re:
Perhaps you can challenge Ms Chaplin-Thomas to provide her sources
Maybe this will help! This reprint was found on this web page and states the orginal is in the National Archives
http://www.littletechshoppe.com/ns1625/conbat2a. Maybe I have saved Ms Chaplin-Thomas some time
1916 April 13
Chief of the General Staff
13 April 1916
Memorandum on the
enlistment of Negroes in
Canadian Expeditionary Force
1. Nothing is to be gained by blinking facts. The civilized negro is vain and imitative; in Canada he is not being impelled to enlist by a high sense of duty; in the trenches he is not likely to make a good fighter; and the average white man will not associate with him on terms of equality. Not a single commanding officer in Military District No. 2 is willing to accept a coloured platoon as part of his battalion (H.Q. 297-1-29); and it would be humiliating to the coloured men themselves to serve in a battalion where they were not wanted.
2. In France, in the firing line, there is no place for a black battalion, C.E.F. It would be eyed askance; it would crowd out a white battalion; and it would be difficult to re-inforce.
3. Nor could it be left in England and used as a draft-giving depot; for there would be trouble if negroes were sent to the front for the purpose of reinforcing white battalions; and, if they are any good at all, they would resent being kept in Canada for the purpose of finding guards, etc.
4. It seems, therefore, that three courses are practicable:
(a) As at present, to allow Negroes to enlist, individually, into white battalions at the discretion of commanding officers.
(b) To allow them to form one or more labour battalions. Negroes from Nova Scotia, for example, would not be unsuitable for the purpose.
(c) To ask the British Government if it can make use of a black battalion, C.E.F., on special duty overseas (e.g. in Egypt): but the battalion will not be ready before the fall, and, if only on account of its relatively extravagant rates of pay, it will not mix well with other troops.
5. I recommend courses (a) and (b).
W. Gwatkin
Major-General
Chief of the General Staff
13.4.16
— Original in Public Archives of Canada, Ottawa
Perhaps you can challenge Ms Chaplin-Thomas to provide her sources
Maybe this will help! This reprint was found on this web page and states the orginal is in the National Archives
http://www.littletechshoppe.com/ns1625/conbat2a. Maybe I have saved Ms Chaplin-Thomas some time
1916 April 13
Chief of the General Staff
13 April 1916
Memorandum on the
enlistment of Negroes in
Canadian Expeditionary Force
1. Nothing is to be gained by blinking facts. The civilized negro is vain and imitative; in Canada he is not being impelled to enlist by a high sense of duty; in the trenches he is not likely to make a good fighter; and the average white man will not associate with him on terms of equality. Not a single commanding officer in Military District No. 2 is willing to accept a coloured platoon as part of his battalion (H.Q. 297-1-29); and it would be humiliating to the coloured men themselves to serve in a battalion where they were not wanted.
2. In France, in the firing line, there is no place for a black battalion, C.E.F. It would be eyed askance; it would crowd out a white battalion; and it would be difficult to re-inforce.
3. Nor could it be left in England and used as a draft-giving depot; for there would be trouble if negroes were sent to the front for the purpose of reinforcing white battalions; and, if they are any good at all, they would resent being kept in Canada for the purpose of finding guards, etc.
4. It seems, therefore, that three courses are practicable:
(a) As at present, to allow Negroes to enlist, individually, into white battalions at the discretion of commanding officers.
(b) To allow them to form one or more labour battalions. Negroes from Nova Scotia, for example, would not be unsuitable for the purpose.
(c) To ask the British Government if it can make use of a black battalion, C.E.F., on special duty overseas (e.g. in Egypt): but the battalion will not be ready before the fall, and, if only on account of its relatively extravagant rates of pay, it will not mix well with other troops.
5. I recommend courses (a) and (b).
W. Gwatkin
Major-General
Chief of the General Staff
13.4.16
— Original in Public Archives of Canada, Ottawa
