• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
Oh stop it. There is nothing “false majority” about floor crossings.

How about, Pierre, you self-reflect on why MPs are motivated to defect to the Government and work on that?
You did actually watch the video? Or did you just say bad Pierre because of the title? Curious?
 
You did actually watch the video? Or did you just say bad Pierre because of the title? Curious?
I actually, generally, like Pierre.

But to command a majority (confidence) in Parliament, all you have to do is routinely convince a majority of MPs to vote your way. If you convinced them to cross the floor- even better, I guess, but you had always better be sceptical of their motives. That was my only point.
 
Poilievres idea about being able to recall MP's to parliment for by-elections if they cross the floor, or just as a means of accountability is great. Canadians should demand that.
 
I actually, generally, like Pierre.

But to command a majority (confidence) in Parliament, all you have to do is routinely convince a majority of MPs to vote your way. If you convinced them to cross the floor- even better, I guess, but you had always better be sceptical of their motives. That was my only point.
So did you watch the video? Yes or no?
 
He's going to spend the time Carney is in office calling out unethical and shady behaviour. Would you rather see a meek opposition leader who doesn't call that stuff out? Poilievre may not be able to do anything about it but at least Canadians will be informed and can't act like they didn't know.
I have no problem, but he also has a habit of making mountains from mole hills without evidence
 
I have no problem, but he also has a habit of making mountains from mole hills without evidence
Maybe not a best gift to the LPC but a good gift to Canadians who want transparency and to know what our MPs are doing. Just in time for Carney to smile and shrug.
 
Now, here I will share this. Mark Carney is the political hot item right now and this could really put him into a favourable position for the up coming three by elections. Nick Nanos has an interesting way of polling

As Warren Kinsella says "What does he do with it?"

 
Maybe not a best gift to the LPC but a good gift to Canadians who want transparency and to know what our MPs are doing. Just in time for Carney to smile and shrug.
Transparency sure, but thats a double edged sword, especially given the issue of his security clearance, and using the average canadians lack of knowing what a ethics screen is to their advantage.
 
especially given the issue of his security clearance
Even Liberals have dropped that line of attack. It had no teeth to it whatsoever, Long before the election when Tom Mulcair (Former NDP leader and former leader of the opposition) came out several times on CTV (generally a more balanced news agency than CBC), and explained why Pierre was smart to DECLINE the NSICOP security clearance.

Jagmeet got that particular security clearance, said there were major concerns and nothing else. Liz May got it and said she was not worried but nothing else.

It was a blatant political trap and of all the things that worked against Pierre, that was not one of them.

Nice try on digging up old irrelevant dirt. Perhaps next you want to take a shot at his life growing up?
 
So again, I will bring something up. Especially since some here are very partisan and then pretend not to be. Hell, I am biased, I vote CPC and I am pro Pierre. I can live with it though if the party gives him the heave ho.

NOW, lets try doing something truly objective. Carney is 72 hours ish away from a slight majority. That means the opposition parties no longer have the power to bring him down. Only his own party can do that now with the opposition.

While we see major scrutiny on the CPC, and from the same crowd, next to zero scrutiny of the actual governing party,, lets flip that around.

START judging the soon to be majority Liberal government, for someone of you for the first time ever. The government is the actual ones responsible for policies, bills being passed, governing the nation and whoa, RESULTS.

How about we try that? Deeds not words.

On the floor crossers, the final argument will be solved in those five ridings next election. The constituents will give the final judgement, especially if any of the floor crossers actually dare to run again in the same ridings.
 
Transparency sure, but thats a double edged sword, especially given the issue of his security clearance, and using the average canadians lack of knowing what a ethics screen is to their advantage.

A security clearance isn’t a requirement to lead an opposition party. Poilievre not obtaining it is a political choice, not a security failure. He’s prioritizing his role in public accountability and opposition work over participating in a classified briefing system that comes with restrictions on what he can say publicly. Not getting the clearance allows him to be transparent about what he knows.
 
Can someone explain to me why the Liberals are spending $27 Billion + on consultants? That is ridiculous

Pierre Poilievre on Juno news Live tonight.
Did he back that up with any actual facts? Was he rolling up 15 years of spending and dropping in contractor support (which is totally different than straight consulting).

PP is spending around $140k a year the last few years on consultants just from his office (with the gap while he was out of office), so does that count towards LPC consultant spending?

If he has some receipts, sure, but he's far too loose with context in his claims to take it seriously.
 
Here is a suggestion.

How about Mark Carney go on Joe Rogan and/or Diary of a CEO podcast? Anyone?
Out of curiosity, would that make him the first sitting word leader to do either one of these Podcasts while in office?
 
A security clearance isn’t a requirement to lead an opposition party. Poilievre not obtaining it is a political choice, not a security failure. He’s prioritizing his role in public accountability and opposition work over participating in a classified briefing system that comes with restrictions on what he can say publicly. Not getting the clearance allows him to be transparent about what he knows.
Except he doesn't know anything if he's not getting the security briefings, and getting the security briefing would in no way stop him from talking about topics that are already in the public realm.

It's such a massive red herring, and everyone on here regularly talks about things they have deeper knowledge on the high side while sticking to what's open source already, so weird people with actual clearnances and experience in that kind of thing buy into it.

He's basically just talking out of his ass, and pretending getting a clearance and info briefing would somehow muzzle him, it's asinine. If he's not going to get a clearance, fine, but then he should just STFU about the things he's not getting briefed on.
 
Did he back that up with any actual facts? Was he rolling up 15 years of spending and dropping in contractor support (which is totally different than straight consulting).

PP is spending around $140k a year the last few years on consultants just from his office (with the gap while he was out of office), so does that count towards LPC consultant spending?

If he has some receipts, sure, but he's far too loose with context in his claims to take it seriously.
Pierre is usually pretty accurate and on target with his numbers. I do plan to write my MP to confirm this, however Pierre usually has been spot on with his numbers. Lets get back to this one.
PP is spending around $140k a year the last few years on consultants just from his office (
Did he use public funds or CPC funds?

Wait, Google AI, take with a grain of salt.

  • Office Expenses: Data for the first three quarters of the 2023-2024 fiscal year showed that Poilievre claimed $143,201 in expenses for his role as the MP for the riding of Carleton.
  • Comparison: This amount was roughly one-quarter of what NDP Leader Jagmeet Singh expensed during the same period ($533,533).
  • Context: The $143k expense was for his parliamentary office, not personal consulting fees. Poilievre was noted as one of the few MPs whose constituency expenses for that period did not include costs for "travel" or "hospitality".
 
Might be. I have to look that up. Would be a first, trail blazing thing to do.
I know he did Scott Gallagher’s podcast during the election.
I don’t follow Podcasts much, I’ve watched a few here and there. At first glance, sitting with one of these folks doesn’t look much different than sitting down with Peter Mansbridge or Barbara Frumm back in the day.
 
hen he should just STFU about the things he's not getting briefed on.
Thats your opinion. He has 2 MPs to get the briefings for him (one of them is mine Alex Ruff), and there is a limit to what they can tell him, but he hopefully gets enough to be able to act.

So you want the leader of the opposition to STFU? Ok, you don't like democracy much?

Your weakly framing your argument to shit on Pierre, bottom line.
 
And AGAIN, we have the microscope coming out for Pierre Poilievre and the blinders get put on for Carney.

I challenge you all to judge both leaders with similar standards. Deeds not words.
 
Back
Top