MPs cry foul; Paul Martin's doctor runs private clinics
Last Updated Fri, 07 May 2004 21:38:56
OTTAWA - Opposition politicians are calling Paul Martin a hypocrite after finding out that his personal physician heads a private health care clinic in Montreal.
Dr. Sheldon Elman is the founder and CEO of the Medisys Health Group. He has been Martin's doctor for 23 years.
Paul Martin
Martin says he's never used private health care. In recent months, he has been touting the Liberals as the protectors of medicare while painting the Conservatives as the party that wants to privatize services.
"The hypocrisy of these guys is absolutely breathtaking," said Conservative leader Stephen Harper.
The company's web site, lists its 2003 revenue as $53 million and says it provides health care to some of the country's largest corporations. It also operates a chain of private MRI clinics.
Martin insists he's never undergone an MRI.
"My primary health coverage...is my medicare card and that's what I use all the time when I go to a public clinic," says Martin. "I don't believe in queue-jumping."
Deputy Prime Minister Anne McClellan took questions from reporters Friday wondering why Martin would use a private clinic.
"This is a clinic in Montreal that is publicly accessible to anyone who needs medical treatment."
Only last week, Health Minister Pierre Pettigrew was forced by Martin to clarify remarks Pettigrew made suggesting the Liberals were more open to private clinics.
New Democrat MP Bill Blaikie says the issue is the fact that private clinics are flourishing.
Quebec is home to a growing number of MRI clinics. Patients can opt to pay out-of-pocket for the service, bypassing the long waiting lists of hospitals.
Harper says Martin has failed to make clear his intentions on medicare.
"No one knows where this prime minister stands," says Harper.
Martin has promised to work out a new health funding deal with the provinces this summer. He is also expected to make health care an issue in the next federal election, expected to be called any day.
Written by CBC News Online staff