• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
Similar, but, thankfully, not me, but sitting beside the missus or daughter with toddler grandson. A lot of the stuff that the ER sees could quite easily be handled by a walk-in clinic or similar alternative, but where is the funding for those? Most of people sitting in the waiting room either don't have a doctor, do have a doctor but can't get time off from their precarious employment or, in the case of an infant, aren't willing to wait until Monday to try an alternative. Our family doctors are 3 hours away, and won't prescribe antibiotics over a virtual appointment. It's hard to get a diagnosis for that 'thing on your butt' via Zoom. When all else fails, go to the ER, and take snacks and a book.

Our local hospital has had a few layoff rounds of nurses and support staff. Thankfully, they haven't had to close the ER, but have had days when only one doctor is on duty. I just checked the current wait time at 4 hours; it's been as high as 9.

I could not find any data on hospital administration cost trends, but did find that Ontario has to low rate of hospital funding in several measures (per capita, per gdp). I know in urban areas like Toronto, hospitals have been grouped into 'networks' covering several hospitals, so I can imagine of you are the CEO or similar high administrator of 3 or 4 hospital sites, you are going to command a higher compensation than simply running one.
layers of bureaucracy. Each individual facility has a director who is simply the CEO one level down. Maintenance is the same cost, taxes the same, some savings in supplies I would expect but all at the expenses of increased office costs throughout the network. so they nickel and dime on the front line workers. Part-time staff, no replacement for the first person who calls in sick that kind of thing.
 
Right but the point’s not simply the registration and voluntary compliance by those playing within the rules; it’s the considerable new enforcement options once intelligence or law enforcement investigation identify that a person or entity is non-compliant. I could easily trace a direct path from failure to register, where intelligence has identified a foreign interference nexus, through to full blown national security criminal investigation for offences under the new FISOIA legislation that carry up to life in prison and are sentenced consecutively.

One does not create new legal obligations and criminal offences with the expectation that all the criminals will suddenly fall in line and obey.

Remember how the U.S. ultimately got Al Capone.
 
Right but the point’s not simply the registration and voluntary compliance by those playing within the rules; it’s the considerable new enforcement options once intelligence or law enforcement investigation identify that a person or entity is non-compliant. I could easily trace a direct path from failure to register, where intelligence has identified a foreign interference nexus, through to full blown national security criminal investigation for offences under the new FISOIA legislation that carry up to life in prison and are sentenced consecutively.

One does not create new legal obligations and criminal offences with the expectation that all the criminals will suddenly fall in line and obey.

Those enforcement powers mean very little if authorities aren't identifying and going after non-compliance though. If there are an estimated 2,400 people who should be registered and only 9 names on the registry what kind enforcement has begun against them?

The Foreign Influence Commissioner’s testimony (to the house committee) said:
-no notices of violation or investigations had been opened at that point (6 Oct 26, 2 months after it went online)
-the office was still validating registrations and preparing to identify people and organizations that should have registered but had not (fair); and
-acknowledged that the government had not provided him with a definitive list of the estimated 2,422 potential registrants.

Why would the government not provide that? To me that suggests they're not taking it seriously.

Dr. Leah West (served on the research council for the public inquiry into foreign interference) also agreed Canada did not have an effective registry.

Counter-point - it's only been 2 months. I'll put a sticky on my screen to revisit this in a year and see what enforcement happened over the year.


brihard said:
Remember how the U.S. ultimately got Al Capone.
Lack of penicillin :sneaky:
 
Those enforcement powers mean very little if authorities aren't identifying and going after non-compliance though. If there are an estimated 2,400 people who should be registered and only 9 names on the registry what kind enforcement has begun against them?
Why would we expect that information to be publicly visible? Investigations into such matters, like any investigation, and particularly those informed by national security intelligence, can be reasonably expected to be pretty discrete until and unless there are overt actions like search warrant executions or prosecutions. The Commissioner did announce reaching out to about 60 persons or entities affiliated with the Alberta referendum so clearly some work has started. That many suggests to me there’s some prioritization at work, but that’s a guess.
The Foreign Influence Commissioner’s testimony (to the house committee) said:
-no notices of violation or investigations had been opened at that point (6 Oct 26, 2 months after it went online)
-the office was still validating registrations and preparing to identify people and organizations that should have registered but had not (fair); and
-acknowledged that the government had not provided him with a definitive list of the estimated 2,422 potential registrants.

Why would the government not provide that? To me that suggests they're not taking it seriously.
I suspect it’ll take a while to ramp up given they’re newly established. It takes time to hire and train people who can competently perform investigations.

I don’t know why there hasn’t been some master list provided; my guess is sis that was an estimate based on previous reporting and probably security intelligence sources. The organizations holding that data will want to be very clear on what can and cannot be shared and acted upon before handing anything over for regulatory or criminal investigation. I think we’re in ‘watch and shoot’ for this.
Dr. Leah West (served on the research council for the public inquiry into foreign interference) also agreed Canada did not have an effective registry.
She’s good shit (former Dragoon notwithstanding). I’ve had a class with her, she’s super knowledgeable on the national security and intelligence law side of the house from her NS legal work with DOJ. She does have some knowledge or experience gaps on the criminal investigation side of some subjects; nothing wrong with that, it’s not the world she comes from. The odd time that’s happened I’ve found her receptive and interested in perspectives that fill those gaps in. We’ve talked about the very new registry in class in the past, and the way it will likely interface with other law enforcement and regulatory powers. Lots of ‘forward looking’ on that. Out of respect for the ‘Chatham house’ approach to a lot of in class discussion I don’t want to stray beyond that.
Counter-point - it's only been 2 months. I'll put a sticky on my screen to revisit this in a year and see what enforcement happened over the year.
That’s very fair and probably a good idea. I would certainly hope to see more by then than we do now… Although if any foreign interference criminal investigations emerge from it, it could still be a while yet before we see or hear anything public.
Lack of penicillin :sneaky:
🤣
 
Why would we expect that information to be publicly visible? Investigations into such matters, like any investigation, and particularly those informed by national security intelligence, can be reasonably expected to be pretty discrete until and unless there are overt actions like search warrant executions or prosecutions. The Commissioner did announce reaching out to about 60 persons or entities affiliated with the Alberta referendum so clearly some work has started. That many suggests to me there’s some prioritization at work, but that’s a guess.
/UnsolicitedSociopoliticalthought

Public interest, transparency, and maybe rebuild trust in the Parliament and government.

Someone from our spy department risked life in prison to inform Canadians there was a lot of foreign interference happening with the government, and they weren't taking it seriously. When called out on it, the Trudeau government (which is like 97% of the Carney government, bent over backwards trying to brush it under the table.
[It looks like the only MP that was fired for possible interference (reasons still unknown) was a Liberal safe seat that let Carney slide in nearly unopposed]

Canadians don't need to know the intimate details of ongoing investigations. They do deserve to know this government is taking it seriously and doing something about it. I.e there's actually investigations on going.

Americans interfering with Alberta's doomed should we ask if we should separate vote seems manifestly less serious than Russian, Indian, and Chinese foreign interference in Canada over the last decade.

I don’t know why there hasn’t been some master list provided; my guess is sis that was an estimate based on previous reporting and probably security intelligence sources. The organizations holding that data will want to be very clear on what can and cannot be shared and acted upon before handing anything over for regulatory or criminal investigation. I think we’re in ‘watch and shoot’ for this.
It took longer than average to get the registry going. The defense was they wanted to make sure they got it right. That makes sense. You would figure in 2 years they could have figured out what can and cannot be shared. That seems like it would be an integral part of the process. Considering the only investigations so far is regarding the Alberta referendum one might thibk the government is anxious to bypass all that 2022 interference stuff. Especially with the economic ties we're pushing with India and China.

Lots of ‘forward looking’ on that. Out of respect for the ‘Chatham house’ approach to a lot of in class discussion I don’t want to stray beyond that.
Do you mean the conversations between you and her? Or the whole class discussion?

That’s very fair and probably a good idea. I would certainly hope to see more by then than we do now… Although if any foreign interference criminal investigations emerge from it, it could still be a while yet before we see or hear anything public.
Agreed. Let's put a pin in it, circle back in 365 days to let them operationalize the strategic alignment framework, conduct a retrospective assessment of deliverables, evaluate stakeholder accountability to measure execution against stated objectives, and determine whether any meaningful progress has translated into tangible measurable outcomes.
 
Back
Top