• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
So you seem to be saying that I am responsible for the decisions that those above me make, as well as those I make and those that my subordinates make. That doesn't sound right.

While I was a senior officer, was I responsible for the decisions made by my peers as well in the pursuit of their own objectives and those of their boss? Is Base Edm responsible for the traffic shitshow in Petawawa? Is the Comd of the RCAF on the hook for decisions made by the Army Commander about funding the Army Reserves? Was Comd 1 CMBG accountable for the readiness levels of the other two Brigades?

I think you are applying a standard to Mr Carney in another chapter of his life that no one else in the corporate world has ever been held to...and that I would question if it was applied to me in my military career, or my current career as a C Suite Officer in two different companies.

As a senior officer I would say they're responsible (accountable?) for the decisions their team makes, which they supported or signed off on. I don't think we're giving Mark Carney's position at Brookfield the recognition it deserves.

Mark Carney wasn't Brookfields CEO. He was Chair of the Board of Brookfield Asset Management and Chair and Head of Transition Investing.
[and this is about what Brookfields assets were doing]

Carney was one of Brookfield's most senior leaders, with a board-level leadership position. In military terms that would be what? A Lieutenant-General? Maybe even CDS?

The CAF has 146 authorized general positions (I'm guessing we physically have close to that?). In Brookfields chain of command they have 12.
The CEO, Board Chair (Mark Carney), and 10 other directors. Carney's position wasn't someone in base Edmonton being responsible for Petawawa traffic. It's a possibility Carney wasn't intimately aware of Brookfield companies buying and burning the rainforest but as Chair of the Board and #2 of #12 I'd say is more responsible/accountable that your average Brookfield employee.
 
As a senior officer I would say they're responsible (accountable?) for the decisions their team makes, which they supported or signed off on. I don't think we're giving Mark Carney's position at Brookfield the recognition it deserves.

Mark Carney wasn't Brookfields CEO. He was Chair of the Board of Brookfield Asset Management and Chair and Head of Transition Investing.
[and this is about what Brookfields assets were doing]

Carney was one of Brookfield's most senior leaders, with a board-level leadership position. In military terms that would be what? A Lieutenant-General? Maybe even CDS?

The CAF has 146 authorized general positions (I'm guessing we physically have close to that?). In Brookfields chain of command they have 12.
The CEO, Board Chair (Mark Carney), and 10 other directors. Carney's position wasn't someone in base Edmonton being responsible for Petawawa traffic. It's a possibility Carney wasn't intimately aware of Brookfield companies buying and burning the rainforest but as Chair of the Board and #2 of #12 I'd say is more responsible/accountable that your average Brookfield employee.
I’m curious how many people raising a stink about this have actually ever shown any sign of giving two shits about deforestation until they could attach to it the name of someone prominent in a political party in Canada? I suspect there’s a lot of contrived grievance in this.
 
I’m curious how many people raising a stink about this have actually ever shown any sign of giving two shits about deforestation until they could attach to it the name of someone prominent in a political party in Canada? I suspect there’s a lot of contrived grievance in this.
Possible. Others might not care about saving trees but disagree with half a billion tax dollars being sent to a relatively new organization with next to no information on the proposed terms Canada will be paid back, who makes sure the money is being spent on what it's intended for, and financial safeguards.
 
Possible. Others might not care about saving trees but disagree with half a billion tax dollars being sent to a relatively new organization with next to no information on the proposed terms Canada will be paid back, who makes sure the money is being spent on what it's intended for, and financial safeguards.
Completely fair. If so they should frame it that way; not suddenly pretend to be environmentalists.
 
Completely fair. If so they should frame it that way; not suddenly pretend to be environmentalists.
I completely understand where you're coming from. Disingenuous for someone who has never brought up or argued environmental concerns in the past to all of a sudden star caring about clear cutting in Brazil. I don't. I would if I trusted this money was actually going to the right place and it would help. As it stands I assume it's going to the international version of GC Strategies Inc (ArriveCan).
 
It's completely unsurprising that people who have not previously expressed any particular opinion about principle X will suddenly take an interest if a partisan political axe can be ground.
 
I completely understand where you're coming from. Disingenuous for someone who has never brought up or argued environmental concerns in the past to all of a sudden star caring about clear cutting in Brazil. I don't. I would if I trusted this money was actually going to the right place and it would help. As it stands I assume it's going to the international version of GC Strategies Inc (ArriveCan).
We are paying a corporation to not cut trees i.e. not work. You can guarantee that it won't go to the people who are wielding the axes.
 
Canada does not have a healthcare system.

There are 13 provincial and territorial healthcare syatems.
As elsewhere, the Niagara Region has closed and demolished 2 hospitals, repurposed 3 more as specialty facilities for rehab and long term closed 3 emergency wards on top of that. They have built one new hospital and are planning a second. For the majority ofthe county the closures have meant that the nearest hospital is right on the limits for safe transport. Why is big and centralized considered so important instead of keeping treatment close and transporting if required. Every day I see ambulances heading to McMaster or the General so their shiny new buildings can't take care of everything anyways. Having spent 5 or 6 days in emergency wards sinc COVID I can testify that most ailments are easily handled so why are we spending that amount of money on decoration. Serious question
 
Back
Top