• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
Is this the monent that the LPC is about to enter freefall?

CBC will never say it because they are too busy boot licking Carney but the signs are there.

I will remind you once again, Chrystia Freeland stepped down and that's when the writting was on the wall for Trudeau.

Steven Guilbault will leave parliament and then go full scorced earth on the LPC which will tank the LPC in Quebec. The entire left flank of the LPC will flock to the NDP and a few members floor cross to the greens or sit as independents bringing the LPC back to a minority.

My prediction? Carney popularity will plummet fast and he manufactures an election or loses a confidence vote.

Deeds not words.

He explained why he was stepping down. I don't think it's going to move the needle too much, not with the population currently being very supportive of various national projects and that includes oil and gas.

Guilbeault says Canada 'backsliding' on climate action as he resigns as MP​

 
When will the Liberals lose melanie Joly?

Brian Liley drops some reality on Minister Joly's fantasies

 
When will the Liberals lose melanie Joly?

Brian Liley drops some reality on Minister Joly's fantasies

I think, sadly, that she sticks around longer. She needs to ‘redeem’ herself under Carney in order to wipe the stink from the Trudeau years and to better position yourself for whatever comes next.
 
Is this the monent that the LPC is about to enter freefall?

CBC will never say it because they are too busy boot licking Carney but the signs are there.

I will remind you once again, Chrystia Freeland stepped down and that's when the writting was on the wall for Trudeau.

Steven Guilbault will leave parliament and then go full scorced earth on the LPC which will tank the LPC in Quebec. The entire left flank of the LPC will flock to the NDP and a few members floor cross to the greens or sit as independents bringing the LPC back to a minority.

My prediction? Carney popularity will plummet fast and he manufactures an election or loses a confidence vote.

Deeds not words.

Sure. Guilbeault was holding the government together…

1779971612371.gif
 
Yeah. Not sure about putting Guilbault in the same league as Freeland. And does he really have that much sway in Quebec?
 
Is this the monent that the LPC is about to enter freefall?

CBC will never say it because they are too busy boot licking Carney but the signs are there.

I will remind you once again, Chrystia Freeland stepped down and that's when the writting was on the wall for Trudeau.

Steven Guilbault will leave parliament and then go full scorced earth on the LPC which will tank the LPC in Quebec. The entire left flank of the LPC will flock to the NDP and a few members floor cross to the greens or sit as independents bringing the LPC back to a minority.

My prediction? Carney popularity will plummet fast and he manufactures an election or loses a confidence vote.

Deeds not words.
The QC prediction assumes he carries a lot of political water there. I hear he doesn’t but we’ll see.

I don’t think one fringe type leaving = the downfall of Team Red at this point.
 
The QC prediction assumes he carries a lot of political water there. I hear he doesn’t but we’ll see.

I don’t think one fringe type leaving = the downfall of Team Red at this point.
Quebec still appears adamant to prevent any carbon fuel related projects from being accepted in the province so perhaps he might have more influence than you think. Hopefully he doesn't but in La Belle Province, who knows>
 
If Guilbeault really wanted to screw over Carney he could've crossed the floor. This resignation is pure theatrics of a spoiled activist who didn't get his way.
Crossed to where? Which party aligns would align with him?
 
Crossed to where? Which party aligns would align with him?
Does it matter if his intent was to damage the LPC brand? Even if he were to sit as an independent, I suspect he would still support the LPC against the opposition.
 
He explained why he was stepping down. I don't think it's going to move the needle too much, not with the population currently being very supportive of various national projects and that includes oil and gas.

Guilbeault says Canada 'backsliding' on climate action as he resigns as MP​

Even as an MP and environment minister, plenty of the LPC faithful thought he was nuts, let alone the general population. I admire that he has convictions and is sticking by them I guess, even if I think he's a militant ideologue (with a questionable grasp on the real world) that is unable to understand that you need to compromise to get big things done in a democracy. 60% of 100% is always better than 100% of 0.
 
Some convictions cost real people real time and money. Some people can afford the friction, and some cannot, and for the latter it makes their lives difficult. Convictions are not necessarily admirable. All sorts of people have convictions. In Guilbeault's case, his convictions were burdening a lot of ordinary people, to not much useful purpose.
 
Some convictions cost real people real time and money. Some people can afford the friction, and some cannot, and for the latter it makes their lives difficult. Convictions are not necessarily admirable. All sorts of people have convictions. In Guilbeault's case, his convictions were burdening a lot of ordinary people, to not much useful purpose.
I think his convictions were stupid, it was just refreshing to see a politician stand by them. But he's a pretty big outlier, so his leaving is hardly a reflection on anything (and frankly take him quitting as an MP as a sign things are going in the right direction).
 
Even as an MP and environment minister, plenty of the LPC faithful thought he was nuts, let alone the general population. I admire that he has convictions and is sticking by them I guess, even if I think he's a militant ideologue (with a questionable grasp on the real world) that is unable to understand that you need to compromise to get big things done in a democracy. 60% of 100% is always better than 100% of 0.
Is there description of his faults somewhere? Im curious how many things i would differ with him on
 
If Guilbeault really wanted to screw over Carney he could've crossed the floor. This resignation is pure theatrics of a spoiled activist who didn't get his way.

Yeah, the only reason he wasn’t Green or NDP was Trudeau. He’s surprised to learn that the LPC is flexible with their principles.
 
Back
Top