• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Process+Approvals = Operational & Informational Constipation in AFG?

The Bread Guy

Moderator
Staff member
Directing Staff
Subscriber
Donor
Reaction score
8,796
Points
1,360
An op-ed in the New York Times by a former US Army officer who's been to AFG earlier this year makes me worried about too much process:
THE Taliban commander was back in the village. Our base roared to life as we prepared to capture him. Two Chinook helicopters spun their blades in anticipation in the dark. Fifty Afghan commandos brooded outside, pacing in the gravel. I was nearby, yelling into a phone: “Who else do we need approvals from? Another colonel? Why?”

A villager had come in that afternoon to tell us that a Taliban commander known for his deployment of suicide bombers was threatening the elders. The villager had come to my unit, a detachment of the United States Army stationed in eastern Afghanistan, for help.

Mindful of orders to protect the civilian population, we developed a plan with the Afghan commandos to arrest the Taliban commander that evening before he moved back into Pakistan. While the troops prepared, I spent hours on the phone trying to convince the 11 separate Afghan, American and international forces authorities who needed to sign off to agree on a plan.

Some couldn’t be found. Some liked the idea, others suggested revisions. The plan evolved. Hours passed. The cellphone in the corner rang. “Where are you?” the villager asked urgently. The Taliban commander was drinking tea, he said.

At 5 a.m. the Afghan commandos gave up on us and went home. The helicopters powered down. The sun rose. I was still on the phone trying to arrange approvals. Intelligence arrived indicating that the Taliban commander had moved on. The villagers were incredulous.

This incident is typical of what I saw during my six-month tour in Afghanistan this year. We were paralyzed by red tape, beaten by our own team. Our answer to Afghans seeking help was: “I can’t come today or tomorrow, but maybe next week. I have several bosses that I need to ask for permission.” ....

I hope it's not like this EVERYWHERE in Afghanistan....
 
This is the kind of bureaucratic BS that happened in Vietnam. Having to get approval from several different levels of command, sometimes including POTUS.

Better to beg forgiveness than seek permission....
 
Just west of Khe San we, while on patrol, discoved a truckpark with about 50-75 fully loaded trucks. We dutifully called it in requesting an Arc Light strike.....we sat on our duffs for over 24 hours watching them chill out. Finally, we were ordered to RTB.

They bombed it 3 days later. We went back for BDA.....all we found were bent trees....
 
How overwhelmingly depressing.... :o

~ God save me from my friends. I can protect myself from my enemies. ~    Martin Luther
 
Back
Top