• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
I am going to get someone to pay for a load of beef, then when they come to pick it up, I will give them Lamb instead. I will say you choose me to be your farmer and in spite of what we agreed upon, I decided for you without discussion.

For all you closet Liberals, it is simple, you ran as candidate for X riding and you said you represent party A, then stick to it. The MP got the benefit of being elected ON THAT PARTY name.

The rest is lies you are telling yourself to make you feel less stupid.
Except that is again a false anology.

Unlike you and your customer, there is no contract, real or implied, between a voter and an elected official.

You also cannot know why an MP was elected. Was it party? Was it platform? Was it their good looks and charm? When 100,000 people cast individual votes in a riding, they all do so with variety of motives. Your reason for putting an X beside candidate Bloggins may differ from your next door neighbour who also selected Bloggins.
 
Except that is again a false anology.

Unlike you and your customer, there is no contract, real or implied, between a voter and an elected official.

You also cannot know why an MP was elected. Was it party? Was it platform? Was it their good looks and charm? When 100,000 people cast individual votes in a riding, they all do so with variety of motives. Your reason for putting an X beside candidate Bloggins may differ from your next door neighbour who also selected Bloggins.
When a candidates name is on the sign with PARTY affiliation plus they are on the web site and recognized as a candidate, come on, FALSE ADVERTISING.

Your arguing semantics and going long ways to try and shape your argument.
 
Since the last general election, did the situation change significantly?

Are there new issues facing Canada not envisioned during the last election?

Does either the PM or Opposition party leader’s performance or conduct suddenly suck so badly that an MP cannot ethically continue on that side of the house?

I see the issue as democratic legitimacy. Voters elect MPs on a party platform at a specific time, and if an MP changes party mid-term, the most direct democratic remedy is to let constituents decide through a by-election. That doesn’t prevent MPs from acting on conscience it just ensures accountability follows the change rather than waiting years for the next general election.

Cannot ethically continue on that side? That's fine, switch sides and confirm the people still want you as their member of parliament.


Tell me, if someone with the last name rhyming with “Rudeau” were Prime Minister and his MPs wanted to leak away to the opposition leading to the probable defeat of the Govt and a general election, would you still be happy with a bunch of byelections?
Believe it or not, yes. Absolutely.

We see it with floor crossers who one day spew vitriol and the next heap praise on their new party. Automatic by elections would protect the spirit and process of representative democracy IMO.

Ridings should be able to recall their MP and call an election and a majority of them feel their MP isn't representing them.
 
If MPs are supposed to represent constituents, then switching parties without asking them isn’t independence it’s changing the deal after the vote. Letting voters decide immediately (via by-election) is more democratic.

If someone says "I spoke with constituents" then a by-election would be a fair due process. That seems the fairest approach in a representative democracy.
Do MP's have a pre-set opinion on every issue that gets locked in on election day? In selecting your MP are you forced to automatically support each and every policy platform of the party your candidate runs for? If your MP votes for/against something that you felt was not in line with what you thought their position was when you voted for them are they "changing the deal after the vote"? How is that any different than the MP changing the t-shirt they wear (party) in the HOC? How does changing their party affiliation in Parliament differ from changing their opinion on any other important issue they may vote on while sitting as an MP? What about the interest of your neighbours that may not have voted for their MP? Is the MP not also responsible for looking out for their best interests as well...which may differ from the interests of the leader of the party under who's banner they originally ran?

We have a Representative Democracy. We elect an individual who's judgement we trust to REPRESENT us in Parliament. This individual doesn't just represent you or I as individuals, they represent the entirety of their constituents - regardless of how they voted - based on the broad consensus of which individual they feel will best represent their collective interests in Parliament (i.e. the election).

If you are unhappy with the decisions that the representative your riding collectively selected in the last election makes while representing your riding in Parliament (be that their support/non-support for firearms regulations, support/non-support for environmental regulations, support/non-support for a particular taxation measure, support/non-support for the budget bill or support/non-support for a particular political party) then you can choose to not vote for that individual again at the next election.

If you want to restore the primacy of Parliament over the Executive then it's exactly MPs that are willing to vote against their party lines, or gasp! even change party affiliation in order to do what they feel best represents the interests of their constituents rather than just being clapping seals that blindly support what the leader of their party tells them they have to support.
 
Do MP's have a pre-set opinion on every issue that gets locked in on election day? In selecting your MP are you forced to automatically support each and every policy platform of the party your candidate runs for? If your MP votes for/against something that you felt was not in line with what you thought their position was when you voted for them are they "changing the deal after the vote"? How is that any different than the MP changing the t-shirt they wear (party) in the HOC? How does changing their party affiliation in Parliament differ from changing their opinion on any other important issue they may vote on while sitting as an MP? What about the interest of your neighbours that may not have voted for their MP? Is the MP not also responsible for looking out for their best interests as well...which may differ from the interests of the leader of the party under who's banner they originally ran?

We have a Representative Democracy. We elect an individual who's judgement we trust to REPRESENT us in Parliament. This individual doesn't just represent you or I as individuals, they represent the entirety of their constituents - regardless of how they voted - based on the broad consensus of which individual they feel will best represent their collective interests in Parliament (i.e. the election).

If you are unhappy with the decisions that the representative your riding collectively selected in the last election makes while representing your riding in Parliament (be that their support/non-support for firearms regulations, support/non-support for environmental regulations, support/non-support for a particular taxation measure, support/non-support for the budget bill or support/non-support for a particular political party) then you can choose to not vote for that individual again at the next election.

If you want to restore the primacy of Parliament over the Executive then it's exactly MPs that are willing to vote against their party lines, or gasp! even change party affiliation in order to do what they feel best represents the interests of their constituents rather than just being clapping seals that blindly support what the leader of their party tells them they have to support.

MPs can vote their conscience. We know what happens when their conscience runs counter to the party. The overwhelmingly similar way MPs in a party vote isn't coincidence.

Many voters still choose MPs largely through party platforms, which is why party affiliation matters at the ballot box. If an MP changes parties mid-term, it changes the mandate they were elected on, so the most democratic remedy is letting constituents test that change at a by election rather than waiting years for the next general election.

Whats a by election cost, $2M-$3M?
A "rounding error" as people are apt to say when politician et el get caught ripping off the government. It all comes down to "prove it".
 
He's going to spend the time Carney is in office calling out unethical and shady behaviour. Would you rather see a meek opposition leader who doesn't call that stuff out? Poilievre may not be able to do anything about it but at least Canadians will be informed and can't act like they didn't know.
If he could walk that way, while sincerely chewing the “happy to help & support government come up with solutions” gum, I think that would be a reasonable mix of poke & help that could help him shed some of the harder-held “just a prick” aura. Maybe I’m naive, though.
 
A security clearance isn’t a requirement to lead an opposition party. Poilievre not obtaining it is a political choice, not a security failure. He’s prioritizing his role in public accountability and opposition work over participating in a classified briefing system that comes with restrictions on what he can say publicly. Not getting the clearance allows him to be transparent about what he knows.
But not transparent about problems re: any serving Team Blue MPs. If Ma was such a China pawn as some allege, how long was he one in the Blue benches?
 
MPs can vote their conscience. We know what happens when their conscience runs counter to the party. The overwhelmingly similar way MPs in a party vote isn't coincidence.

Many voters still choose MPs largely through party platforms, which is why party affiliation matters at the ballot box. If an MP changes parties mid-term, it changes the mandate they were elected on, so the most democratic remedy is letting constituents test that change at a by election rather than waiting years for the next general election.

Whats a by election cost, $2M-$3M?
A "rounding error" as people are apt to say when politician et el get caught ripping off the government. It all comes down to "prove it".
Political parties are an artificial creation used to generally classify a broad coalition of people who in general claim to support the same general set of policies. Many people may choose to limit their political engagement to that extremely superficial level and just blindly vote for their chosen party. That however doesn't change the fact that you are voting for an INDIVIDUAL not a PARTY to represent you and your fellow constituents in Parliament.

If you are of the opinion that electing your MP should be nothing more that selecting the political party you support then save a bunch of money and get rid of the individual MPs and just have the leaders of the political parties represent the ridings that voted for their party.

In that case you can have the five party leaders sit around a dinner table and vote on the issues:

  • Mark Carney gets 171 votes
  • Pierre Pollievre gets 140 votes
  • Avi Lewis gets 6 votes
  • Elizabeth May gets 1 vote
  • 3 votes still to be confirmed
If you bind your MP's to their party affiliation rather then their own conscience and free will then that is effectively what you are doing.
 
If he could walk that way, while sincerely chewing the “happy to help & support government come up with solutions” gum, I think that would be a reasonable mix of poke & help that could help him shed some of the harder-held “just a prick” aura. Maybe I’m naive, though.

No, I think you're quite right. He reminds me of prick bosses I've had that were blunt, and great at their job. Similarly I've had bosses that were all charm and had me walking away convinced of their grandeur but they turned out shallow, self-absorbed, and just worried about themselves (i.e Trudeau).

Maybe Canadians feel a happy charismatic leader represents them on the world stage and want to be associated with that perceived persona.
 
If you are of the opinion that electing your MP should be nothing more that selecting the political party you support then save a bunch of money and get rid of the individual MPs and just have the leaders of the political parties represent the ridings that voted for their party.

You might be on to something.

We could also have MP's run as citizens not associated to any party. They tell us their views and beliefs and we pick them based on that. Then once elected they pick the party they feel most aligns with their views.

Like a Harry Potter sorting hat of sorts.
 
You might be on to something.

We could also have MP's run as citizens not associated to any party. They tell us their views and beliefs and we pick them based on that. Then once elected they pick the party they feel most aligns with their views.

Like a Harry Potter sorting hat of sorts.
The introduction of party affiliations into federal ballots was in the mid 20th century, as I recall. Prior to that, I believe ballots would list names and occupations instead.

One stunt parties would try would be to find people with the same name as a popular candidate to confuse voters and leech off some of their support.
 
You might be on to something.

We could also have MP's run as citizens not associated to any party. They tell us their views and beliefs and we pick them based on that. Then once elected they pick the party they feel most aligns with their views.

Like a Harry Potter sorting hat of sorts.
I don't get the obsession with pushing parties to the top of the political pyramid.

Ideally political parties should just be a loose affiliation of individual members that work together toward similar political objectives, not an organization that constrains its members to voting as a single block on a whole range of issues.
 
You might be on to something.

We could also have MP's run as citizens not associated to any party. They tell us their views and beliefs and we pick them based on that. Then once elected they pick the party they feel most aligns with their views.

Like a Harry Potter sorting hat of sorts.
We could, but it would very difficult to prevent some sort of “nudge nudge wink wink” party but not a party from forming. Humans are humans.
 
When a candidates name is on the sign with PARTY affiliation plus they are on the web site and recognized as a candidate, come on, FALSE ADVERTISING.

Your arguing semantics and going long ways to try and shape your argument.
But it is not false advertising. That concept does not exist in politics. I am not being glib or trolling you.

At the moment of the election the candidate is running under the banner of X party, which gives a voter (I suppose) a broad idea of what the candidates stand for. 10 mins after the election? All bets are off. Honestly.

There is both good and bad in that system. I lean towards de-emphasizing party control and party affiliation and focussing on a candidates ideas and character. I view the ability for an MP to cross the floor in either direction as an asset which allows Parliamentarians to react in an agile manner to changing circumstances. But, that I freely admit that is my bias and others may not share it.
 
No, I think you're quite right. He reminds me of prick bosses I've had that were blunt, and great at their job. Similarly I've had bosses that were all charm and had me walking away convinced of their grandeur but they turned out shallow, self-absorbed, and just worried about themselves (i.e Trudeau).

Maybe Canadians feel a happy charismatic leader represents them on the world stage and want to be associated with that perceived persona.
What, the persona of someone who has a PhD from one of the worlds most respected universities and was also the Governor of both the Banks of Canada and England?
 
The party is just as important as the person. Thats the reality. The Prime Minister comes from the party with the most seats. Yes there is good and bad in the system.

Saying people vote for the person not the party is incorrect. I would say it is subjective. Every voter makes their selection based on their own criteria. David Colletto of Colletto polling made it very clear recently, in his research that their is a large number of Canadians who don't even know who their MP is, it is that they selected the name next to the party.

There is what theoretically should be, and how it is.

Bottom line, is Gladu's riding (and I am sure the same with the others), is many in her riding are furious.
 
The party is just as important as the person. Thats the reality. The Prime Minister comes from the party with the most seats. Yes there is good and bad in the system.

Saying people vote for the person not the party is incorrect. I would say it is subjective. Every voter makes their selection based on their own criteria. David Colletto of Colletto polling made it very clear recently, in his research that their is a large number of Canadians who don't even know who their MP is, it is that they selected the name next to the party.

There is what theoretically should be, and how it is.

Bottom line, is Gladu's riding (and I am sure the same with the others), is many in her riding are furious.
I actually find very little to disagree with you, here.
 
Back
Top