MilEME09
Army.ca Fixture
- Reaction score
- 8,621
- Points
- 1,210
Op nanook is class C, reg force pay systemWell, we could go on about Class A pay problems until Judgement Day or the problems are

Op nanook is class C, reg force pay systemWell, we could go on about Class A pay problems until Judgement Day or the problems are
Any know if the Loyal Eddies (and other reservists?) were there as part of the 3 PPCLI task force workup, or were the Eddies also incidentally in the field at the same time? I’m guessing these were all reserve augmentees to 3 VP?
I think back to the days when we lost Reg F Lt (N) Chris Saunders aboard CHICOUTIMI and Class A Gunner Ariel Keyes- Oliver in a rollover in Pet (I was in a nearby training area that day) within a couple of days. The CDS at the time, Hillier, said they would both be treated equally. That we would do the right thing, not do things right. He did not have the authority to do that. Has anything changed and does Carney have any more authority today than Hillier had back then to do the right thing?Well, potential to be 3 (4?) distinctions of possibilities for Reservists, from any Unit from across Canada, impacted by the Wainwright MCI:
Class A: Any of them there just working a couple of Class A dates to support?
Class B: Contracted out with TC Wainwright itself or potentially Edmonton to support?
Class C: Potentially contracted with CAF for upcoming overseas deployment.
It's all well and good now with PM Carney adivsing Canadians that we will look after everyone and all of them. We know that any Regular Force members certainly will be (even if differently amongst them too) - 24/7 and all that heat and light on Wainwright MCI 17 Oct 2026.
I'm worried about long term for any reservists impacted --- and what VAC will rule years out from now when the heat and light is off about "your contract that day ....", "not Class C, Not an SDA" etc etc. Fuck even Regular Force are having to fight/fight/appeal/appeal.
SDB, SISIP, VAC ... take 'yer chances depending on your 'employment status' that day. For the immediate heat and light show we've got them. Canada's got them. The PM says so.
It's their future fights I'm worried about because precedents. Is the PM about to order VAC to treat any of the above classes exactly the same in the future for any/all benefits and entitlements because, by law right now, those are not the same. What about the next Class A soldier/sailor/aviator injured on a range or a normal Class A training day? Is the system going to treat the the same way? If not, I foresee a Class Action (another one!) in the future.
Hell - even for the Regular Force personnel involved their mileage may vary with VAC in the future: Were they tasked on DTG in question to upcoming deployment thus falling under "operational" ... or were they merely (sarcasm on) RegF personnel there supporting/reacting/assisting thus not "operational" ... because, frankly, that's where VAC distinguishes and discriminates.
Time to start treating every single soldier, sailor, aviator the same when they injured doing their damn jobs. Same troops side by side in same incident with same injuries are potentially NOT the same, nor entitled to same by VAC and the insurance agencies that decide ...
That sucks. That's the devil in the details of this MCI.
P.S. -- take care of yourself, because I suspect the impact on you & the team will be more than zero, even for those "just handling the paperwork."I cannot give great detail about internal VAC people & processes, but I know that lack of a CF98 or 663 will not be a show stopper in this case (for Res F Pte Bloggins who breaks a toe on a weekend Ex, it does complicate it). It is what is on a medical record (military and/or civilian) that can be the deciding factor. These troops are being tracked closely.
Here, we have received the bulk CASREP giving name/rank/SN for all of those killed and injured. Actions have been initiated, Designated Assistants are going out to all impacted families, briefings for the MND/CDS etc on benefits and services available to Reg F & Res F casualties are being prepped/delivered. At least in this case, as it is so high profile, they will not be overlooked.


I suppose one could say Rick Hillier had no clout over a Government Ministry beyond his position within DND, where as the PM, as the boss of the Cabinet, can look at the Minister responsible and direct them to sort their shit out and ensure legislation and directives are written or re-written or lose their position within the Cabinet. Most really Hillier would have been able to do is wag his finger and maybe embarrass them in public...assuming that the minister concerned was actually capable of feeling embarrassed about anything.I think back to the days when we lost Reg F Lt (N) Chris Saunders aboard CHICOUTIMI and Class A Gunner Ariel Keyes- Oliver in a rollover in Pet (I was in a nearby training area that day) within a couple of days. The CDS at the time, Hillier, said they would both be treated equally. That we would do the right thing, not do things right. He did not have the authority to do that. Has anything changed and does Carney have any more authority today than Hillier had back then to do the right thing?
All of that works well until the DM is told by his PS minions that there is very good reason for why things are the way that they are and in the result the status quo needle moves slightly if at all. The problem is that there are disconnects with politicians who skim the surface of issues because they do not have the depth of experience to understand when they are being managed and the civil service who believes any progress is an upset to the natural order of things.where as the PM, as the boss of the Cabinet, can look at the Minister responsible and direct them to sort their shit out and ensure legislation and directives are written or re-written or lose their position within the Cabinet
Margaret Thatcher once described it as a documentary.All of that works well until the DM is told by his PS minions that there is very good reason for why things are the way that they are and in the result the status quo needle moves slightly if at all. The problem is that there are disconnects with politicians who skim the surface of issues because they do not have the depth of experience to understand when they are being managed and the civil service who believes any progress is an upset to the natural order of things.
"Yes, Minister," is not a comedy; it's a tragedy.
![]()
To be fair, in my limited, lower-level dealings within The Federal Machine, I've also seen where ministers want x, no matter what the DM wants, and somehow, it magically happens - or at least a variation on the theme. We'll have to see 1) what outlier cases will be coming out of all this, 2) what "doing the right things" means compared to "doing the right thing", and 3) how much support the minister in question has in government.All of that works well until the DM is told by his PS minions that there is very good reason for why things are the way that they are and in the result the status quo needle moves slightly if at all. The problem is that there are disconnects with politicians who skim the surface of issues because they do not have the depth of experience to understand when they are being managed and the civil service who believes any progress is an upset to the natural order of things.
"Yes, Minister," is not a comedy; it's a tragedy.
![]()

Last I heard there were reservists were part of the injured group, task force had about 18% augmentationAny know if the Loyal Eddies (and other reservists?) were there as part of the 3 PPCLI task force workup, or were the Eddies also incidentally in the field at the same time? I’m guessing these were all reserve augmentees to 3 VP?
eWell said.My deepest condolences to the families, friends, and members of the PPCLI family affected by this tragedy. May they find strength in one another and keep the memories of the fallen, as well as the wounded, close to their hearts.
Several of the women I am currently coaching have deep personal connections to those impacted, and this loss has weighed heavily on them. In the midst of that grief, I hope the structure, discipline, and camaraderie of camp have provided a measure of comfort and a welcome respite from the pain.

Brit-based tabloid media being provocative? Shocked (not).Metro News UK Highlights
Social media misinformation is one thing, but media personalities need to stay in their lanes too. This article on the Wainwright MCI from their Entertainment Reporter. Excerpt - the line below the 'bold':
View attachment 102720e
Do better.
mediabiasfactcheck.com
Here's my responseMetro News UK Highlights
Social media misinformation is one thing, but media personalities need to stay in their lanes too. This article on the Wainwright MCI from their Entertainment Reporter. Excerpt - the line below the 'bold':
View attachment 102720e
Do better.
