Replacing the Subs

[Colin Parkinson]

Also TKMS is upping their "Canadian component game"

TKMS and Marmen sign strategic Teaming Agreement to support production of 212CD submarine segments in Canada

Press Release

noahscornerofrandomstuff.substack.com

 

[Rainbow1910]

Also TKMS is upping their "Canadian component game"

TKMS and Marmen sign strategic Teaming Agreement to support production of 212CD submarine segments in Canada

Press Release

noahscornerofrandomstuff.substack.com

While it definitely is a "feel good" moment for Canadians and will definitely make some politicians happy, I have concerns about the ability of Canadian companies to meet the incredibly high bar required for producing sections of basically one of the worlds most advanced non-nuclear submarines. There is very miniscule margin for error here, with potentially disastrous consequences and little room to learn.

 

[Czech_pivo]

While it definitely is a "feel good" moment for Canadians and will definitely make some politicians happy, I have concerns about the ability of Canadian companies to meet the incredibly high bar required for producing sections of basically one of the worlds most advanced non-nuclear submarines. There is very miniscule margin for error here, with potentially disastrous consequences and little room to learn.

Any CDN manufacturing company that produces for MDA should be seriously looking at gaining some of the sub contracts that might come available. Those are the companies that understand the design/quality levels that you are referring to.

 

[Rainbow1910]

Any CDN manufacturing company that produces for MDA should be seriously looking at gaining some of the sub contracts that might come available. Those are the companies that understand the design/quality levels that you are referring to.

You will have to excuse my skepticism given the widespread incompetence within the Canadian shipbuilding industry, that companies won't totally bungle this sort of contract given how short of a metaphorical runway exists for them.

 

[Czech_pivo]

You will have to excuse my skepticism given the widespread incompetence within the Canadian shipbuilding industry, that companies won't totally bungle this sort of contract given how short of a metaphorical runway exists for them.

MDA is MDA Space, the company that produces equipment for NASA, the Canadian Space Agency, builds satellites, etc. I don't really see them or the companies that build for them, dropping the ball on something if they chose to enter the contract world in teaming up with Hanwha or TKMS to help build our subs.

 

[Rainbow1910]

MDA is MDA Space, the company that produces equipment for NASA, the Canadian Space Agency, builds satellites, etc. I don't really see them or the companies that build for them, dropping the ball on something if they chose to enter the contract world in teaming up with Hanwha or TKMS to help build our subs.

And submarines are some of the most complex pieces of equipment ever produced by mankind even compared to what you mention, I'll withhold my confidence until they can prove in this context able.

 

[Retired AF Guy]

While it definitely is a "feel good" moment for Canadians and will definitely make some politicians happy, I have concerns about the ability of Canadian companies to meet the incredibly high bar required for producing sections of basically one of the worlds most advanced non-nuclear submarines. There is very miniscule margin for error here, with potentially disastrous consequences and little room to learn.

At the end of the article Noah has some comments including this snippet, "This choice is actually something that had been pushed by the Federal government. I believe it was either Champagne or Joly who pushed for, at least, module production to take place in Canada. Marmen was one of the companies they were specifically pushing."

 

[Czech_pivo]

At the end of the article Noah has some comments including this snippet, "This choice is actually something that had been pushed by the Federal government. I believe it was either Champagne or Joly who pushed for, at least, module production to take place in Canada. Marmen was one of the companies they were specifically pushing."

From their website