• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
After watching a bit of the Liberal convention, I'm more convinced then ever the LPC under PMMC will make things far worse then they are now.
There was plenty of people spouting off bat shit crazy ideas like that exit tax. We saw similar wild idea at the CPC floor like trying to limit abortion. None of those wild ideas passed there, and they wont here either. It seems clear to me that Carney doesnt care for the radical social left agenda.
 
There was plenty of people spouting off bat shit crazy ideas like that exit tax. We saw similar wild idea at the CPC floor like trying to limit abortion. None of those wild ideas passed there, and they wont here either. It seems clear to me that Carney doesnt care for the radical social left agenda.
These conventions are akin to a General Mess Meeting, without jalapeño poppers afterward.

Just because you table it doesn't mean it will be adopted or implemented l.
 
There was plenty of people spouting off bat shit crazy ideas like that exit tax. We saw similar wild idea at the CPC floor like trying to limit abortion. None of those wild ideas passed there, and they wont here either. It seems clear to me that Carney doesnt care for the radical social left agenda.

WTF is the “exit tax”?
 
WTF is the “exit tax”?
One of those oddball policy proposals we see at party conventions, where delegates can basically table anything they want, some partisans and some media may a big deal of it, and it gets voted down and/or utterly ignored by the party’s caucus is when legislating. It’s a nothingburger.
 
I like to see a requirement that MP's have to go independent for 6 months and have to hold a referendum with the voters in their riding. Election Canada can provide the website and process to vet respondents. Questions are simple:

1. Remain independent
2. Return to the party
3. Join party X
Except the cure is potentially worse than the disease.

For years here on Army.ca I have read many comments about how MPs put Party in front of Constituency. And how bad that is for democracy. And how much sway Party has and that MPs are trained seals.

Yet, an MP crossing the floor (in either direction: opposition to govt or govt to opposition), potentially could be putting constituents first and is the very definition of not being a trained seal. I say: let the constituents of the affected riding decide that for themselves at the next election if Party affiliation or voting record on the actual issues are more important to them.

By passing some sort of law requiring a byelection in the event of a floor crossing you are potentially removing a safety valve in Parliament and basically codifying that Party is more important than the individual MP (ie- you must dance with the one that brung ya). That, to me, is really dangerous. A really craven PM, because they control the timing of any by-election within a 6 month window, could weaponize this and neuter the Parliamentary Opposition.

In short, I am advocating for treating MPs and voters like adults.
 
Except becoming an independent doesn't really matter if you've been bribed or blackmailed to cross the floor. You'll still vote for the party that pays you and carry their water. All you do is make it easier for the engineers of the plan to more vehemently deny interfering in democracy.
True, but a referendum result where you might be forced back into the party might make people think twice about that.
 
MORE viewers, more exposure, domestic and international. Carney is a politician and by default must always keep promoting his brand.
I think his brand is no nonsense get to work.

He doesn't really need a podcast for that.

And he's one of the most popular PMs we've seen in a long time.

Imagine having a positive approval rating in every province. A liberal...positive approval in Alberta. Alberta!

Although it's telling that 60 odd percent of conservatives are not happy with him. Just cannot please some people.
 
Except the cure is potentially worse than the disease.

For years here on Army.ca I have read many comments about how MPs put Party in front of Constituency. And how bad that is for democracy. And how much sway Party has and that MPs are trained seals.

Yet, an MP crossing the floor (in either direction: opposition to govt or govt to opposition), potentially could be putting constituents first and is the very definition of not being a trained seal. I say: let the constituents of the affected riding decide that for themselves at the next election if Party affiliation or voting record on the actual issues are more important to them.

By passing some sort of law requiring a byelection in the event of a floor crossing you are potentially removing a safety valve in Parliament and basically codifying that Party is more important than the individual MP (ie- you must dance with the one that brung ya). That, to me, is really dangerous. A really craven PM, because they control the timing of any by-election within a 6 month window, could weaponize this and neuter the Parliamentary Opposition.

In short, I am advocating for treating MPs and voters like adults.
My idea leaves the choice in the hands of the voters and reminds the politician, that it is the voters choice. A fixed referendum question saves the costs and hassle of a byelection and gives consequence to the choice of crossing the floor. The 6 months period gives the politician the chance to convince the voters of their reason and for the system to go through the process. It will reduce the ability for the other party to "bribe" people, as they won't immediately be able to switch over and there is no guarantee that it would be successful.
 
Yet, an MP crossing the floor (in either direction: opposition to govt or govt to opposition), potentially could be putting constituents first and is the very definition of not being a trained seal. I say: let the constituents of the affected riding decide that for themselves at the next election if Party affiliation or voting record on the actual issues are more important to them.

By passing some sort of law requiring a byelection in the event of a floor crossing you are potentially removing a safety valve in Parliament and basically codifying that Party is more important than the individual MP (ie- you must dance with the one that brung ya). That, to me, is really dangerous. A really craven PM, because they control the timing of any by-election within a 6 month window, could weaponize this and neuter the Parliamentary Opposition.

In short, I am advocating for treating MPs and voters like adults.

If MPs are supposed to represent constituents, then switching parties without asking them isn’t independence it’s changing the deal after the vote. Letting voters decide immediately (via by-election) is more democratic.

If someone says "I spoke with constituents" then a by-election would be a fair due process. That seems the fairest approach in a representative democracy.
 
And he's one of the most popular PMs we've seen in a long time.

How quickly you forget Trudeau Mania. Carney is only 3% higher than peak Trudeau popularity.

Imagine having a positive approval rating in every province. A liberal...positive approval in Alberta. Alberta!

Although it's telling that 60 odd percent of conservatives are not happy with him. Just cannot please some people.

Yup. Some people will oppose any leader regardless of performance, that one goes both ways.
 
I think his brand is no nonsense get to work.

He doesn't really need a podcast for that.

And he's one of the most popular PMs we've seen in a long time.

Imagine having a positive approval rating in every province. A liberal...positive approval in Alberta. Alberta!

Although it's telling that 60 odd percent of conservatives are not happy with him. Just cannot please some people.

You realize nothing last forever? Like I said last night, enjoy the political buzz for now, I guarantee there is a hangover to come.

And stop pretending your non-partisan, your very pro Liberal, come out and admit it.
 
Although it's telling that 60 odd percent of conservatives are not happy with him.
Big surprise? Thats usually what happens in politics. When one party is in power, the other is usually unhappy or the least unsatisfied

Need another lesson in basic politics?
 
If MPs are supposed to represent constituents, then switching parties without asking them isn’t independence it’s changing the deal after the vote. Letting voters decide immediately (via by-election) is more democratic.

If someone says "I spoke with constituents" then a by-election would be a fair due process. That seems the fairest approach in a representative democracy.
Since the last general election, did the situation change significantly?

Are there new issues facing Canada not envisioned during the last election?

Does either the PM or Opposition party leader’s performance or conduct suddenly suck so badly that an MP cannot ethically continue on that side of the house?

Tell me, if someone with the last name rhyming with “Rudeau” were Prime Minister and his MPs wanted to leak away to the opposition leading to the probable defeat of the Govt and a general election, would you still be happy with a bunch of byelections?
 
I am going to get someone to pay for a load of beef, then when they come to pick it up, I will give them Lamb instead. I will say you choose me to be your farmer and in spite of what we agreed upon, I decided for you without discussion.

For all you closet Liberals, it is simple, you ran as candidate for X riding and you said you represent party A, then stick to it. The MP got the benefit of being elected ON THAT PARTY name.

The rest is lies you are telling yourself to make you feel less stupid.
 
Since the last general election, did the situation change significantly?

Are there new issues facing Canada not envisioned during the last election?

Does either the PM or Opposition party leader’s performance or conduct suddenly suck so badly that an MP cannot ethically continue on that side of the house?

Tell me, if someone with the last name rhyming with “Rudeau” were Prime Minister and his MPs wanted to leak away to the opposition leading to the probable defeat of the Govt and a general election, would you still be happy with a bunch of byelections?
I was less than impressed when Leona Allesev crossed to the conservatives, I put up a FB post at the time saying it made us look immoral and sneaky. So I stand by my standards then and I still do now. I was equally unimpressed when Jennica Atwin left the greens for the liberals, I have nothing to do with those parties (I stopped voting green after 2015).
 
I was less than impressed when Leona Allesev crossed to the conservatives, I put up a FB post at the time saying it made us look immoral and sneaky. So I stand by my standards then and I still do now. I was equally unimpressed when Jennica Atwin left the greens for the liberals, I have nothing to do with those parties (I stopped voting green after 2015).
Good for you for at least being consistent in your position. We can disagree about whether floor crossing is good or bad, but I can totally respect that.
 
Back
Top