence. With the submarine and air assets needed to do that (likely arriving sooner than the surface ships!). And the logistical sustainment for those. So that's going to take about 20 years to sort out. Then we can do the Australia thing and spend another 10 years of very dedicated and expensive work to develop amphib capability.

Given limited resources I would rather spend amphib capability money on cyber, space, EW, logistical or intelligence capabilities that can augment/assist the core capabilities the CAF is required to do, instead of creating an entire grouping of capabilities for its own mission.

Not quite the heat death of the sun, but given the current state of the CAF and the goal for a proper army division, the defence of Canada emphasis and the rearmament push going forward we're going to be ready for "flair" capabilities sometimes around 2060.

I don't disagree with much of this, there are a lot of competing priorities right now, and I wouldn't suggest putting an amphib ship at the top of the list.

Nor am I suggesting that gov.ca head over to amazon.mil and buy an entire ARG's worth of kit, in triplicate, all at once.

But I maintain that a genuine middle power' needs to be capable of not just effective defence, but also be capable of significant force projection, independently if needed.

I suggested the Makassar as a starting point because of its smaller size, and reasonable cost. Size wise, they aren't much different than the RCD. And it baffles the mind to think the original set of ships had a unit cost comparable to a F16 at the time...

In more modern terms, the version being build for the UAE seems like a reasonable starting point. It is larger than the originals, but that made it capable of handling the Chinook.


I don't want to dirty up the Corvette thread too much more with this, just think it'd be a good first step, with a full ARG by 2060 as a reasonable goal to work towards.
 
Back
Top