• Thanks for stopping by. Logging in to a registered account will remove all generic ads. Please reach out with any questions or concerns.

Reconstitution

There are lies, damn lies, and statistics.

CAF recruiting numbers tend to fall into the middle category.

Philosophical question: is someone an applicant when they sign a paper saying they are interested? Or should they only be counted as an applicant once they provide the required supporting documents? Which definition you choose has major implications for how you need to interpret the data.
We used to define them as prospects vs applicants.
 
  • Like
Reactions: ueo
I suspect a lot of police, and other similar agencies, offloaded testing like PT

Where I worked, candidates must sucessfully complete The Ottawa Paramedic Physical Ability Test (OPPAT) evaluation before their application can move forward in the recruiting process.

Successful OPPAT evaluation.
Completed prior to Stage 3 (dated within 6 months of driving date); exempt if currently employed with an Ontario municipal ambulance service


Saw the video. Looks like a "no fail" physical ability test.

Legally defensible

is legally defensible, wherein the OPPAT was developed based on the best practice template emerging from the seminal 1999 Meiorin Supreme Court Case

Regarding that Supreme Court case,

Supreme Court orders female firefighter rehired​








 
Where I worked, candidates must sucessfully complete The Ottawa Paramedic Physical Ability Test (OPPAT) evaluation before their application can move forward in the recruiting process.




Saw the video. Looks like a "no fail" physical ability test.





Regarding that Supreme Court case,

Supreme Court orders female firefighter rehired​



Makes sense, it is a job that requires a minimum level of fitness.

The problem isn't that there is a test, it's the way the testing is done for some jobs.

Making a person pay, just to apply to maybe get a job, is a great way to encourage people to look elsewhere. That made sense at one time, we are likely a decade or so past the point that it made sense though.
 
Making a person pay, just to apply to maybe get a job, is a great way to encourage people to look elsewhere.

Right.

It is not cheap. To maybe get a job.

( Even if you are accepted into the program, and graduate, there is no guarantee of a job offer from a municipality in Ontario. )

My old college ( Humber ) charges,

Semester 1 $1,992.62

Semester 2 $1,992.62

Semester 3 $3,035.38

Semester 4 $1,992.62

Total: $9,013.24

Additional Costs:

$1,000 - uniforms and other medical supplies;

$800 - books;

$640 - driver education fee (for Year 2);

$400 - CEPCP Educational Certification fee for students placed with York Region.

Total: $2,840.00













[COLOR=rgba(40, 40, 40, 0.9)]

[COLOR=rgba(40, 40, 40, 0.9)]​

[/COLOR][/COLOR]
 
FWIW... Col Redman (retd).

He's a really good speaker IMHO...

Unfit for Duty: It is Time to Rebuild the Canadian Armed Forces​


Decades of government neglect and underfunding have left the Canadian Armed Forces a depleted, demoralized and nearly shattered force. The country is increasingly being ignored or even shunned by its traditional allies at a time when an increasingly dangerous world poses escalating national security risks. Canada must urgently rethink and rebuild its military to meet these challenges, safeguard its sovereignty and fulfill its obligations on the world stage, writes David Redman. In this clear-eyed assessment, the CAF veteran and crisis management expert sets out a pathway to renewal, explaining what the armed forces need to rebuild and how Canada’s political leaders – if they have the will and the intelligence – can make it happen.



 
Last edited:
Add to the above:


A honest assessment about the state of the Canadian Armed Forces

 
The single greatest problem that His Majesty's Canadian Armed Forces must overcome is a peninsula in Kingston.

Honestly, I no longer think this is the case. RMC is an expensive, third-rate university that cosplays as a military college. The product received since COVID is essentially a DEO with some extea steps.

I think out biggest problem now is that the Ottawa integration of CAF into DND has led to an almost Animal Farm-esque confusion of who is pig (CAF) and who is man (DND).

If most of our senior leaders are thinking about what is best for the DM/MND, they're no longer working for the CAF's best interests.

If its anything, Reconstitution is failing because of the "Defence Team" concept.
 
Honestly, I no longer think this is the case. RMC is an expensive, third-rate university that cosplays as a military college. The product received since COVID is essentially a DEO with some extea steps.

I think out biggest problem now is that the Ottawa integration of CAF into DND has led to an almost Animal Farm-esque confusion of who is pig (CAF) and who is man (DND).

If most of our senior leaders are thinking about what is best for the DM/MND, they're no longer working for the CAF's best interests.

If its anything, Reconstitution is failing because of the "Defence Team" concept.

That 'third-rate university that cosplays as a military college" produces a disproportionate amount of the senior leadership of the CAF. In private industry, if one supplier continually provides parts that fail, you change suppliers.

If the CAF's institutional leadership is failing, then we need to see how we develop that leadership. RMC is one nexus; CFC and the lack of a valid selection model for JCSP and NSP is another.
 
A significant portion of 60 Moodie's problems start on the peninsula.

Two birds, one stone.
Meh.

You could shut down RMC tomorrow and that won’t change the disdain for, not the influence over, that the Four Corners have on DND/CAF. I think the ‘improvement’ you believe would take place, never would.
 
And likely like a lot of emergency services does not have an annual qualification. Do it once then that is it. Maybe a few times for promotions maybe?

If you worked 9-1-1 operations 40 hours a week, you were considered fit for duty.

If you were away from 9-1-1 operations for longer than three months, you had to go through a medical and fitness evaluation.

Also, classroom refresher training. Followed by on the street preceptorship with a Field Training Officer ( FTO ).

Depending on one's POV, some might have returned to 9-1-1 operations just before their three months was up to avoid the above?

It was pretty much a no-fail. Although, perhaps some did not want to pass? 🤷‍♂️

There was no physical evaluation for promotion, as lifting and carrying people was not part of their job description.
 
Back
Top