Liberal (Minority/Majority) Government 2025 - ???

[Czech_pivo]

You can see the contrast in approaches and results.

Trudeau was open communication, trust people to do their job and gave them a thousand chances if they came up short.

Carney yelling that he needs solutions, and for MPs to do their jobs.

Weird dichotomy that i think Carney wont last as long as Trudeau but get a lot more done while he's PM.

Trudeau was a pathetic leader - full stop.
Carney is an adult compared to Trudeau. He yells - so the F&ck what. How much was actually achieved under Trudeau? Carney is not there to hold your hand and nod sympathetically that you’re stressed and your feelings are hurt. MPs and Cabinet Ministers male massive amounts of money compared to 90+% of the rest of CDN society- the expectation is that you are capable, require minimum direction and guidance and should be a ‘doer’ right from the get go.
That is how the CEO of a Fortune 500 company surrounds themselves with their leadership team and expects 125% effort all the time - day in and day out. It’s certainly what I expect of my PM, my Federal Government and my MP.

 

[Jarnhamar]

. He yells - so the F&ck what. How much was actually achieved under Trudeau? Carney is not there to hold your hand and nod sympathetically that you’re stressed and your feelings are hurt.

Is Poilievre held to the same standard as Carney here?

 

[Brad Sallows]

Is Poilievre held to the same standard as Carney here?

Conservative yellers are bullies.

 

[Altair]

Trudeau was a pathetic leader - full stop.
Carney is an adult compared to Trudeau. He yells - so the F&ck what. How much was actually achieved under Trudeau? Carney is not there to hold your hand and nod sympathetically that you’re stressed and your feelings are hurt. MPs and Cabinet Ministers male massive amounts of money compared to 90+% of the rest of CDN society- the expectation is that you are capable, require minimum direction and guidance and should be a ‘doer’ right from the get go.
That is how the CEO of a Fortune 500 company surrounds themselves with their leadership team and expects 125% effort all the time - day in and day out. It’s certainly what I expect of my PM, my Federal Government and my MP.

Trudeau lasted almost 10 years.

Carney will face a caucus revolt the second the LPC dip below the CPC in the polls.

I'm not going to say which approach is more effective, what I will say is Carney will rub a lot of MPs the wrong way in contrast to Trudeau who held his caucus together until the very end.

 

[Czech_pivo]

Is Poilievre held to the same standard as Carney here?

Why? Does PP ‘yell’ at his Shadow Ministers for not doing their job?

 

[Altair]

I kind of agree with your view point. The Liberals needed him badly to save their party...but are not willing to pay the true price of having a no nonsense PM in charge.

The LPC are very happy that they are where they are. They were facing a wipeout.

But if Carney is yelling at MPs and instituting a top down kind of approach when MPs are used to the bottom up approach Trudeau put in place, it wont take long for the knives to come out if Carney isn't in as secure a position.

 

[Czech_pivo]

Trudeau lasted almost 10 years.

Carney will face a caucus revolt the second the LPC dip below the CPC in the polls.

I'm not going to say which approach is more effective, what I will say is Carney will rub a lot of MPs the wrong way in contrast to Trudeau who held his caucus together until the very end.

He held his caucus together because his bloody standards and expectations were so incredibly low.
Why rock the boat when your boss expects so little of you?

 

[Altair]

He held his caucus together because his bloody standards and expectations were so incredibly low.
Why rock the boat when your boss expects so little of you?

You're not wrong.

Again, I just think Carney will run through the goodwill of his caucus a heck of a lot faster than Trudeau did.

 

[Czech_pivo]

You're not wrong.

Again, I just think Carney will run through the goodwill of his caucus a heck of a lot faster than Trudeau did.

Possible - but if so it will be the lowly incompetent jealous ones left behind who band together because they don’t have the intelligence or the backbone to move on their own.

Always fear the incompetent ones who are too stupid to know that they are.

 

[YZT580]

Trudeau lasted almost 10 years.

Carney will face a caucus revolt the second the LPC dip below the CPC in the polls.

I'm not going to say which approach is more effective, what I will say is Carney will rub a lot of MPs the wrong way in contrast to Trudeau who held his caucus together until the very end.

Trudeau lasted the last 6 because he had the NDP in bed with him and all of them were addicted to power. When you have no ethical standard to live by it is easy to chose "what's in it for me" instead of following Kennedy's famous line. 'Ask not what your country can do for you but rather what can I do for my country' or words to that effect.

 

[brihard]

Is Poilievre held to the same standard as Carney here?

Speaking for myself, if Poilievre sternly expects expects his people to show up on time, look professional, and know their files, and is a bit of a dick to those who fail to- fine with me.

 

[Good2Golf]

Again, I just think Carney will run through the goodwill of his caucus a heck of a lot faster than Trudeau did.

If the LPC wants to return to the ways of the next Trudeau-ite, they will have no one to blame when PPnor his successor form the next government. PP could only be so fortunate…hopefully he has a sequel plan when Carney moves in by whatever methodology he chooses when his time comes.

 

[CBH99]

I kind of agree with your view point. The Liberals needed him badly to save their party...but are not willing to pay the true price of having a no nonsense PM in charge.

What would be the true price of us having a LPC no-nonsense PM...???

Carney seems to be a fairly non-nonsense PM so far.

I just happen to violently disagree with where he thinks this is all going. The end state for Canada once Carney leaves I don't think will be all that different from when Justin was in charge


But who knows. He certainly seems to have momentum behind things that we didn't before, so I'm trying to stay upbeat

 

[daftandbarmy]

What would be the true price of us having a LPC no-nonsense PM...???

Carney seems to be a fairly non-nonsense PM so far.

I just happen to violently disagree with where he thinks this is all going. The end state for Canada once Carney leaves I don't think will be all that different from when Justin was in charge


But who knows. He certainly seems to have momentum behind things that we didn't before, so I'm trying to stay upbeat

I kinda feel like a shipwrecked crew member in a liferaft thinking I'm doing great in the calm seas ....

... soon to discover I'm in the eye of a hurricane

 

[RangerRay]

Green Party has started it's leadership race, Elizabeth May will stepping down in November upon it's conclusion.

Unless of course they have to bring her back again.

Green Party of Canada launches leadership race – Green Party Of Canada

www.greenparty.ca

Are the Liberals finally going to make her a senator?

A politician expecting results and expressing that vocally? Refreshing honestly.

I’m with Gerson on this: this makes me like him more, taking the Trudeau retreads to the the woodshed.

I disagree that Trudeau was “collaborative” or “bottom up”. There is plenty of reporting that everything came out of the PMO, cabinet and caucus were given their marching orders from the PMO, Telford and Butts were ruthless gatekeepers and scolded anyone who dared to have and independent thought. They did, however, seem to tolerate incompetence, sloth and nonperformance in cabinet, because nothing was expected of them.

Ii think May would prefer a Dodge Viper.

Jesus, doesn’t she know how much dead dinosaur juice that thing burns up?

 

[ArmyRick]

Mark Carney is the best damn conservative to ever lead the Liberals. I think when he was entering politics, he turned down the wrong hallway and accidently took over the Liberals when he really should be in charge of the Conservatives.

Seriously though, the LPC backbenchers had better decide and real fast, they are in or they are out. The Trudeau brand is gone, period. As Brian Liley recently pointed out, its not good to be high in the polls and have "hidden" MPs in your party backstabbing you, that normally happens when your low in the polls.

 

[Altair]

Mark Carney is the best damn conservative to ever lead the Liberals. I think when he was entering politics, he turned down the wrong hallway and accidently took over the Liberals when he really should be in charge of the Conservatives.

The CPC moved to the right. Carney would never have beaten PP in a leadership contest.

Seriously though, the LPC backbenchers had better decided and real fast, they are in or they are out. The Trudeau brand is gone, period. As Brian Liley recently pointed out, its not good to be high in the polls and have "hidden" MPs in your party backstabbing you, that normally happens when your low in the polls.

Carney will be fine in a majority situation.


Next election if hes in a minority by enough that he cannot lure enough CPC and NDP MPs over, he's cooked.

 

[Good2Golf]

The Trudeau brand is gone, period.

He still has a few more to help on to other careers…

 

[Czech_pivo]

Mark Carney is the best damn conservative to ever lead the Liberals. I think when he was entering politics, he turned down the wrong hallway and accidently took over the Liberals when he really should be in charge of the Conservatives.

Seriously though, the LPC backbenchers had better decide and real fast, they are in or they are out. The Trudeau brand is gone, period. As Brian Liley recently pointed out, its not good to be high in the polls and have "hidden" MPs in your party backstabbing you, that normally happens when your low in the polls.

I suspect that there are a number of MP’s under Carney who were Cabinet Ministers under Trudeau who are pissed that they are on the outside now - Erskine was a perfect example, I suspect my MP, K Gould is another. Heck she was 1 of the 3 leadership candidates and he still has passed her over for the last 15 months to be a Minister…..to me, that says a lot about her capabilities….