• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

The War in Ukraine

Going back to the Orange Revolution, Putin wanted to keep Ukraine as a poor, corrupt puppet state so the Russian people didn’t look across the border at a higher standard of living and an open society and say “Why don’t we have that”.
Pretty much it in a nut shell
 
Primorsk is about the same distance from St. Petersburg as Ust-Luga, and Novorossiisk is only ~200km away from Crimea. If I were Ukraine I'd hit Primorsk good and hard and force more of their oil exports through the Black Sea.



The Black Sea is an active range. The Baltic is tense but quiet. Less problematic to take potshots in the Black Sea?
Several Baltic Nations have been seizing shadow fleet vessels that sail into their waters.


Well, here's Primorsk. And they aren't shy about going kinetic on shadow fleet ships in the Baltic either.



 
So Poland to send Military into Ukraine to learn how to fight drones...
The Ukrainians are in the UK now training the Brits.

Another CEO died by suicide. He decapitated himself. See around the 10:45 mark for a total of "falling out" with Putin to date.

Not the targeting of the British Council, the EU HQ and the apartment bldg. where EU diplomats live.

 
Cost/Benefit thumbnail sketch:

USSR 2.0 drones about 50k each (average of decoys to live drones that attempted to return to the Belarus Oblast arbitrarily set at $50k as likely many more decoys than drones were used and there is a cost difference between them)

4 drones shot at successfully, $2.2 million per missile. Lets assume only 1 shot per hit and maybe 1 miss for Murphy's sake. $11M lets say $10m just in case some ground based non-missile solution was used (it does not seem any Patriots actually launched although some batteries likely were activated - I stand to be corrected).

But that should not be the cost used in calculating the benefit. It is likely unknowable unless the shooter is within mark 1 eye ball range in daylight with an experienced drone hunter as to precisely what the target is. That is kinda the point of (longer range) decoys sent to map/test air defence coverage, response times and threat magnitude.

The real cost is an opportunity cost. 'What If' any of those 4 shot down had successfully engaged targets with live warheads and were triaged as harmless / left to hit their target; potentially a hospital, apartment block, headquarters, military airfield (although I have not seen any indication yet of a Geran cluster munition variant - something I hope Ukraine is working on it they do not have one already), refinery or other high value target whose value might easily be in the 10's of millions not including loss of life costs to the state, society and the individuals family.

With that in mind the 'Fox 2 ' (AIM-9 Sidewinder - Infared homing) decision is an easy one, even the far more expensive 'Fox 3' (AIM-120 AMRAAM - Radar homing) decision. The unforgiving never tiring bitey things circling your head at night sleep depriving (cue the NFB Blackfly cartoon) WW4/CW2 factor is the absolute shallowness of the "do not dive here / no lifeguard (US) on duty" NATO magazine depth; the ENTIRE collective Wests completely inexcusable scataphillic ostrich proclivities that STILL have prevented adequate contracts being issued, budgets increased, doctrines and war plans revised/updated/trained, and re-election fear tendencies squashed.

The West is so far behind the 8 ball you need a 4-16x50 S&B scope to read it. With luck we might beat a surplus CUCV's downhill 0-60 time in months not seconds.

Not all things can be resolved down to a business case.

So Poland to send Military into Ukraine to learn how to fight drones...

I'll be curious how this ends up.

Un, deux, trois!

France to send warplanes to protect Polish airspace​

President Emmanuel Macron will send three Rafale jets to NATO’s eastern flank following a Russian drone incursion.


🍿

The Rafael is their nuclear delivery jet isn’t it?
In general yes, and those specifically based at Istres Air Base (some of which visited Poland from Istres AB on a Macron-Tusk signaling visit earlier this year), YES.

Armament is the ~300kt Air-Sol Moyenne Portée Améliorée ASMPA Cruise missile with 600km range…about mid-way into Belarus to Moscow… 😉 The fact that France is discussing forward deploying nuclear-capable attack aircraft to Poland has to be giving some of Putin’s inner circle the shits…

 
Back
Top