• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
What, the persona of someone who has a PhD from one of the worlds most respected universities and was also the Governor of both the Banks of Canada and England?
That’s an appeal to authority rather than an argument about the persona itself. Credential signaling or halo effect if you prefer. But yes I can see Canadians using that as a reason for it.
 
Members of Parliament enjoy immense privilege to speak openly in the context of their Parliamentary duties. Any MP, entrusted with classified information, would be able to disclose same in Parliametary business without fear of prosecution under FISOIA. They would likely lose subsequent access, but the concept of a FISOIA ‘gag’ on utterances made in the course of parliamentary duties simply isn’t true.

*There’s currently a very narrow carve out to that for members of the National Security and Intelligence Committee of Parliamentarians who receive classified information in the course of their NSICOP duties. There’s a Supreme Court decision pending imminently on how that squares with Parliamentary privilege.
Sure but even outside of Parliament, there is nothing that stops him speaking about a topic he got a briefing on, and fully complying with FISOIA, as long as he sticks to what's in the public domain.

Maybe the Parliamentary briefings are different, but pretty much all the ones I've seen at just the confidential and secret level always spelled out what part was actually classified.

He absolutely could have gotten a briefing on foreign interference etc, and stilled talked about it in general, or taken action if necessary, as long as he didn't disclose anything. It was a fundamentally stupid arguement, and essentially a complete fabrication by someone that should know better after spending their entire career as an MP.
 
Not getting the clearance allows him to be transparent about what he knows.
....and deprives him of the insights he could garner from a more nuanced understanding of the context and background. In short, he wants to -charitably - be able to assess and explain the situation to his audience using no more information than that available to all. Less charitably, be as uninformed as the people he wants to represent.
 
The Prime Minister comes from the party with the most seats.
That’s not a given. The PM comes from the party that commands the confidence of the House of Commons. Generally that’s the party with the most seats but it doesn’t have to be.

Imagine an election that resulted in:

  • 155 CPC
  • 152 LPC
  • 20 NDP
  • 15 BQ
  • 1 GPC

The CPC form a rickety minority government, survive their first budget, but the next year the budget vote fails. The CPC leader requests the GG dissolve Parliament and call an election, but immediately thereafter the leaders of the LPC and NDP tell the GG they have a supply and confidence agreement, and the LPC will have the 172 votes necessary to demonstrate confidence. The GG could (and should) absolutely let the LPC leader do so. The LPC leader would become PM and would be allowed to form a ministry and government so long as they maintain that confidence. While unlikely and rare, this would absolutely be valid and legitimate in our system.
 
That’s not a given. The PM comes from the party that commands the confidence of the House of Commons. Generally that’s the party with the most seats but it doesn’t have to be.

Imagine an election that resulted in:

  • 155 CPC
  • 152 LPC
  • 20 NDP
  • 15 BQ
  • 1 GPC

The CPC form a rickety minority government, survive their first budget, but the next year the budget vote fails. The CPC leader requests the GG dissolve Parliament and call an election, but immediately thereafter the leaders of the LPC and NDP tell the GG they have a supply and confidence agreement, and the LPC will have the 172 votes necessary to demonstrate confidence. The GG could (and should) absolutely let the LPC leader do so. The LPC leader would become PM and would be allowed to form a ministry and government so long as they maintain that confidence. While unlikely and rare, this would absolutely be valid and legitimate in our system.
in that case, the two parties essentially become one party. Rewind to 2008. This case has never gone to full test.
 
A security clearance isn’t a requirement to lead an opposition party. Poilievre not obtaining it is a political choice, not a security failure. He’s prioritizing his role in public accountability and opposition work over participating in a classified briefing system that comes with restrictions on what he can say publicly. Not getting the clearance allows him to be transparent about what he knows.

....and deprives him of the insights he could garner from a more nuanced understanding of the context and background. In short, he wants to -charitably - be able to assess and explain the situation to his audience using no more information than that available to all. Less charitably, be as uninformed as the people he wants to represent.

Not to mention it allows him to remain ignorant of Beijing's sympathizers in his caucus. They are not as plentiful as in the LPC caucus, but they are there.
 
in that case, the two parties essentially become one party. Rewind to 2008. This case has never gone to full test.
No they don’t, no more so than they were one party a year and a half ago under the LPC minority with NDP supply and confidence. It would be exactly that just coming from a different start point.
 
No they don’t, no more so than they were one party a year and a half ago under the LPC minority with NDP supply and confidence. It would be exactly that just coming from a different start point.
What I could dig up on coalition governments (google AI, take with a grain of doubt)
Yes, a coalition government can legally form in the Canadian Parliament, though it is extremely rare at the federal level. It requires two or more parties to agree to form a government together, sharing Cabinet seats to hold a majority in the House of Commons. While possible, parties usually prefer informal agreements to a formal coalition.
  • Definition & Structure: A formal coalition requires members from different parties to sit in Cabinet together, allowing them to command the majority support needed to govern.
  • Legitimacy: Coalition governments are legally valid within Canada’s parliamentary democracy, although rarely seen in federal politics.
  • Historical Context: The only formal federal coalition was the 1917 Union Government led by Sir Robert Borden.
  • 2008–09 Case: In 2008, the Liberal Party and NDP planned a coalition supported by the Bloc Québécois to challenge a Conservative government, but it did not come to fruition.
  • Minority vs. Coalition: Many federal governments are minority governments—where the governing party has the most seats but not a majority—relying on agreements with other parties rather than sharing power in a formal coalition
Although frequently considered as a possibility during minority situations, a formal, multi-party Cabinet coalition has not existed in federal politics in over a century.

Now my thoughts. That is a rare beast indeed. Just imagine any 2 parties actually cooperating enough to achieve this? As stated, very rare.

The Justin-Jagmeet Pact was not actually a coalition government although it essentially created the same effect. In the end, look at what voters said to Jagmeet for essentially propping up the Liberals (yes there are a multitude of reasons of why but the biggest I see is this combined with scary orange man bad)

You look at the four party leaders (I assume a best case scenario for Avi and the NDP), it would be pretty fragile coalition if any two of them cooperated.

And it would still not require anyone to leave their party.
 
No they don’t, no more so than they were one party a year and a half ago under the LPC minority with NDP supply and confidence. It would be exactly that just coming from a different start point.
Im sure there would be lots of confusion which ever way the GG chose, witness King-Byng, Australia 1975
 
Who are we kidding? This Liberal party is practically a coalition, pretty soon it will be like a 1/3 conservatives if these floor crossings keep happening.
 
Who are we kidding? This Liberal party is practically a coalition, pretty soon it will be like a 1/3 conservatives if these floor crossings keep happening.
Carney wont need them after Monday so if anymore CPC's cross then they must really be fed up with Pierre
 
Gilles Duceppe endorsing a liberal candidate in tomorrow's by election? What in the world?
ghostbusters GIF
 
Carney wont need them after Monday so if anymore CPC's cross then they must really be fed up with Pierre
I would argue Carney will need as many Conservatives as he can get since he IS a Conservative that has wrenched the Steering wheel of the Liberal Bus from the socialist coalition that Trudeau and Singh ran.

What Liberal PM would deliver and actually spend 8.74 Billion in EXTRA Defence funds in any Fiscal year?
What Liberal P.M. would buy 65,402 AR -15 derived Assault Rifles?
What Liberal P.M. would reduce a womens issue Departmental budget from over 486 Million to under 80?

What the addition of recent Conservatives allows Carney to do is send Wilcox, Guibault, Joly, and other left leaning Trudeau
ministers away. Anywhere. The Blue Liberal/Progressive Conservatives in the Country are very much liking what Carney is doing
as he is an Adult with more real World executive experience than most of the World. The man is meeting the time.
The time is calling for a business like attitude and the retirement of the last 50 Year Trudeau family social Justice experiment.
 
Not to mention it allows him to remain ignorant of Beijing's sympathizers in his caucus. They are not as plentiful as in the LPC caucus, but they are there.
Exactly. Now he can remain willfully ignorant while Carney can willfully ignore it. Certainly Poilievres is the greater sin.
 
Back
Top