- Reaction score
- 6,167
- Points
- 1,260
E.R. Campbell said:"Sunshine is the best disinfectant."
I was just listening to Sen George Baker on the local (Ottawa) CBC radio morning show.
He makes one good point: the steps taken, this year, by the Senate to provide some transparency ("sunshine") to senators' expenses are likely to help prevent repeats of the kind of disrepute into which Sens Brazeau, Duffy, Harb, Lavigne and Wallin have dragged parliament. The transparency ~ including "opening" the Senate to the Auditor General and making "internal economy" reports public ~ will likely make senators think before they spend. It will put the Senate into the position of letting in some "sunshine," which, according to an old political maxim, "is the best disinfectant."*
But, as Sen Baker suggested, the Senate's reforms need to be made permanent and even expanded in the Senate, itself, and applied to the House of Commons, too. The Parliament of Canada should be at least as open and transparent as is the Government of Canada. Members' and senators' expenses should be as visible as are those of senior civil servants. (I am not suggesting that the government's Directive on Travel, Hospitality, Conference and Event Expenditures is an especially good system but it does provide some visibility without violating the privacy of officials.)
As a genera rule: transparency in government is a good thing ... provided that transparency is balanced against government's real, valid need for security. What's good for government is, also generally, good for parliament, too.
There is, I believe, an opportunity here for Prime Minister Harper.
_____
* I think the quote can be attributed to U.S. Supreme Court Justice Louis Dembitz Brandeis (1856-1941)
Here in more on Sen Baker's comments, excerpted from a CBC News report:
In a separate interview, Liberal Senator George Baker praised the initiative, saying, "The auditor general is looking at everything," although Michael Ferguson told a Senate committee in June he could not say if he
would examine every senator's expenses or just a sample, or whether he would name errant senators.
Baker did blast MPs for not following suit and inviting the auditor general to put their expenses under the microscope. "If I were mining for gold, I'd go right there with the pan," he said, meaning the House of Commons.
Baker continued, pointing out he was an MP for 29 years before his Senate appointment, "There are three times as many people over there. They have much greater budgets over there. They have much more
leeway in their spending over there. They're not micromanaged like some people are in society. So I imagine the same thing would result and you may have down the road criminal charges laid, and you may see
some people go to jail."
Baker, as a Liberal Senator, will have to join Liberal MPs in September and begin posting his expenses online in fine detail, enumerating every trip and its cost. Publicizing expenses was a promise made by Liberal
Leader Justin Trudeau, who has also publicly disclosed his personal finances.