• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
LOTS can happen between now and then. But lets assume Carney continues on his journey. Carney definitely has a more center leaning to him so that edge Pierre had on Trudeau won't work.

The biggest threat Carney can do is get just a few big wins for Canada between now and then, and that will make Pierre's job very tough to fight for the center.

That being said, I have heard from many rumour mills, that Carney is only doing a 4 year run and then calling it a day (he is in his 60s). If that happens, then the game changes completely.
Yeah, 3 years is a long time. I'm just going off broad strokes, most Canadians are in the center, he needs to move himself and the CPC to where the people are, or hope the NDP is popular enough to allow the CPC to win vote splits while maintaining the coalition he built in 2025.

As for Carney, I assume nobody works for all that time to become the most powerful politician in the country only to give it all away. Especially if he wants to give the LPC time to get a new leader. He's not going to do that until after trump is gone, and he has a read on the new person in office.

I don't see him serving more than 2 terms, but I don't see him leaving before 2030, assuming he wins.
 
Many are just itching to see Pierre dropped and very desperate for it to happen.

It oddly seems at the forefront of a lot of people's political concerns. Some Conservatives, but way more non-Conservatives. Among the latter it certainly seems more important than the pro-Beijing sentiment that's taken hold in our MP's, and of course Carney’s wheeling and dealing to circumvent a minority government.

Do you want to win an election ? Because the CPC wont with PP at the helm. That window existed, and he failed to get his bow into the seas.

I will not put my X for the LPC. I don't think that will ever happen again. But I don't think I can put it down for the CPC with PP either.

Interesting. I know your not CPC (especially since publicly endorsed Futures party), and yet, you would like Pierre to remain right where he is at.

So YOU do not seem him as a threat to Carney's reputation I assume.

No, his intent is that PP is an easy target for the LPC and a measurable foe.
 
“Coerced”? Are you suggesting he coerced any MP to cross?

The LPC has pretty much admitted to targeting certain CPC members. Sounds like it to me.

But as I have been told by you and many others here, this is how our system works.

Happy Adam Scott GIF by Sky
 
“Coerced”? Are you suggesting he coerced any MP to cross?
Lets not insult Carneys acumen. Even Trudeau was smart enough to be out of town when his intermediary Butts was coercing JWB about SNC Lavalin.

No doubt Carneys frontmen were positioned to provide Carney plausible deniability if the deals the 'overzealous' members offering crossed any lines and reported publicly.
 
The LPC has pretty much admitted to targeting certain CPC members. Sounds like it to me.

But as I have been told by you and many others here, this is how our system works.

Happy Adam Scott GIF by Sky

Sounds to me like “targeted” in the recruitment sense- identify those who might be more amenable to the idea and focus efforts there. Nothing nefarious about that.

Any attempt to coerce an MP to cross who didn’t want to would blow up in their face spectacularly, and would highly likely be criminal.

The leader of the opposition has failed to sell himself to all of his MPs as the best way going forward and some of them threw in with the other guy. Some may want a more favourable personal political outcome, others may simply not want to ride out the end of their Paeliakentaryu career in an opposition with no power.

Crossing can work in any direction, so the good news for CPC is if they convince Canadians that they can present a better alternative, they’re equally free to attract members of other parties, break the majority, and take us to an election. But…

Given that the CPC literally hid two MPs behind a curtain to avoid accidentally voting down the budget and triggering an election, I’ve only got a little bit of sympathy for their complaining about how the current composition of the house was achieved. They and the other parties had the chance to take us to the polls and make a better case and they chose not to.
 
Sounds to me like “targeted” in the recruitment sense- identify those who might be more amenable to the idea and focus efforts there. Nothing nefarious about that.

lol Word games is the best way to observe bias.

"Targeted" vs "Coerced"

Sure. What ever sits well with you.
 
lol Word games is the best way to observe bias.

"Targeted" vs "Coerced"

Sure. What ever sits well with you.
“Coercion” means to compel someone to involuntarily do something. It implies threat or corrupt leverage that overcomes someone’s own lack of willingness. Negative incentive. “If you don’t cross the floor I’m releasing the photos of you in Tijuana in a gimp suit” is coercion.

Targeted recruiting happens all the time; we could also call it headhunting. Identify people where you have some particular reason to want them and/or to think they may be open to coming over and incentivizing it. “If you join us I want your voice at the table on northern and indigenous policy” or “if you join us I want to draw on your knowledge and credibility in oil and gas to move that portfolio forward”.

Very, very different. As I said coercion would likely border on criminal. Offering someone a job where they’ll be taken seriously and have some influence is not that.
 
“Coercion” means to compel someone to involuntarily do something. It implies threat or corrupt leverage that overcomes someone’s own lack of willingness. Negative incentive. “If you don’t cross the floor I’m releasing the photos of you in Tijuana in a gimp suit” is coercion.

Targeted recruiting happens all the time; we could also call it headhunting. Identify people where you have some particular reason to want them and/or to think they may be open to coming over and incentivizing it. “If you join us I want your voice at the table on northern and indigenous policy” or “if you join us I want to draw on your knowledge and credibility in oil and gas to move that portfolio forward”.

Very, very different. As I said coercion would likely border on criminal. Offering someone a job where they’ll be taken seriously and have some influence is not that.

Like I said, what ever sits well with you.
 
Like I said, what ever sits well with you.
Yup. I’m just going to expect anyone alleging coercion to show their work in order to be taken seriously.

I’m fine with what has happened and I’d be fine with it going the other way too. The freedom to cross the floor is the last, biggest guarantor of an MP’s independence and a check on the balance of any PMO or party leader. I personally like that in principle. I’m also good with PM Carney being given the opportunity to bash on and work to steer our economy back from whatever the hell the last decade+ was.
 
Yup. I’m just going to expect anyone alleging coercion to show their work in order to be taken seriously.

I’m fine with what has happened and I’d be fine with it going the other way too. The freedom to cross the floor is the last, biggest guarantor of an MP’s independence and a check on the balance of any PMO or party leader. I personally like that in principle. I’m also good with PM Carney being given the opportunity to bash on and work to steer our economy back from whatever the hell the last decade+ was.

Sounds good man. You do you.
 
Oh come on...lol

His whole majority government was bought, and coerced through playing backroom games
Coercion is the act of forcing or pressuring someone to do something against their will using threats, intimidation, or physical force.


Are you suggesting illegal activity to get members to cross the floor such as black mail and intimidation?
 
Coercion is the act of forcing or pressuring someone to do something against their will using threats, intimidation, or physical force.


Are you suggesting illegal activity to get members to cross the floor such as black mail and intimidation?
how about a compromise for both sides: they were bribed.
 
how about a compromise for both sides: they were bribed.
bribing a public official would would be a criminal code offense, got some evidence there? Getting someone to quit and do the same job for someone else is just poaching in the corporate world, how is this any different?
 
Back
Top