Why? To be blunt, that’s a ridiculous take.
CUSMA is agreed and in place. Has been for years. It’s the best deal Canada will get under this U.S. administration. There’s no realistic way we achieve a net improvement in our overall position; we’re facing off with an economic mercantilist. He doesn’t want to ‘rennegotiate’ CUSMA in a way that would benefit us. He just wants to renege, because that’s who Trump is. Deals with him are unreliable.
Fortunately in our case we have strong legal and political protections for the deal in place. He has to deal with his own Congress.
So no, there’s no reason for us to negotiate a new ‘deal’ on CUSMA, because there’s no advantageous deal to be had. Trump just wants out of his commitments and wants us to help him back out of them. Screw that.
Appeals to ‘renegotiate CUSMA’ with Trump are essentially an appeal to economic capitulation. Our best interest, as I’ve said from the start, remains in just ragging the puck and running the clock. What he wants will hurt Canada, but in this case he won’t get it if we don’t hand it over to him.