• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

NHL Players Are "Scabs"

Bruce Monkhouse

Pinball Dude
Staff member
Directing Staff
Subscriber
Reaction score
7,881
Points
1,360
I never thought of this but thats exactly what they are,"scabs", imagine the screaming they would make if the NHL started signing players to play in thier place?



  Sat, October 30, 2004

'They are scabs'
Hirsch blasts NHLers in Europe
By Corey Hirsch

Calgarian Corey Hirsch attacks NHL players for going to Europe during the NHL lockout. (Toronto Sun Photo)

Calgarian Corey Hirsch, 32, was tending net for the Langnau Tigers of the Swiss 'A' League when the NHL lockout hit. His life has been affected by the influx of locked-out NHLers to Europe.

Hirsch and Sun columnist Chris Stevenson have been exchanging e-mails about the situation facing players in Europe who have lost their jobs since the arrival of the locked-out NHLers. Hirsch is one of them. His is the story behind the headline every time you read another NHLer is Europe-bound. Here is his story, in his words:

- - -

The NHL lockout has affected many people on a variety of different levels -- but every time an NHL player signs in Europe, another life is affected.

As of yesterday, 236 NHLers are playing in Europe.

One of these lives affected is my own.

I came to Europe two years ago to get away from the NHL.

For whatever reason, like many of my North American colleagues over here, I didn't make it in the NHL. Europe was the next best option to keep my career going.

Once again, though, the NHL has me in its grasp. It's like a chokehold I can't get out of but this time it's different.

It's my fellow players who are doing the damage.

NHL players are coming to Europe in droves and are bumping off, one by one, players who actually need the money.

While I understand some players feel they have to play or they may become lockout casualties themselves, the lack of compassion and understanding of what they are doing to many of the players in Europe is extremely unnerving.

Every day, I read another arrogant quote from someone coming to play in Europe for no other reason than to stay in shape. Where is the logic in not negotiating a CBA that will still pay a player more than he'll need but instead come to Europe to play just to stay in shape?

Some of these players should have a talk with my pregnant wife and kids who moved their lives to Europe, only to watch me sit in the stands game after game because I have been bumped by an NHL player (Martin Gerber of the Carolina Hurricanes). There's a good chance I may not play a game this season.

The NHL lockout will end and a strong majority of these players will go back to the NHL.

They will have careers making great salaries but the damage they will have left in their wake will be irreparable.

While they are back playing, myself and many others will be fighting for jobs that pay minute salaries compared to the NHL.

Without playing the previous season due to this mess, many players in Europe may have to retire.

I wonder if any of the NHL players understand the repercussions of their actions.

When the topic of NHL replacement players comes up, it is met with anger and resistance.

Do NHL players not realize this is exactly what they are doing by taking jobs in Europe?

They are scabs over here, replacement players, basically rented to put fans in the seats.

All these players they are stepping on over here will now be the first to stand in line if and when the NHL needs replacement players.

I understand my views will probably not change anything.

They will, however, give NHL players an understanding it is not OK to bring their lockout mess to Europe and believe they are doing no harm.

We are now at 236 lives and counting, not to mention the families that have been affected.

So before NHL players come to Europe, I suggest they take a long hard look in the mirror and ask themselves why they are coming?

Other than to stay in shape, they will be playing for little money and will be destroying the job security of others.

Is this not exactly what the NHL players are fighting against back in North America?

 
As much as I'd like believe their reasons for going to Europe to play (to stay in shape), I doubt that's the reason.   There's plenty of rinks throughout Canada and America, not to mention all the rinks in the same State or Province that player may be playing in, why not just rent some ice (which is probably only a little over a $100 bucks, depending on the rink) with their $10,000,000 US salary.   heck, they could buy a rink and play whenever the heck they want.   Go to a gym, buy a space and build their own private gym if they don't want to be bothered by locals because "I'm an NHL superstar", there's many things they can to do to better themselves without becoming a scab.  

The rink surface in Europe is bigger, and if I'm not mistaken there is no red line, as soon as they adapt to that style of play do you know how hard it's going to be for them to return to playing with a smaller ice surface and the two line off side pass?   In minor hockey (which I play), they removed the red line this year, we've been playing for 2 - 3 months now and some players still play like it's there, it's a lot harder to adapt then some think it is.

So not only are they hurting the European players, they're hurting themselves as well.   Again, I doubt they went to play to stay in shape, even though the money players get paid is peanuts compared to their NHL salary, it's all about the money.   Which raises my eyebrow...

If they go OVERSEAS to be PAID LESS with DIFFERENT rules, why not stay here, take a pay cut (but with a reasonable cap) and get the NHL season underway without going overseas, get paid more money then they would in Europe, and play with the same rules.   Maybe it only looks easy on paper, but it would have been worth a shot.
 
I am divided on this one. Yes it is true that the NHL players are taking the jobs of the normal European league players. This would not happen if the European team owners cared more about their regular players and less about filling the seats while they can. >:(
Secondly the NHL players did not withdraw their services but were locked out by their team owners in an attempt to get the collective bargin the owners want. I can not blame the players form looking for alternative work in the mean time.

Lets Hope for a Settlement
 
In what other job can you make $375000.00US for 82 days of work with no previous job history with that employer??  That's the max that a rookie can make in their debut year.  I'll be lucky if I make that in the next 15 years.  I don't blame the owners for locking out the players.  The salaries are outrageous.  I'm not willing to go and pay to see a Leafs game at the prices they charge now let alone if the players salaries continue to rise.  I'm a huge fan of hockey, but I can't see the need for the elevated pay rate that the players receive.  Lets not forget that many of the players also have endorsement deals.  My opinion= NHL players are scabs in the European market.

Cheers!! :cdn:

The Army Guy
 
Lets not forget that it was a few of the owners that created the high pay in the first place(I'll buy the cup). Now the owners want to use the collective agreement to protect them from some of themselves.
If any one can honestly tell me they would turn down a very very huge pay offer for the same job they are currently doing no strings attached I'd say BULLSH1TE.

JMO

 
 
Back
Top