• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

  • Thread starter Thread starter Deleted member 37876
  • Start date Start date
PP has been better on that front recently, but if they let Mr Hoekstra talk about how everything wrong with the Canada USA relationship is due to Canada, they had better tell him where he can stick it.

If they passively just let him run his mouth and don't stand up for Canada, they deserve the maple maga moniker.

Are you holding Liberals to the same standard as Conservatives here?
 
It's interesting that your base assumption is that conservatives are inherently likely to not counter anti-Canadian messaging, and are hoping that they will overcome their inherent anti-Canadian nature to make arguments for Canada...
I believe that people who invite Pete Hoekstra to a political event in Canada, and whose invitation he accepts, regardless of their political stripe, bear the onus of convincing me that they will be sufficiently critical of and challenging towards his positions as his country’s representative in Canada. I’m perfectly prepared to be convinced of that and it wouldn’t be difficult. Simple, civil, firm pushback on the trade war positions.
 
Maple MAGA allegations are never going to go away I guess.

Certainly making for a very easy canvas to paint.

I seriously laugh every time I hear the term "Maple MAGA" . To me, it is a contradictions of terms, someone accusing someone of being for a strong Canada and at the same time hoping for a strong USA., unable to make up their mind which of the two to make great.
 
I seriously laugh every time I hear the term "Maple MAGA" . To me, it is a contradictions of terms, someone accusing someone of being for a strong Canada and at the same time hoping for a strong USA., unable to make up their mind which of the two to make great.
I wish it were that simple.

When i hear maple maga, its a Canadian who hopes for a strong America with zero regard for what is good for Canada. Or worse yet, actively cheering American because its run by the side of the political aisle they are on while detesting Canada because its run by the other side of the aisle that they dont support.

There are some for example, who look at the tariffs placed on Canada because of "fentanyl and illegal immigration" and said, yeah, america is right, we deserve this. Meanwhile every country on earth is being hit with tariffs, and the reasons of fentanyl and illegal immigration dont hold water, nor could we reduce it to numbers that would ever remove the tariffs. Clearly that has america in the wrong but to maple maga types Canada is still somehow in the wrong.

And you may think I'm joking but Pierre poilievre during the initial tariff period is on record disparaging Canada and calling for the military to be deployed to the border to cut down on illegal immigration and fentanyl trafficking, giving legitimacy to the utterly false claims by the USA.

Now Pierre Poilievre has been much improved in this regard, even during the Joe rogan show, but based on his pass comments, he really needed to be consistent in that regard, and inviting Pete Hoekstra to run his mouth while not saying anything in defense of Canada would be a very bad look. Either dont invite him if you dont want to push back on any ridiculousness he might say, or invite him but be fully prepared to push back on what he might say. Failure to do so and the maple maga moniker resurfaces and its their own damn fault.
 
I wish it were that simple.


At this point it’s a no win label. If Poilievre pushes back on the US he’s accused of playing politics for votes. If he engages with Americans or even acknowledges issues like border security, he’s Maple MAGA. That’s framing where the outcome is predetermined and whatever he does just gets slotted into it.

No other Politican save Ford stood up to Hoekstra. By your admission if Poilievre doesn't jump down his throat then he's clearly Maple MAGA.
 
At this point it’s a no win label. If Poilievre pushes back on the US he’s accused of playing politics for votes.
I am so sick of this. Who said this? Where are they? Anyone here? I didn't say jack when ford stood up to Pete. Not a damn word. I didnt have a bad thing to say about Pierre standing up to the USA in the Joe rogan experience. So who are these mythical people who would accuse Pierre Poilievre of playing politics for votes?

I'll say this right now, if Pete says something stupid and Pierre pushes back and tells him to pound sand, I'm grabbing my red and while maple leaf hat and standing right beside him screaming hell ya
If he engages with Americans or even acknowledges issues like border security, he’s Maple MAGA. That’s framing where the outcome is predetermined and whatever he does just gets slotted into it.
If hes giving weight to false american narratives hes maple maga.

If he want to talk the border, be my guest. If he wants to talk the border saying Canadian failings justify american tariffs, sorry, youre maple maga eh.
No other Politican save Ford stood up to Hoekstra. By your admission if Poilievre doesn't jump down his throat then he's clearly Maple MAGA.
The solution was simple. Dont invite him.
 
Last edited by a moderator:
I wish it were that simple.

When i hear maple maga, its a Canadian who hopes for a strong America with zero regard for what is good for Canada. Or worse yet, actively cheering American because its run by the side of the political aisle they are on while detesting Canada because its run by the other side of the aisle that they dont support.

There are some for example, who look at the tariffs placed on Canada because of "fentanyl and illegal immigration" and said, yeah, america is right, we deserve this. Meanwhile every country on earth is being hit with tariffs, and the reasons of fentanyl and illegal immigration dont hold water, nor could we reduce it to numbers that would ever remove the tariffs. Clearly that has america in the wrong but to maple maga types Canada is still somehow in the wrong.

And you may think I'm joking but Pierre poilievre during the initial tariff period is on record disparaging Canada and calling for the military to be deployed to the border to cut down on illegal immigration and fentanyl trafficking, giving legitimacy to the utterly false claims by the USA.

Now Pierre Poilievre has been much improved in this regard, even during the Joe rogan show, but based on his pass comments, he really needed to be consistent in that regard, and inviting Pete Hoekstra to run his mouth while not saying anything in defense of Canada would be a very bad look. Either dont invite him if you dont want to push back on any ridiculousness he might say, or invite him but be fully prepared to push back on what he might say. Failure to do so and the maple maga moniker resurfaces and its their own damn fault.

I still think that the persons using that phrase are very, very confused. There are several terms that the Left like to throw around in that may sound great in sound bites; but in reality are nonsensical.
 
How many parliamentary committees did the Liberals force to move "in camera" (the latin term for in chambers).

Why was their a sudden need for so much secrecy? What are they hiding? Where is the accountability and transparency?

This will burn Carney in the long run for sure and it may hurt him sooner. 2 by elections coming soon.
 
I am so sick of this. Who said this? Where are they? Anyone here? I didn't say jack when ford stood up to Pete. Not a damn word. I didnt have a bad thing to say about Pierre standing up to the USA in the Joe rogan experience. So who are these mythical people who would accuse Pierre Poilievre of playing politics for votes?

This is how the discourse tends to go in general. You’ll see it across media commentary, partisan spaces, and online discussion. The same pattern applies regardless of party. In Poilievres case, everything is Maple MAGA, including him going on Joe Rogan.


If hes giving weight to false americans narratives hes maple maga

That’s exactly the problem. It turns into a moving definition. Any engagement with US claims can be (and often are) framed as “giving weight,” even when it’s just acknowledging or responding to them. At that point the label stops describing a real position and just becomes a way to discredit whoever you already disagree with. I said it before, it's become a lazy phrase.

If he want to talk the border, be my guest. If he wants to talk the border saying Canadian failings justify american tariffs, sorry, youre maple maga eh.

Has Poilievre said anything close to Canadian failings justify American tariffs?


The solution was simple. Dont invite him.

Probably should get rid of Smith, Harris, Campbell, Norquist, and any other Americam too just to be safe.
 
This will burn Carney in the long run for sure and it may hurt him sooner. 2 by elections coming soon.
I'm sure Canadians, with everything going on in Canada and the world are following with baited breath the goings on of parliamentary committees.

But I do respect your change in tact, from a election within a year predictions to the more muted trouble with by elections predictions
 
What makes democracy weak? Not following politicians closely and paying attention. Not wanting to be bothered with policies and decisions.

What keeps a democracy strong? Paying close attention to our political leaders, what they say, what they do and what they are pushing. Staying politically involved.

So yes, more than a few of us follow parliamentary committees closely. If CBC showed even 10 minutes of parliamentary committee and what happens, I think the Liberals would suffer a real blow.

Sunshine is the cure for piss poor and bad politicians. How long will the Carney honeymoon last? 2 by elections coming.
 
Has Poilievre said anything close to Canadian failings justify American tariffs?
No, but he did say that our border with the Americans is broken, pointing to a non existent drug smuggling and illegal immigration problems and is on recoded saying he wanted to deploy the CAF to the border.

Did he come flat out and say trumps tariffs are justified? No. But he did give weight to the nonsensical idea that we were somehow the problem, an idea, in hindsight, that has aged very poorly.
 
???? And how do you arrive at that? Please explain.
You dont like the term maple maga. You find it nonsensical.

Quisling is a long established term for a similar phenomenon, is that better or worse than maple maga in your estimation?
 
Back
Top