• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
I know he did Scott Gallagher’s podcast during the election.
I don’t follow Podcasts much, I’ve watched a few here and there. At first glance, sitting with one of these folks doesn’t look much different than sitting down with Peter Mansbridge or Barbara Frumm back in the day.
I think Mark Carney would do well if he can get on with DOAC podcast. Stephen is British-American, very well spoken and would definitely give him a fair shake. Joe would too but Joe will ask the tough and controversial questions.

It would increase the carney Juggernaut. Not sure he ever would though.
 
Except he doesn't know anything if he's not getting the security briefings, and getting the security briefing would in no way stop him from talking about topics that are already in the public realm.

If something was already in the public realm what's the need to get a security clearance? He doesn't seem interested in information he can't readily share.
 
I think Mark Carney would do well if he can get on with DOAC podcast. Stephen is British-American, very well spoken and would definitely give him a fair shake. Joe would too but Joe will ask the tough and controversial questions.

It would increase the carney Juggernaut. Not sure he ever would though.

5622e872-4a13-4458-b473-557a428f0ccc_1920x1080.webp


We also measure how people feel about the way in which the government has approached 23 different topics. On all 23, a majority offers either a “good” or “acceptable” rating. At the top of the performance chart is the government’s effort to diversify trade relations. The results show the continued stress Canadians are feeling on housing affordability and the cost of living, which are the lowest rated areas of performance. Worth noting is that 72% offer a good or acceptable rating for the position taken by the government on the US and Israel war against Iran.

Perhaps the most interesting thing which these results reveal is that the level of partisan polarization is weaker than it has been in recent years. About two thirds of those who voted BQ and NDP last year are satisfied with the government, and 31% of those who voted for Pierre Poilievre’s Conservatives feel that way too.

He's doing pretty well in my opinion.
 
Pierre is usually pretty accurate and on target with his numbers. I do plan to write my MP to confirm this, however Pierre usually has been spot on with his numbers. Lets get back to this one.

Did he use public funds or CPC funds?

Wait, Google AI, take with a grain of salt.

  • Office Expenses: Data for the first three quarters of the 2023-2024 fiscal year showed that Poilievre claimed $143,201 in expenses for his role as the MP for the riding of Carleton.
  • Comparison: This amount was roughly one-quarter of what NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh expensed during the same period ($533,533).
  • Context: The $143k expense was for his parliamentary office, not personal consulting fees. Poilievre was noted as one of the few MPs whose constituency expenses for that period did not include costs for "travel" or "hospitality".
Pierre Poilievre - Conservative Party of Canada

It links to the actual expenses; in Q3 of 25-26 alone he spent $140k on contractors as well as 140K on travel, with another $600k in staff salaries for his office, that's all public funds, just in the Sep-Dec period of 2025. But just an example from a single expense report, where about 15% of what his office spent in 3 months went to consultants out of about a $1M.

Which is fine, and have no issue with his office or Carney's spending that much as the leader of the opposition or PM, but again, $27B of just salary on consultants in a single year is almost 200,000 people (using 140k for an FTE). That doesn't pass any sniff test as being a reasonable, and there is no way we're even contracting that many consultants and reviewing/accepting their work, so is definifitely some kind of cumulative number.

If you took the same during the Harper years, and adjusted it for inflation to 2026 dollars, it's probably a lot bigger number than you would think.
 
I remember in my partisan days raging at Belinda Stronach crossing, then a little while later cheering David Emerson crossing.

Now, I don’t really care. If they were offered a better job, whatever. If this is their one way to hold the leadership of the party accountable for poor leadership if there’s not enough support for a full-on revolt, whatever. They will be held accountable for their decision at the next election for, as Burke would say, using their judgment.
 
I know he did Scott Gallagher’s Galloway’s, aka Prof G, podcast during the election.
I don’t follow Podcasts much, I’ve watched a few here and there. At first glance, sitting with one of these folks doesn’t look much different than sitting down with Peter Mansbridge or Barbara Frumm back in the day.

Sorry, had to FTFY.
 
I remember in my partisan days raging at Belinda Stronach crossing, then a little while later cheering David Emerson crossing.

Now, I don’t really care. If they were offered a better job, whatever. If this is their one way to hold the leadership of the party accountable for poor leadership if there’s not enough support for a full-on revolt, whatever. They will be held accountable for their decision at the next election for, as Burke would say, using their judgment.


Imagine hiring a lawyer to represent you in court only they start pursuing issues counter to your own and your only recourse is to hire different lawyer, but only after paying them for 4 years.
 
Imagine hiring a lawyer to represent you in court only they start pursuing issues counter to your own and your only recourse is to hire different lawyer, but only after paying them for 4 years.
It is not the same thing, at all.

Your MP is your MP whether you voted for them or not. They represent everyone in your riding.
 
Except he doesn't know anything if he's not getting the security briefings, and getting the security briefing would in no way stop him from talking about topics that are already in the public realm.

It's such a massive red herring, and everyone on here regularly talks about things they have deeper knowledge on the high side while sticking to what's open source already, so weird people with actual clearnances and experience in that kind of thing buy into it.

He's basically just talking out of his ass, and pretending getting a clearance and info briefing would somehow muzzle him, it's asinine. If he's not going to get a clearance, fine, but then he should just STFU about the things he's not getting briefed on.
Members of Parliament enjoy immense privilege to speak openly in the context of their Parliamentary duties. Any MP, entrusted with classified information, would be able to disclose same in Parliametary business without fear of prosecution under FISOIA. They would likely lose subsequent access, but the concept of a FISOIA ‘gag’ on utterances made in the course of parliamentary duties simply isn’t true.

*There’s currently a very narrow carve out to that for members of the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians who receive classified information in the course of their NSICOP duties. There’s a Supreme Court decision pending imminently on how that squares with Parliamentary privilege.
 
Imagine hiring a lawyer to represent you in court only they start pursuing issues counter to your own and your only recourse is to hire different lawyer, but only after paying them for 4 years.
Lawyers have a legally recognized and defined duty to a specific individual client, who they advise, but who then instructs them.

MPs represent a constituency but at no point are elected with the expectation that they must and will adhere to a single inflexible viewpoint. With over a hundred thousand constituents per riding that’s unworkable. We choose MPs because we trust them as an individual to do the best they can for our riding in the aggregate.

I’d be ok with a high-threshold recall petition mechanism, but not automatic byelections.
 
Okay, lawyer example was flawed.


We choose MPs because we trust them as an individual to do the best they can for our riding in the aggregate.

I don't think that's what the majority of Canadians do at all. Overwhelmingly we choose based on party affiliation.

MP's can try to champion their ridings needs but at the end of the day how many MP's vote contrary to what their party tells them to do? 1%? And even then it's a one-off.
 
I like to see a requirement that MP's have to go independent for 6 months and have to hold a referendum with the voters in their riding. Election Canada can provide the website and process to vet respondents. Questions are simple:

1. Remain independent
2. Return to the party
3. Join party X
Except becoming an independent doesn't really matter if you've been bribed or blackmailed to cross the floor. You'll still vote for the party that pays you and carry their water. All you do is make it easier for the engineers of the plan to more vehemently deny interfering in democracy.
 
After watching a bit of the Liberal convention, I'm more convinced then ever the LPC under PMMC will make things far worse then they are now.
 
After watching a bit of the Liberal convention, I'm more convinced then ever the LPC under PMMC will make things far worse then they are now.
Drat, I was sure for a second there that Carney was one good speech away from getting you on board.

Maybe next time.
 
I think Mark Carney would do well if he can get on with DOAC podcast. Stephen is British-American, very well spoken and would definitely give him a fair shake. Joe would too but Joe will ask the tough and controversial questions.

It would increase the carney Juggernaut. Not sure he ever would though.
Joe Rogan has been a dud ever since COVID fried his bullshit detector. He'll believe anything anyone tells him pretty uncritically, including lots of fringe and conspiratorial lines. Preferring Russia over Canada is certainly a position.
 
Joe Rogan has been a dud ever since COVID fried his bullshit detector. He'll believe anything anyone tells him pretty uncritically, including lots of fringe and conspiratorial lines. Preferring Russia over Canada is certainly a position.

His style is also softball. Nothing wrong with that but don’t expect anyone getting grilled. If anything, he sounds gullible taking whatever his guest says as gospel. But that’s part of why he’s popular, he tries to have an interesting conversation, not expose his guests as phonies.

A while ago, he had Douglas Murray on. Murray really challenged him about some of his previous guests and how he didn’t challenge any of the garbage they were spewing. Rogan said that’s not what he does. Fair enough, but don’t expect hard-hitting journalism from him.
 
His style is also softball. Nothing wrong with that but don’t expect anyone getting grilled. If anything, he sounds gullible taking whatever his guest says as gospel. But that’s part of why he’s popular, he tries to have an interesting conversation, not expose his guests as phonies.
100%. Rogan has unscripted conversations with people, many with controversial views. He gives people space to talk. There's other shows if people want to hear guests carefully prepared scripted answers to softball questions under the guise of journalism.
 
Joe Rogan this, Joe That...He has more viewers than almost all other podcast.
 
Back
Top