• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

King Charles III

dapaterson said:
The CG is a task, not a unit.
Click to expand...
If we cobble together a Coy minus from 2 Res Inf Bns, call it a TBG, and it still counts as a "unit"... so does CG.

Cloud Cover said:
The CG is a burden, not a task.
Click to expand...
Public Duties are a necessary burden, as diplomacy is part of national security and foreign policy.

If foreign Heads of State/Government are received with Ho Hum pomp and pageantry, sets the tone for the rest of the visit.

Less a burden, more making an impression.

I get the current obsession with "if its not operational, its worthless!" mentality in the Canadian Armed Forces... but I would hope someone in the headshed (ADM(Pol) maybe?) or at protocol at Rideau Hall keeps their head enough about this aspect of rolling out the red carpet.
 
A TBG is not a unit. Unit is a legal term, defined per the NDA.

Organization

17 (1) The Canadian Forces shall consist of those of the following elements that are from time to time organized by or under the authority of the Minister:

(a) commands, including the Royal Canadian Navy, the Canadian Army and the Royal Canadian Air Force;

(b) formations;

(c) units; and

(d) other elements.

Marginal note:Components

(2) A unit or other element organized under subsection (1), other than a command or a formation, shall from time to time be embodied in a component of the Canadian Forces as directed by or under the authority of the Minister.
Click to expand...
 
rmc_wannabe said:
If we cobble together a Coy minus from 2 Res Inf Bns, call it a TBG, and it still counts as a "unit"... so does CG.


Public Duties are a necessary burden, as diplomacy is part of national security and foreign policy.

If foreign Heads of State/Government are received with Ho Hum pomp and pageantry, sets the tone for the rest of the visit.

Less a burden, more making an impression.

I get the current obsession with "if its not operational, its worthless!" mentality in the Canadian Armed Forces... but I would hope someone in the headshed (ADM(Pol) maybe?) or at protocol at Rideau Hall keeps their head enough about this aspect of rolling out the red carpet.
Click to expand...
How about 150± of these folks, based in Ottawa, for public duties and as an augmented force for e.g. demonstrations and diplomatic security? Oh, and a band, too.
 

Attachments

  • DSC_3098-copyWEB-scaled.jpg
    DSC_3098-copyWEB-scaled.jpg
    626 KB · Views: 7
dapaterson said:
A TBG is not a unit. Unit is a legal term, defined per the NDA.
Click to expand...
Ack. Thank you for the pedantic clarity.

Edward Campbell said:
How about 150± of these folks, based in Ottawa, for public duties and as an augmented force for e.g. demonstrations and diplomatic security? Oh, and a band, too.
Click to expand...

If we are hurting that badly as an Armed Forces that we hand over Public Duties to a Gendarmerie (who would be even more expensive to pay, quarter, and cloth... not to mention the crues and howls we'd get from their Professional Association).... perhaps all is lost for us.
 
Edward Campbell said:
How about 150± of these folks, based in Ottawa, for public duties and as an augmented force for e.g. demonstrations and diplomatic security? Oh, and a band, too.
Click to expand...
Or…these folks.

Smaller military but they decided (rightly or wrongly) that 170 folks should be posted to a purely ceremonial unit.
 
dapaterson said:
The CG is a task, not a unit.
Click to expand...
Well it used to be. It still has its own UIC. But CG is now a subunit of the GGFG. It no longer has a CO or RSM. Still has a reg force major as OC now and the CWO position is now an MWO position.

Public Duties is the task. But with a significant reduction in incremental numbers since the pandemic and reconstitution.
 
Remius said:
Well it used to be. It still has its own UIC. But CG is now a subunit of the GGFG. It no longer has a CO or RSM. Still has a reg force major as OC now and the CWO position is now an MWO position.

Public Duties is the task. But with a significant reduction in incremental numbers since the pandemic and reconstitution.
Click to expand...
In the early 2000s CG was treated as a unit, but in fact was not one. There was no Ministerial Organizational Order creating it, and thus is was not a unit. On the legal org chart of the CAF, CG appeared as a sub unit of the GGFG.

There are provisions in the QR&O which enable a Commander of a Command to designate an individual as a CO, despite them not occupying a position designated as the CO of a unit. Thus the CG had a CO despite not being a unit.
 
Fishbone Jones said:
And ignored by everyone. Sitting, talking, walking out. Fergus up there grinning like a dog eating burrs. How sad.
Click to expand...
In defense of the Speaker (who I couldn't care less about), his job is to maintain the order of the House and get on with the business of the day.

He attempted to call the House to order, realised it was not going to happen, and permitted it to continue.

As for folks walking around while others were singing, it was impromptu and not sanctioned by the House. The Standing Orders state the only anthem sang in Parliament is the National Anthem and its only sung on Wednesday at the start of the day. There was no requirement to have MPs stand, stop, or sing along in this case.

Additionally, some of those walking about were Paiges, Clerks, and others who still had shit to do.

As for notice, it was noticed across the Commonwealth in their news media, as it was a pretty ho hum Private Member's Bill in Canada, but has far more symbolic impact in countries that are trying to distance themselves or abolish the monarchy.

Glossing over the fact that we have a pretty solid constitutional lock on the Monarchy in Canada, it was a demonstration of where we stand amongst other Commonwealth members.
 
rmc_wannabe said:
In defense of the Speaker (who I couldn't care less about), his job is to maintain the order of the House and get on with the business of the day.

He attempted to call the House to order, realised it was not going to happen, and permitted it to continue.

As for folks walking around while others were singing, it was impromptu and not sanctioned by the House. The Standing Orders state the only anthem sang in Parliament is the National Anthem and its only sung on Wednesday at the start of the day. There was no requirement to have MPs stand, stop, or sing along in this case.

Additionally, some of those walking about were Paiges, Clerks, and others who still had shit to do.

As for notice, it was noticed across the Commonwealth in their news media, as it was a pretty ho hum Private Member's Bill in Canada, but has far more symbolic impact in countries that are trying to distance themselves or abolish the monarchy.

Glossing over the fact that we have a pretty solid constitutional lock on the Monarchy in Canada, it was a demonstration of where we stand amongst other Commonwealth members.
Click to expand...
How dare you put “context” into a good ol’ outrage train?
 
You must log in or register to reply here.

Similar threads

Grunt_031
    • Like
King Charles III Coronation Medal
7 8 9
Replies
164
Views
13K
Maxman1
Maxman1
T
HMCS
Replies
3
Views
2K
TRIBALCLASS
T
Baz
    • Like
CH-124 Sea King Historical Thread
2 3
Replies
49
Views
2K
Baz
Baz
D
    • Like
Sophie brings empathy to patients and soldiers in Ontario — and hints of future for royal visits
Replies
0
Views
2K
dapaterson
D
J
BOOKS AND READINGS prior to NWO II, III and IV
Replies
5
Views
747
Lumber
Lumber
Back
Top