• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal Minority Government 2025 - ???

Albertans rally for separation, saying things won’t change under Confederation


the comments here show the really the type of people supporting this. Really trying to debate 3 on Twitter, they all commonly also believed 2014 was a cia coup in Ukraine and that Russia is winning the war. So I am starting to question is AB separatists are a foreign influenced destabilization campaign
The Bloc Redneckois. I didn’t come with it but funny…
 
Elections Canada released poll by poll results from 2021 that allows for the 2021 results to be compared with the new (2025) boundaries versus the old. Had 2021 been contested with the new boundaries, the Conservatives would have had stronger results than they did by 2-3%. So it could be fairly said that, save for any affect of demographic change in the riding since 2021, the redistribution likely made it a bit more conservative and should have favoured Poilievre.

Tables from Wikipedia, with data sourced from Elections Canada:

View attachment 93103
Yeah I remember reading or hearing something about that. The new boundaries were supposed to make it stronger for him. Funny how the choices we make can completely change things.
 
Easterners make stuff like this, then wonder where western separatism comes from...

The casual bigotry of Easterners toward the West is always fascinating to me, as a Maritimer disparaged by both groups.

Wait until you hear one municipality diss another, right next door for the past 100 years, municipality.

It's one of those human things, unfortunately...

 
In my youth in the aftermath of the second Quebec referendum, I toyed with the idea of BC independence for about a nanosecond. Mostly from a throwaway line I read in a book I read about the national unity question where the authors stated that the only province that had the economic ability to go it alone was BC. It didn’t take long for me to figure out that BC would go from being a part of one of the wealthiest, most influential countries in the world, to New Zealand. Don’t get me wrong, NZ is great. But their Air Force doesn’t have fighter jets. An independent BC would have to pay for all the trappings of being a state including a credible military, foreign service with embassies, a national security apparatus, etc. These things aren’t cheap. Taxes will have to go up. There goes any economic advantage you thought you had over neighbouring jurisdictions.

As for Alberta and/ or Saskatchewan becoming an economic powerhouse once the chains are broken from Ottawa, I don’t think so. A landlocked country of 4 million people with a single industry dependent on world exports is not ideal. And swapping imperial overlords in Ottawa for imperial overlords in Washington is laughable. Alberta would go from being the wealthiest province in the country with 4 million out of 40 million people to Oklahoma, if the Yanks grace you with statehood which is not guaranteed. You would more likely become a territory like Puerto Rico with no voting rights or representation.

Much of this rhetoric is being boosted by Russia, China and Iran, because this only benefits our enemies.
 
In my youth in the aftermath of the second Quebec referendum, I toyed with the idea of BC independence for about a nanosecond. Mostly from a throwaway line I read in a book I read about the national unity question where the authors stated that the only province that had the economic ability to go it alone was BC. It didn’t take long for me to figure out that BC would go from being a part of one of the wealthiest, most influential countries in the world, to New Zealand. Don’t get me wrong, NZ is great. But their Air Force doesn’t have fighter jets. An independent BC would have to pay for all the trappings of being a state including a credible military, foreign service with embassies, a national security apparatus, etc. These things aren’t cheap. Taxes will have to go up. There goes any economic advantage you thought you had over neighbouring jurisdictions.

As for Alberta and/ or Saskatchewan becoming an economic powerhouse once the chains are broken from Ottawa, I don’t think so. A landlocked country of 4 million people with a single industry dependent on world exports is not ideal. And swapping imperial overlords in Ottawa for imperial overlords in Washington is laughable. Alberta would go from being the wealthiest province in the country with 4 million out of 40 million people to Oklahoma, if the Yanks grace you with statehood which is not guaranteed. You would more likely become a territory like Puerto Rico with no voting rights or representation.

Much of this rhetoric is being boosted by Russia, China and Iran, because this only benefits our enemies.

Meanwhile, the Netherlands - 41,865 km² vs. Vancouver Island - 32,100 km²

Growth in gross domestic product (GDP) per capita, in real terms (after inflation) at purchasing power parity, between 2014 and 2024


1746324206301.png

How big is the Dutch economy?​

The size of the Dutch economy is measured in terms of its gross domestic product (GDP), which surpassed 1 trillion euros in 2023. GDP is the sum of all the goods and services produced in a country in one year. The Dutch economy is about four times larger than the Portuguese economy, for example, and almost twice the size of the Belgian economy. Meanwhile, the German economy is about four times the size of the Dutch economy.

 
Albertans rally for separation, saying things won’t change under Confederation


the comments here show the really the type of people supporting this. Really trying to debate 3 on Twitter, they all commonly also believed 2014 was a cia coup in Ukraine and that Russia is winning the war. So I am starting to question is AB separatists are a foreign influenced destabilization campaign
That was never in question.
 
That was never in question.
The CIA for one has a long history of secretly financing the destabilization of other countries, especially in Latin America. I wouldn’t be surprised at all if they were in Alberta right now giving financial and strategic support to some of the separatist leaders.
 
That's unfair. Carney was a public figure with a small p political presence in both Canada and in the UK before he entered the big P Political arena.

Typical of Canada, we were very proud of him .... right until the point he decided to enter the political arena ;)
 
Based on the 2021 poll results redistributed, with no changes he would have been marginally ahead in 2025 with the new boundaries.
And a big suburban chunk of his former riding went to Ottawa South. McGuinty saw an increase of 19% vote share this time over the last. So it is possible that a significant portion of that may have voted against PP if the riding had stayed as it was.
 
Back
Top