• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Hamas invaded Israel 2023 Megathread

  • Thread starter Thread starter McG
  • Start date Start date
Guaranteed voting rights and human rights for some. They are a segregated society which actively prevents many living in the country from getting citizenship.



So we should just not fix or attempt to fix genocide and terrorism because the extremists will keep pushing for more? That is like saying the States should never have integrated their population because the USSR used it as propaganda. Evil triumphs when good men do nothing.
Apparently the Good Men Persons (FTFY) take the easy route all the time to earn their accolades, it's easy and safe to go after Israel and Jews and until recently in the comfort and safety provide by said "Evil State" Here is a list of some of the Israel supreme court case, call me when you found successful cases against the government in KSA, UAE or Qatar Summary of cases from the Israeli Supreme Court, 2019-2020 | Cardozo Israeli Supreme Court Project
 
So we should just not fix or attempt to fix genocide and terrorism beause the extremists will keep pushing for more? That is like saying the States should never have integrated their population because the USSR used it as propaganda. Evil triumphs when good men do nothing.
People who object to Israel would love it if moderates would concentrate all their fire on Israel. My point is that moderates might consider concentrating their fire on illiberal societies in due proportion to how illiberal those societies are. For my part, I haven't enough time to complain sufficiently about all the really egregious ones, which leaves less than no time for passing Israel under the harrow other than simply noting the existence of its flaws.

What the world needs is for pretty much all the Islamic countries from Morocco to Pakistan to achieve a level of civil and religious reform comparable to the evolution of the mostly Christian countries over the past 500 years. That's Job One.
 
South Africa also had a parliamentary democracy, human rights and guaranteed voting rights - for some.
Sure. That was us a while back, too.

Countries and societies are progressing at different rates and occasionally there is backsliding. Critically, some are a greater threat to liberalism than others. Israel is not a particularly great threat to liberalism or at risk of backsliding except under existential pressure.

It'd be one thing if Canada was simply home to some well-intentioned critics of Israel, but it is beyond contradiction that some of the people Canada has been admitting are opposed not only to the existence of Israel, but also the existence of Canada as long as it falls outside the permitted boundaries of their ideologies. We need to end that, and we need to focus limited resources on the greatest problems. We ought to be pushing liberalism in large chunks where it is most absent, not fighting rearguard actions to prevent barbarians from replacing liberalism where it happens to be imperfect (which is still the case everywhere) and giving them comfort by appearing to take their sides. We get in their faces and advance our ideas on their turf, not they on ours.

I am confident that if existential pressure against Israel were removed, much of its illiberal behaviour would also disappear.

I am confident that what Israel is right now is better (much, much, much better) than any likely replacement, given the cultures and attitudes in the region. It's close to the apex of idiocy to sit in judgement without serious contemplation of what the practical alternatives are.
 
Guaranteed voting rights and human rights for some. They are a segregated society which actively prevents many living in the country from getting citizenship.



So we should just not fix or attempt to fix genocide and terrorism because the extremists will keep pushing for more? That is like saying the States should never have integrated their population because the USSR used it as propaganda. Evil triumphs when good men do nothing.

??

BLUF: I'm an athiest, but my children have Jewish blood in their veins (I do not). Although I'm an athiest I am currently wearing my daughter-in-laws Magen David around my neck (since December 2023 when I took it from her to wear myself) because she is too intimidated to wear it herself due to the intimidation and grief she was is subject to by her fellow-students at her Liberal Arts post-secondary institution in a small-sized Canadian city here in Atlantic Canada.

I've also served in Israel whilst wearing a Canadian uniform and a blue beret. Then began the Second Intifada. On May 18th 2001, I was on my day off and headed to Netayna to the beach with my roomie. I popped into the Hasharon shopping complex looking to buy a new swimsuit while there when BOOM - it was a bloody mess. Their crime? Being Jewish. In August 2001, I was part of an organized day trip into Jerusalem when BOOM went a pizzeria up the road from us - it was a bloody fucking mess. Their crime? Being Jewish and daring to exist. That was my last excursion in Israel prior to my departure. At the end of Aug 2001, I went about Damascus paying off my tabs prior to my departure and had very pleasant conversations with those I had dealt with. One of the vendors (not Druze or Christian) asked when I was leaving and I told him the end of the week. His response "good, you're getting out before the war starts". Hmmmm. When I got back to camp, I reported the conversation and the specific comment to Zero Bunker who reported it up the UN chain. I flew out of Tel Aviv on September 4th 2001 and was still on my disembarkation leave on 11th September 2001 when the first plane hit the building and when I saw the footage on TV and realized it was not a small plane but a large one my mind was already in action with a "no way that's an accident" and started getting drressed. When the second plane hit, I woke my husband up and stated "we're going to war and I'm going to work". I lived in Belleville but as I passed the front gate of 8 Wing the Public Servants were on picket and I yelled out the window for them to go watch the news. I walked into work, in uniform, walked up to the CWO and COs office area to a round of "What are you doing here? You're not back for another 2 weeks". I told them to get the conference room TV going because we were going to war. They stood there gawking and telling me that I was jumping to some pretty serious conclusions. But I knew .... I knew after the first plane hit and I knew who did it.

All this to say, sometimes actual lived experience informs one's judgements and conclusions.

In 2005, Israel pulled out of Gaza. Dismantled the Jewish settlements there and relocated them, dug up and moved their cemetaries etc. They left the Palestinians in charge of their own governance and who they'd elect. Likewise the West Bank - Palestinians then had their elections in both the West Bank and Gaza. Although both locations favoured different entities (Fatah, Hamas etc), they got what they voted for. I note that no Israeli citizens were permitted to vote in those elections.

Israeli citizens (ALL of them) vote in Israeli elections (and serve in their government too!!). Palestinians vote in Palestinian elections (SOME of those citizens anyway). The fact that who the Palestinians chose to represent them have all failed to hold any elections since is NOT an Israel problem. It is a Palestinian problem. Why did Jordan take away citizenship from these Palestinians? Ever asked yourself that question?

Meanwhile, we'll all wax poetic about how Israel is evil and an apartheid state, and believe that Canada is more moral than virtually every nation. All this while we continue to fund non-democratic entities like the Palestinian Authority, cozy up to socialist and dictatorial regimes and completely ignore the terrorist-funding nations that commit crimes against humanity against their own citizens in the tens of thousands (IRGC), the actual genocides happening alongside the Islamic epansionism through the dirt-poor African continent.

It's like a warped version of South Park where "Blame Canada" is the norm for south of our border. We're the North Park show where "Blame the Jews (and Israel) and the US" is now the norm. That's a Canada problem.

I can tell you this much, an existential threat is an exisential threat. Full stop. I live in New Brunswick and if rockets were coming into this province daily from Maine, I'd damn well expect my government to not wait decades after multtudes of suicide bombings, kidnappings and murders, until an October 7th happened to do something about it. I'd hope all Canadians would share the same hope.

Maybe it's just me.

Am Israel Chai. And I for one am glad that they do.
 
??

BLUF: I'm an athiest, but my children have Jewish blood in their veins (I do not). Although I'm an athiest I am currently wearing my daughter-in-laws Magen David around my neck (since December 2023 when I took it from her to wear myself) because she is too intimidated to wear it herself due to the intimidation and grief she was is subject to by her fellow-students at her Liberal Arts post-secondary institution in a small-sized Canadian city here in Atlantic Canada.
Racism and discrimination exist everywhere. I personally couldn't care less about religion other than the effects people have trying to control me with it. I neither like nor hate Jewish people, Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, Hindus, etc. I treat it on a individual basis.

Yes some people are targeting Jews at the moment, just like how some people target Muslims, or Christians, etc. It doesn't help for the Jewish population that Israel actively works to portray any attacks/criticisms of it as anti-semitism rather than a criticism of Israel the country. When you use propaganda to link the two together, it can backfire if people lose the fear of being called anti-semitic.
I've also served in Israel whilst wearing a Canadian uniform and a blue beret. Then began the Second Intifada. On May 18th 2001, I was on my day off and headed to Netayna to the beach with my roomie. I popped into the Hasharon shopping complex looking to buy a new swimsuit while there when BOOM - it was a bloody mess. Their crime? Being Jewish. In August 2001, I was part of an organized day trip into Jerusalem when BOOM went a pizzeria up the road from us - it was a bloody fucking mess. Their crime? Being Jewish and daring to exist. That was my last excursion in Israel prior to my departure. At the end of Aug 2001, I went about Damascus paying off my tabs prior to my departure and had very pleasant conversations with those I had dealt with. One of the vendors (not Druze or Christian) asked when I was leaving and I told him the end of the week. His response "good, you're getting out before the war starts". Hmmmm. When I got back to camp, I reported the conversation and the specific comment to Zero Bunker who reported it up the UN chain. I flew out of Tel Aviv on September 4th 2001 and was still on my disembarkation leave on 11th September 2001 when the first plane hit the building and when I saw the footage on TV and realized it was not a small plane but a large one my mind was already in action with a "no way that's an accident" and started getting drressed. When the second plane hit, I woke my husband up and stated "we're going to war and I'm going to work". I lived in Belleville but as I passed the front gate of 8 Wing the Public Servants were on picket and I yelled out the window for them to go watch the news. I walked into work, in uniform, walked up to the CWO and COs office area to a round of "What are you doing here? You're not back for another 2 weeks". I told them to get the conference room TV going because we were going to war. They stood there gawking and telling me that I was jumping to some pretty serious conclusions. But I knew .... I knew after the first plane hit and I knew who did it.
I can also sit here and point out all the Palestinians who have been killed by Israel for daring to exist. Right now there is Palestinians being harassed and killed in the West Bank for having the audacity to farm the land they have always lived on.

The whole concept of Israel is one of religious fanaticism (Zionism), based upon the idea that 'God gave them that land'. That isn't a good argument to me on whether or not a country should exist.
All this to say, sometimes actual lived experience informs one's judgements and conclusions.

In 2005, Israel pulled out of Gaza. Dismantled the Jewish settlements there and relocated them, dug up and moved their cemetaries etc. They left the Palestinians in charge of their own governance and who they'd elect. Likewise the West Bank - Palestinians then had their elections in both the West Bank and Gaza. Although both locations favoured different entities (Fatah, Hamas etc), they got what they voted for. I note that no Israeli citizens were permitted to vote in those elections.
When your options are dying slowly well being harassed and abused (West Bank) or dying fighting (Gaza) no matter what decision they make they lose. Israel is not serious about peace and never has been. The Israeli version of peace is slowly strangling the Palestinians until they don't exist.
Israeli citizens (ALL of them) vote in Israeli elections (and serve in their government too!!). Palestinians vote in Palestinian elections (SOME of those citizens anyway). The fact that who the Palestinians chose to represent them have all failed to hold any elections since is NOT an Israel problem. It is a Palestinian problem. Why did Jordan take away citizenship from these Palestinians? Ever asked yourself that question?
So actively controlling who can vote isn't a issue for you? They prevent many from getting citizenship and being able to vote based on race and religion. For a country which is supposedly secular they fail to pass that test. Explain to me how it makes sense someone who has never lived in a country can walk in and due to their religion be granted citizenship, yet the people who have lived there for millenia are denied the same rights?

Why are Palestinians in Jordan to begin with? The answer is their homeland was taken from them and now they are refugees. That isn't their fault no more than it is the fault of any group that has been forced from their homes. You too might be bitter if given the same lot in life as the Palestinian people.


Meanwhile, we'll all wax poetic about how Israel is evil and an apartheid state, and believe that Canada is more moral than virtually every nation. All this while we continue to fund non-democratic entities like the Palestinian Authority, cozy up to socialist and dictatorial regimes and completely ignore the terrorist-funding nations that commit crimes against humanity against their own citizens in the tens of thousands (IRGC), the actual genocides happening alongside the Islamic epansionism through the dirt-poor African continent.

It's like a warped version of South Park where "Blame Canada" is the norm for south of our border. We're the North Park show where "Blame the Jews (and Israel) and the US" is now the norm. That's a Canada problem.

I can tell you this much, an existential threat is an exisential threat. Full stop. I live in New Brunswick and if rockets were coming into this province daily from Maine, I'd damn well expect my government to not wait decades after multtudes of suicide bombings, kidnappings and murders, until an October 7th happened to do something about it. I'd hope all Canadians would share the same hope.

Maybe it's just me.

Am Israel Chai. And I for one am glad that they do.
Maybe if they chose not to invade and conquer the people in the area they wouldn't be attacked by them. A fairer comparison would be if you invaded and settled in Maine, evicting the locals from the land, brutally harassing and killing them, and once they start fighting back you start whining about how unfair it is that your being targeted as your still killing them. October 7th was a disgusting attack by Hamas, but that doesn't excuse the Israeli acts leading up to it, during it, or after it.

If you choose to create the existential threat, then remain in the area with the existential threat, that is on you. Much like how a Russian in Ukraine will feel the Ukrainians fighting back is a existential threat to themselves. It is, but it only exists because of choices you made. If the threat is too great, you can always leave.
 
My nephew married a non observant Jewish lady. At their wedding I did shots with her brothers - one is a money maker in banking, the other one was doing his service in Israel.

I will never do shot for shot ever again.
 
So actively controlling who can vote isn't a issue for you? They prevent many from getting citizenship and being able to vote based on race and religion. For a country which is supposedly secular they fail to pass that test. Explain to me how it makes sense someone who has never lived in a country can walk in and due to their religion be granted citizenship, yet the people who have lived there for millenia are denied the same rights?
Did you actually read what she wrote??
 
Did you actually read what she wrote??
Do you not understand how Israel actively prevents muslims living within Israel from getting Israeli citizenship and thus the ability to vote.

We used to do similar things as well, like not allowing all Indians to vote until 1960, or having land ownership requirements. All methods of controlling who gets a say.

The closest thing is South Africa’s apartheid in which black South Africans were made citizens of a ‘homeland’ and couldn’t vote in South African elections as they weren’t South African citizens. Israel plays the same game.
 
Racism and discrimination exist everywhere. I personally couldn't care less about religion other than the effects people have trying to control me with it. I neither like nor hate Jewish people, Muslims, Christians, Sikhs, Hindus, etc. I treat it on a individual basis.

It doesn't help for the Jewish population that Israel actively works to portray any attacks/criticisms of it as anti-semitism rather than a criticism of Israel the country.
That's fair. Just like people treating criticism of Islam as Islamophobia.

I can also sit here and point out all the Palestinians who have been killed by Israel for daring to exist. Right now there is Palestinians being harassed and killed in the West Bank for having the audacity to farm the land they have always lived on.

The whole concept of Israel is one of religious fanaticism (Zionism), based upon the idea that 'God gave them that land'. That isn't a good argument to me on whether or not a country should exist.
Calling all Zionism religious fanaticism is just wrong. Zionism isn't exclusively religious, it's also about Jewish people having the same right to national selfdetermination as everyone else. Particularly given their history of persecution. You don't have to agree with Israeli government policies to recognize Israel's right to exist the same way Palestinians have a right to exist.


Israel is not serious about peace and never has been.
Claiming Israel has never been serious about peace seems historically inaccurate. Israel entered peace agreements with Egypt and Jordan, participated in the Oslo process, and made pretty significant territorial proposals to the Palestinians at Camp David. Also in subsequent negotiations. Yes those efforts ultimately failed but that was involving decisions and actions by both sides.


So actively controlling who can vote isn't a issue for you? They prevent many from getting citizenship and being able to vote based on race and religion. For a country which is supposedly secular they fail to pass that test. Explain to me how it makes sense someone who has never lived in a country can walk in and due to their religion be granted citizenship, yet the people who have lived there for millenia are denied the same rights?
That's comparing 2 different legal situations. Israel's law of return gives Jewish people around the world a right to immigrate and obtain citizenship. Palestinians claims to citizenship, residency and a right of return are a separate, deeply contested issue. I don't think that contradiction should be brushed aside but it also doesn't mean Jewish self determination is inherently illegitimate. The question no one seems to be able to answer is how to protect the rights and self determination of both sides.

Why are Palestinians in Jordan to begin with? The answer is their homeland was taken from them and now they are refugees. That isn't their fault no more than it is the fault of any group that has been forced from their homes. You too might be bitter if given the same lot in life as the Palestinian people.
Then turned around and started a civil war in the country that took them in.


Maybe if they chose not to invade and conquer the people in the area they wouldn't be attacked by them. A fairer comparison would be if you invaded and settled in Maine, evicting the locals from the land, brutally harassing and killing them, and once they start fighting back you start whining about how unfair it is that your being targeted as your still killing them. October 7th was a disgusting attack by Hamas, but that doesn't excuse the Israeli acts leading up to it, during it, or after it.

If you choose to create the existential threat, then remain in the area with the existential threat, that is on you. Much like how a Russian in Ukraine will feel the Ukrainians fighting back is a existential threat to themselves. It is, but it only exists because of choices you made. If the threat is too great, you can always leave.
In 2005 Israel dismantled 21 settlements, forced the evacuation of 9000+ settlers, removed military instillations, and left a bunch of infrastructure. Palestinians looted it, and elected Hamas shortly after who turned around and immediately started attacking Israel.
 
Do you not understand how Israel actively prevents muslims living within Israel from getting Israeli citizenship and thus the ability to vote.
I don't,.....but the fact they can shows a frig of a lot more tolerance then they are afforded. Curious, have you ever been there?
 
Back
Top