• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
While I praise the Liberals for doing such a smashing job of driving this nation right into the ditch. The PBO (Parliamentary Budget Officer) who was appointed by PM MC himself has a very scathing review of Canada's fiscal management (mismanagement?) and lets be frank, very little of this is anything to do with Orange man bad.

 
So yes, its Northern Perspective. However much of what you will find in this video shows that Minister Melanie Joly and the Liberals not only knew about the plant sale in Brampton (Stellantis), but toured the plant with Roshel when they were expressing keen interest in purchasing the plant.

They then feign outrage at the "surprising sale of the plant" and the "betrayal" to the workers. Canadians are not buying the bullshit anymore. Ask Eby what happens when people stop following political fantasies.

DEEDS not words.

You still want to see how Carney decision unfold in the Canadian economy?

Start to think about it a different way. Was the Stellantis payment a gift to stay? Or a parachute/severance payment to exit 😉
 
While I praise the Liberals for doing such a smashing job of driving this nation right into the ditch. The PBO (Parliamentary Budget Officer) who was appointed by PM MC himself has a very scathing review of Canada's fiscal management (mismanagement?) and lets be frank, very little of this is anything to do with Orange man bad.


…or…you could read the actual PBO report, to avoid un-correlated cherry-picking of evil-sounding figures without the associated context that in no way implies that the sky is falling.


Excerpts from said PBO report referred to in your video,
  • Real GDP growth softens to 1.0 per cent in 2026 and 1.7 per cent in 2027, but higher energy prices push growth in nominal GDP, the broadest measure of the tax base, up to 5.6 per cent in 2026 and 3.7 per cent in 2027.
  • Budget 2026 projects the deficit in 2026-27 to be $62.3 billion, which is an improvement from the deficit of $65.3 billion projected in the Spring Economic Update (SEU) 2026.
  • Had the government not introduced new tax or spending measures, this year’s deficit would have fallen to $43.8 billion – due to windfall revenues and updated direct program expenses.
  • New measures of $151.5 billion over five years absorb 96 per cent of the $158.3 billion in new fiscal room anticipated in the coming five years relative to the SEU 2026. Since the 2024 Fall Economic Statement, new measures of $324.8 billion are nearly twice the $176.7 billion in fiscal room created.
  • Of the Budget 2026 new measures, $89.5 billion is classified as capital investment, led by the Productivity Mega Deduction, and $62.0 billion as day-to-day operating spending.
  • In Budget 2026, federal borrowing over 2026-27 to 2030-31 totals $764.7 billion, 2.6 times the total deficits of $288.7 billion. Higher borrowing raises exposure to interest rates.

…​

Revenues, expenses and federal debt​



Relative to the SEU 2026, revenues were revised up by $15.4 billion per year on average over 2026-27 to 2030-31, mainly reflecting higher personal income revenues ($10.0 billion per year). Corporate income tax revenues are lower than in the SEU 2026 from 2027-28 onward, by $6.4 billion in 2030-31. This reflects the Productivity Mega Deduction and weaker year-to-date results.

Program expenses are higher by $10.8 billion per year on average. New measures more than offset the downward revision to the direct program expense projection of about $12.4 billion per year. Public debt charges were revised up by $2.5 billion per year on average, reflecting higher interest rates and borrowing requirements. Relative to the SEU 2026, the financial requirement, which measures the Government’s net borrowing need, is higher by $18.5 billion per year on average over 2026-27 to 2030-31 (Table 4).

Federal debt is projected to reach $1,593.0 billion (40.1 per cent of GDP) in 2030-31, compared with $1,629.4 billion (41.6 per cent of GDP) in the SEU 2026. The debt-to-GDP ratio is 1.5 to 1.6 percentage points lower than in the SEU 2026 in every year from 2026-27. About 60 per cent of the difference reflects lower federal debt, mainly from a smaller deficit in 2025-26, and about 40 per cent reflects higher nominal GDP. It edges up from 39.9 per cent in 2026-27 to a peak of 40.4 per cent in 2028-29 before declining.​

 
@Good2Golf yeah, having looking at what your looking at, I am not sure I would be so casual about those numbers. There is no room for error (i.e. a REAL emergency or disaster as opposed to made up liberal crisis).

Maybe we look at numbers differently.

From the PBO website
"The government promised to spend less to invest more. This budget spends more, invests more and borrows more."

"Almost none of the fiscal windfall went to reducing deficits."

"Housing starts are down. Funding is up. And the government is falling behind on its promise to double homebuilding. It also seems to have stepped away from its earlier commitment to build 500,000 new homes per year, yet proposes to approve an additional 200,000 permanent residents to Canada in Budget 2026."

"Financing commitments from banks do not constitute investments in specific projects."

"That provides an incomplete picture of overall staffing restraint."

"It’s important to look beyond deficits and consider actual cash borrowing. This budget forecasts three-quarters of a trillion dollars in new borrowing over five years. That’s a significant increase to taxpayers’ debt financing load, just as interest rates are starting to climb."

"By 2030-31, per capita debt charges will be $2,000 per year, per capita debt will be $37,000 and per capita liabilities will be $74,000 - up from $56,000 last year."

These are all from the words of Annette Ryan herself, but your correct, she didn't actually say "the sky is falling..."

You view reality your way. Personally I think it is criminal to lay this on our children and grandchildren. Borrowing, borrowing, borrowing, printing money forever can't go on without consequences.
 
Prof, I am going to be hung up on this. Damn good question.
I'm not saying that's definitively what it was but Companies divest assets all the time. Governments give tonnes of $$$ to companies who then turnaround and divest/sell those assets. It's a game.
 
I'm not saying that's definitively what it was but Companies divest assets all the time. Governments give tonnes of $$$ to companies who then turnaround and divest/sell those assets. It's a game.
What I am sure of (but can't prove) is that the Liberals, Stellantis and Roshel had some backroom meetings without Unifor.

I am also appalled at Lana Payne for being too chicken shit to directly call out the LPC but does so indirectly to her members. I honestly don't know what made them think they were ever going to stop this sale.
 
Alot of back and forth on this segment from parliament today. I am not sure this $560 million going to "save" Brazil's rainforest (a total commitment over the next decade or so of 13 billion)

 
@Good2Golf yeah, having looking at what your looking at, I am not sure I would be so casual about those numbers. There is no room for error (i.e. a REAL emergency or disaster as opposed to made up liberal crisis).

Maybe we look at numbers differently.

From the PBO website
"The government promised to spend less to invest more. This budget spends more, invests more and borrows more."

"Almost none of the fiscal windfall went to reducing deficits."

"Housing starts are down. Funding is up. And the government is falling behind on its promise to double homebuilding. It also seems to have stepped away from its earlier commitment to build 500,000 new homes per year, yet proposes to approve an additional 200,000 permanent residents to Canada in Budget 2026."

"Financing commitments from banks do not constitute investments in specific projects."

"That provides an incomplete picture of overall staffing restraint."

"It’s important to look beyond deficits and consider actual cash borrowing. This budget forecasts three-quarters of a trillion dollars in new borrowing over five years. That’s a significant increase to taxpayers’ debt financing load, just as interest rates are starting to climb."

"By 2030-31, per capita debt charges will be $2,000 per year, per capita debt will be $37,000 and per capita liabilities will be $74,000 - up from $56,000 last year."

These are all from the words of Annette Ryan herself, but your correct, she didn't actually say "the sky is falling..."

You view reality your way. Personally I think it is criminal to lay this on our children and grandchildren. Borrowing, borrowing, borrowing, printing money forever can't go on without consequences.
Your know those figures are inflation adjusted, right?

My first car cost me $2,200. It would be $80K+ today. Costs rise, it’s a fact.

In 2031, $2,000/yr debt servicing charges per capita will compare very favorably with the $4,200CAD/yr debt charges per capita that our Southern neighbors pay TODAY, and project to be over $5000CAD/yr per capita in 2031.

So Carney is working to strengthen Canada’s economic future at a rate of debt financing 2-1/2 TIMES LESS than the U.S., and projected to be less than all our fellow G7 nations.

So what numerical figure of debt servicing per capita will make you happy?

Frankly? Debt financing increases pale in comparison to housing affordability. If only governments that had things under control, would have gripped housing affordability back then. If only Harper’s housing minister back in the day had improved housing affordability for Canadians, back when things were good. Fortunately, we don’t have to deal with such people like that these days….oh, wait…
 
Would it not be better to see Roshel take over the plant and build capacity, keeping profits in Canada, and expanding Canada's defence industry? In the short run it may mean a reduction in the employment market in that area, and there are obvious other supply chain linkages that will be impacted. But aren't we always saying on this site how important it is for Canada to increase its defence industrial capacity.
 
Back
Top