Responding to this here so I'm not blamed for yet another Army Reserve sidetrack of another thread...
Maybe a two tier Reserves/Militia for the Army is the way to go.
Reserve units where they can be located within a reasonable travel distance to existing Reg Force facilities. They are integrated directly into Reg Force units and meant to augment the Reg Force as a complete unit when mobilized. Reg Force leadership. Draw heavily on former Reg Force personnel that CT to the Reserves so they have the required training already. Supplemented by Class A recruits off the street to fulfill the lower level positions for which adequate training can be provided locally during summer school breaks, weekends at a centralized location, etc.
Militia units would be those units to distant to Reg Force resources to be able to meet the requirements of being a "Reserve" unit. Similar to the existing AR structure. Act as a source of individual augmentees (from those individuals that had the time/opportunity to get the required training levels) and some specialized skills (STAR specializations) as well as being a source of organized manpower available to the Government in time of emergencies. During mobilization the Militia units wouldn't deploy as units, but like WWI they would provide an initial base of partially trained soldiers to feed into the training system in order to fill out existing units, provide replacements, etc.
one problem I see with this a lot of former Reg force when they transfer to the Reserves, they transfer for a a few different reasons, but they fall into these groups. 1) aging out and do not want a full time army job. they come and get a promotion, then expect the Res Unit to work like the Reg force, do not understand how a part timer cannot give 110% to get the job done every day. 2) they found a new job in the civilie world and do not have the time to drop everything go running back to the former Reg Force Regiment every time the bell rings. So the odd training night and weekend exercise to earn extra money and have fun sounds good still. 3) They come in expecting to change the world of the Res Unit by showing how the Reg Force does it and then realizes the Res Unit has to beg borrow equipment from every where to just to get to the training area. The former Reg Force soldiers has some back door connections and this really helps.
10/90 gun batteries and 4 AD Regt enter the chat.
was Part of 1AD before I transfered to the HorseGuards. With the right leadership and budgets they could of made this work, they made it work for a while then, equipment issues, lack of training area big enough to operate , and personnel issues. The Area Command put more money in the budget for Res Training, the SSF Command put money in the hat, but once money dried up training ceased on all levels. ( I was educated after the Regiment was made in to mud gunners, so I admit I do not have all the facts).
If they really wanted these units to workable and operational, they needed to put in place leadership from the top down to the lowest 1 hook soldier from the Reg side of the chart, and the Res side had to step and realize the commitment they were making was serious and could be real. A good Res Unit is only as good as the lowest rank on the ladder, the CO , RSM can be great but if the soldiers under them are willing to perform, show up and do the job assigned, it looks like a circus and everyone complains.
Reg Force Leadership team needs to know what the Res Leadership can bring to the table, and they have to know the weakness of both sides.
It cannot be a dumping ground for Reg Force career managers getting rid of the troops that are on their way out anyways, or problem children. They have to be professionals and leaders to show the Res Force team how it really works. They have to work as a team, not one side doing all the work and just show up.
Planning & Ops has to be shared work load
Equipment clean up has to be shared
The Res troops when they show up have to show up as professionals too. Show up to the job they are assigned and lead, and be willing to learn at all Ranks so they can do the job if the bell is rung and it is real. Does not have to be a shooting war, but they could be tasked a real operation in Canada where troops are needed and are expected to work shoulder to shoulder.
I believe the Reg Force career managers let the 10/90 units down by giving them mostly the unwanted or unneeded soldiers, and gave in some cases officers who were poor performers to hide them . The Res unit saw the changes and did not like the changes because their way of doing things was changed. Change is never good unless both sides are going to work and make the changes a positive thing