• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
I am tired of Canada being insistant on being someones puppet state. Our country is the most gifted on the planet in terms of location, resources, and population. Yet somehow we squander that.

Bang on.

St Patricks Day Drinking GIF by All Better
 
We should as it is clear the reason for the initial building of those locks still exists.

We created the Canadian side locks because the Americans denied us transit of our ships with troops on them to go fight the Northwest Rebellion so they had to completely disembark with all the stores and equipment, portage the equipment above the rapids, and re-embark after the locks.

Nation building is expensive, but maintaining sovereignty comes with a cost.

I am tired of Canada being insistant on being someones puppet state. Our country is the most gifted on the planet in terms of location, resources, and population. Yet somehow we squander that.
I'm very confused.

Spending billions to build infrastructure that doesnt currently exist but would get a fair bit of use is too expensive for some (HSR), but spending billions to build infrastructure that is redundant and will likely not be used except in the most extreme of circumstances is nation building?
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I'm very confused.

Spending billions to build infrastructure that doesnt currently exist but would get a fair bit of use is too expensive for some (HSR), but spending billions to build infrastructure that is redundant and will likely not be used except in the most extreme of circumstances is nation building?
Considering the States is currently upgrading their side of the locks and we want to open up the ring of fire, yes that is nation building. There is demand, if we choose to be a part of it is the question.

I am also a big proponent of railways, across the whole country. The amount we spend on roads if spent on railways would give us a much better return on a more environmentally friendly and safe method of transportation.
 
Defence expenditures aren't nation-building; they're nation-preserving. The necessary and sufficient conditions for a society are the means and will to defend it.
Although the arguement can be made some projects are nation building when they have duel use. Example shipyards, ports
 
Although the arguement can be made some projects are nation building when they have duel use. Example shipyards, ports
We might have to cede some of the usual ground here to secure the assets against sabotage and other attack. I would rather place large areas completely off-limits than expend a bunch of resources trying to find ways to fit dual-use in without compromising security.
 
I guess I see a line between absolute sovereignty in all matters, simply for its own sake, and mutually beneficial cooperation with a neighbour who, up until fairly recently, treated us as an ally and with a degree of respect. If we want to spend billions on building locks and dredging channels that parallel that which already exists, simply to say they're ours, strikes me as sovereignty without economic reality. Unless we would plan to legislatively force Canadian flagged ships to use 'our side', it would probably devolve into a rate war that we likely couldn't win.

As for railways, we had more, then they became uneconomical. The major carriers can move more in a 2km long train that it predecessors could even dream of. So long as they are private, for-profit companies, they will build or expand when their current infrastructure is maxed-out. Passenger rail could be better, but with our population distribution and density, we ain't going back to the 'golden age of train travel' anytime soon.
 
As for railways, we had more, then they became uneconomical. The major carriers can move more in a 2km long train that it predecessors could even dream of. So long as they are private, for-profit companies, they will build or expand when their current infrastructure is maxed-out. Passenger rail could be better, but with our population distribution and density, we ain't going back to the 'golden age of train travel' anytime soon.
Yeah good in theory, corporate welfare says differently in practice.

They intentionally let things get to a bad point (i.e. not spending on maintenance/expansion, rather taking that money and spending on themselves), at which point the government steps in and pays for it because it is a critical capacity.

Private doesn't mean well run, as much as some seem to think it does. It just means they take all the money they can out of it. Remember my profits, our losses...
 
Yeah good in theory, corporate welfare says differently in practice.

They intentionally let things get to a bad point (i.e. not spending on maintenance/expansion, rather taking that money and spending on themselves), at which point the government steps in and pays for it because it is a critical capacity.

Private doesn't mean well run, as much as some seem to think it does. It just means they take all the money they can out of it. Remember my profits, our losses...
Other than money for safety upgrades at crossings and other specific initiatives, and money they have given to some shortlines, does the federal government bail out the Class 1 roads for maintenance, expansion or operating expenses?
 
Bit of buyers remorse maybe?

Federal officials on the defensive as momentum grows against lawful access bill


Nicole Giles, deputy director of policy and strategic partnerships at the Canadian Security Intelligence Service (CSIS) said during a recent interview.

"Canada is the only Five Eyes country without a lawful access regime..."

Either the deputy director of policy and strategic partnerships at CSIS somehow doesn't know Canada already has a lawful access regime or they're ripping a page out of the firearms ban book and hoping Canadians don't fact check.
 
Bit of buyers remorse maybe?

Federal officials on the defensive as momentum grows against lawful access bill




Either the deputy director of policy and strategic partnerships at CSIS somehow doesn't know Canada already has a lawful access regime or they're ripping a page out of the firearms ban book and hoping Canadians don't fact check.
What a difference the choice of noun and lack of an adjective can make :(
 
Last edited:
And then what?

What are the 3 possible large contracts that could from this?
This is significant. Canada is the only country outside of the EU (including the UK) that was invited to join SAFE.


This gains Canadian defence manufacturers easier access to European markets. The sad truth is that both investors and the CAF prefer dealing with companies that already have products on the market. This market access tool will build the Defence Industrial Base that the CAF needs for resilience, readiness, and rapid procure / deploy.

Not every move is designed for a quick win...especially if you have severely atrophied the industrial infrastructure over the last 50 years.
 
This is significant. Canada is the only country outside of the EU (including the UK) that was invited to join SAFE.


This gains Canadian defence manufacturers easier access to European markets. The sad truth is that both investors and the CAF prefer dealing with companies that already have products on the market. This market access tool will build the Defence Industrial Base that the CAF needs for resilience, readiness, and rapid procure / deploy.

Not every move is designed for a quick win...especially if you have severely atrophied the industrial infrastructure over the last 50 years.
Thanks for that more in depth explanation. Let's hope that we are able to execute on it going forward.
 
This is significant. Canada is the only country outside of the EU (including the UK) that was invited to join SAFE.


This gains Canadian defence manufacturers easier access to European markets. The sad truth is that both investors and the CAF prefer dealing with companies that already have products on the market. This market access tool will build the Defence Industrial Base that the CAF needs for resilience, readiness, and rapid procure / deploy.

Not every move is designed for a quick win...especially if you have severely atrophied the industrial infrastructure over the last 50 years.
now how quickly can we spin up munitions manufacturing. Everyone seems to be jumping on the drone bandwagon so munitions systems would seem to be the way to go.
 
now how quickly can we spin up munitions manufacturing. Everyone seems to be jumping on the drone bandwagon so munitions systems would seem to be the way to go.
Aside from that kind of thing, there are lots of Canadian products that other nations might use for their own platforms; the RCN has some unique comms and platform control systems that are already exported (the new QE carrier IPMS is essentially the CPF one with a facelift), and lots of things like chip detect technology for the POL systems and other unsexy but critical things that can easily be used.

Bit more distributed, but supplying hundreds of components from dozens of companies is a lot easier to manage then trying to muscle in on full weapon platform replacements, especially when a lot of other countries have existing policies of buying from domestic where they can, and also a lot easier to make dual use products for a general wider market.

Having big defence suppliers is nice, but sometimes having a slice of a much larger pie actually supports more jobs and brings in more to the economy then being big fish in a small pond.
 
Back
Top